subprime mess does affect manhattan - NYT
Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
Todays NYT article about subprimes affects on Manhattan a doctor making 700K a year needed a 0 down 800k-1MM loan for condo at Atlier. Could not get 0 down and settled for a 600k studio instead.. WTF! http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/01/realestate/01cov.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1 I guess those new condos in Manhattan really did accept 0 downs! very interesting to watch now...
We, Manhattanites, live in a bubble wallpapered with greenbacks, nothing can make our market go down, our bubble will allways go up, up and away
what kind of person making $700K cant save enough for a downpayment? Ridiculous -- doesn't deserve any mortgage!
Umm ok..
1) Why is it bad exactly if you're not allowed to put 0% down? That just means you have more qualified, stable and REAL buyers. And further sipports the arguement of "You can't buy with 0% down in manhattan".
2) If you READ, it says he put 10% down for the 600k. After a couple years, he could feasibly (and probably will) buy that apt in cash. The problem for him is that he has no cash on hand... which is a problem for most people.
3) The whole problem with the bubble talk is I just keep hearing more about ppl who want to buy in NYC and can't... that's a lot of demand. I don't hear about rows and lines of condos with for sale signs that have no buyers because there are no jobs (florida).
#3, he's a surgeon... probably just got out of school and has a lot of debt already. Just wait a few years though, he'll be buying a bigger place while others are still screaming "prices can't keep going up".
0% down is subprime and with 80% of the buildings in NYC being coop with a minimum of 20% down--this is what protects Manhattan unlike the suburbs that are seeing foreclosures. That will drag the prices down. I agree with comment #2, someone making $700,000 a year should be able to afford the down payment.I also agree with comment #4--I don't see a glut of inventory with no buyers, properties are selling at a healthy pace.
that surgeon making $700K a year is exaggerated! The average salary of a surgeon in Hawaii makes $300K/yr. Unless he's a plastic surgeon, that's a different story... I am a surgeon so it doesn't make any sense!!! If he makes $700K per year, he can save up $30K per month after taxes and medical malpractice insurance. He could have saved up for 3 months and buy that apartment at the Atelier! And of course, there's alot of doctors in Hawaii and the pay sucks compared to elsewhere in the US. Lastly, if he makes that much, why does he need 100% financing unless he's flat broke or just graduated from his residency program making $40K per year and paying off $200K in student loans from medical school?
If it doesn't make sense, it's usually not true!
Obviously he must have just graduated from residency if he's only got 60k downpayment. Maybe he paid off his debt first. Relax. If you're a surgeon, you know he can specialize further and get more money.
I'm amused at #1's desparate attempts to drop the market. You're trying to compare a traditional subprime borrower to a 700k surgeon. That's just hilarious.
i believe the article states he has two other properties in Hawaii. so he's probably a bit stretched and would of rather not use his last cash for the down payment. I'm sure he'll get the unit and eventually get a bigger one when the time is right.
LOL even better a surgeon making 700k with two properties in hawaii... wow. Renters really must be getting desparate.
no employers or private practitioners just graduated from residency makes $700K per year. properties in hawai'i are cheaper than new york.
They wanted the apartment in Manhattan because their eight year old son has a modeling contract. If he's a surgeon in Hawaii he also has overhead there not to mention flying back & forth between the 2 cities. At least temporarily the lenders are not giving you enough rope to hang yourself.
This post is to show that because lending is getting tight, buyers are stepping back and buying less thus driving demand in some segments of the market...
How come nobody engages in doctor's bashing at the same level they engage in teacher's bashing? Medical students are usually teacher's pets.
The google tells me the good doctor is a general and colorectal surgeon. I'm a doc as well and kinda agree with #7 that 700K+ sounds pretty unlikely for a general surgeon in Hawaii (thought quite likely for an orthopod or plastics guy or other sub-specialist).
And it's rather peculiar for a doc to broadcast his income to the New York Times.
It's also somewhat strange to have your 8 your old kid go off to New York to become...a child model?! And the wife has a vaguely early Jocelyn Wildenstein look.
Something seriously fishy at this luau.
The Hawaiian plastic surgeon is not the only example in this article [Lots and lots of plastic surgery in Hawai'i; I got a relative who's a doctor in Maui]. The point of the article is that a variety of people are having more trouble getting financing than they would have 6 months ago. It's supply and demand, and this affects the demand part--the number of buyers who are able to get financing, or who will go through the hassle/investigation at whatever price point. I'm a buyer who is paying all cash (when I find the place), and a broker told me this will give me an advantage vis a vis buyers who have to arrange mortgages. I'll let y'all know if he's right.
to #17. At this moment in time, I don't think you'll have much advantage. However if lending standards simply go back pre-2004 levels you'll have much more negotiating power.
i am writing this as a fellow physician who is also searching for a home in nyc.
i commend dr. au's decision to broadcast his financial info. dr. au is a general surgeon practicing in a local hospital in o'ahu. he is well known as a very respectable surgeon and currently is the chair of the only medical school in hawai'i - john a burns school of medicine. he also sits in the advisory board of the the hawaii breast cancer division of the american cancer society.
Although his financial information may or may not be exaggerated, it may reflect financial income from other resources besides being a physician. I seriously doubt dr. au will give up his position in hawaii to move to nyc. he may be purchasing a home to decrease the costs of a hotel room for his wife and child while they travel back and forth from hawaii and ny.
i wish dr au and his family the best.
#18 I disagree. #17 will have a huge advantage if he is paying all cash as it is a much easier and cleaner deal ESPECIALLY with what is going on in the mortgage industry. He may even be able to come in a little lower than someone who needs to finance. A seller will always take a cash deal over financing unless there is a significant difference in offers.
His wife could work and have income and he could have other income generating assets...
hah! that's highly unlikely for a $700K husband to have his wife work... that would tarnish his reputation unless it is her own will wanting to work
These news articled never tell you the WHOLE story...lots of details/info is needed to secure a mortgage so we don't know the real story with Dr. Au. Maybe he was expecting to finance 100%...maybe his credit isn't as strong as one would think it would be for a doctor making $700k. Who knows?
Actually those details are given in the story for those who read. There were some credit related issues and he wanted to have 0% financing using other property in Hawaii as collateral. All you have to do is READ.
#24, #25 here - I DID read the article...my point is that people are making assumptions.... having worked in journalism I know that key details are often omitted from stories or sometimes the sources (ie Dr. Au) don't tell the whole story.