Skip Navigation

How many Old Timers On This Board?

Started by Bonzo
over 19 years ago
Posts: 380
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
..... who bought in the 70s, 80,s or 90s? Your reaction to today's prices? Do you think you would have still bought that 4 or 5 million townhome today, that you paid 500K for in 1985? If you were a doctor or lawyer back then has your income kept up to be able to afford it? What would you advise the young of today with prices at their historical peaks? If it is possible to put yourself in their shoes (the young) would you still be clamoring to buy in the city immediately, or could you wait a little until maybe the market cools down a little and be a little more prudent or patient? Can you answer these questions objectively putting yourself back in 1985 or 1975 without the benefit of 20/20 hindsight?
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1905
Member since: Apr 2007

Excellent query, hope there's a big response. The prices are breathtaking, aren't they?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1905
Member since: Apr 2007

Is it the term OLD TIMERS that turns people away? I think this would be fascinating if you'd get some feedback. Youngsters?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

My dad bought his current apartment for $5,000. I bought mine for $85,000. We were both told that we were buying at the peak of the market and would lose our shirts.

Yes, prices did rise and fall. But in the long run, we both made a pretty penny.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007

My mom's prime UWS building thumbs-downed an opportunity to buy their classic sixes at $10,000 each. It's still a rental.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1905
Member since: Apr 2007

Ouch. When was that? Many moons ago, I reckon.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Bought my village unit in 1986, twenty years ago, and paid up for a really spectacular place in a landmarked location with great views and light and lot line protection. At the end of the day, the value of the place never mattered to me because I own a beautiful place that I would never move from or sell, and I don't consider my home to be a part of my asset portfolio. It's currently worth about 4x - 5x (including money I put in to a full reno about four years ago) what I initially paid for it 20 years ago.

That's what so funny about these boards with their 'it's all gonna crash' or their 'it won't crash' jibber jabber. I heard the same 'it's gonna crash' stuff when I bought in 1986, and it didn't - for about four years. Then it did - for about five more years. Then it didn't. Everybody's going to be right at some point. Bottom line, I've built up a massive amount of equity, my monthly mortgage payment has never changed (and is laughably low compared to inflation and renting), and most importantly, I have LOVED my home for the past twenty years - and the value that I place on THAT is way more than $'s.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007

#7--Just curious. How much did you pay for your place in 1986 and what size is it? Thanks,

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

#7 here again.

To answer #8 - it's a 2,000 s.f top floor, with a 700 s.f. attached (not roof) terrace. 2 bed 2 bath, good layout. I paid $675,000 in 1986. Put in another $175,000 to redo kitchen, both baths, fireplace and all hardware. Probably over the last twenty years have spent total of $50,000 on the terrace for irrigation system, lighting, new pavers, furniture, planters, and plant material. Windows, floors, walls, doors, and moldings are all still beautiful.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007

I'm assuming its worth north of 2.2MM today? I'm still thinking that the average price today for , say a 1 BR, is inflated as against the same size in 86. I base this on salaries back then as against salaries now in relation to entry level price points. Being able only to base it as against my profession (thats the only salary level I know), I surmise that back in 86 entry level attornies at large NYC white shoe firms made about 55K. Today they make 160K, roughly 3x. Have apartments incresed in value ONLY 3x or have they increae more than that? I think more than that, thus either one of two things. Salaries are stagnant or r.e. values are out of whack, currently. All this gllom and doom stuff is based on the assumption as to when to enter the market. No one wants to pay 10-20% more than they have to.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Poster 7/9 here again:

Poster 10 - despite all the elevated real estate prices recently, I think that 2.2MM as a base for my place is WAY too cheap. 2000 sf top floor, 20 x 35 attached fully planted terrace, 2 big winged beds, two large totally reno'd baths (master with double vanity and seperate rain shower and tub), redone (wood burning) fireplace, totally reno'd kitchen, W/D, excellent closets (master has a massive custom built walk in for 2 lined in cherry and cedar), excellent light and views, protected lot lines, and all in the prime Village? 2.2MM?!? I don't think so. You should sharpen that pencil and try again.

Poster 11 - it was a lot of money 20 years ago, but the potential was huge, the bones were terrific, and the location unbeatable. I knew I'd be happy there for a very long time.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007

#12-- Outdoor space is not computed into internal Price per SF, thus you will not get nor can you assume you would get 1000+/sf for that outdoor space. Having said that, what do you think your place is worth. coop or condo? monthlies??

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 311
Member since: Mar 2007

To #10: I think salary's are somewhat stagnant. I know 160K sounds like a lot of money to some people, but the cost of living in NYC has outpaced salaries. My CPA once told me that NYC was the only place that a $250K salary could make you feel poor.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Poster 7/9/12 here again:

Poster 13 - uh, yes, of course, internal and external sf are computed differently. After iving in this place for 20 years, you should assume that I'm probably well aware of that fact. I think my place is worth between 2.8MM - 3.5MM, minimum. Although it's silly, a one bedroom Village top floor coop unit with a smaller terrace (no fireplace) in a comparable location and building sold for as much recently. Top floor 2 bed/2bath units with large useful planted terraces, wood burning fireplaces, and my light, views, finish, and layout in a prime Village location and doorman building are an extremely rare commodity. Standard per sf computations are only a guideline in my case. My place is a very well run coop with strong financials (we own the building - no mortgage) with very liberal views on things like subletting (as long as you want as long as subletee is approved by the building and is reviewed every three years) and zero flip tax. My monthly is $2,368.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007

#16-- $2368 sould probably get you a livable studio in prime village these days. makes me wanna plunk down 1 MM for a 1 BR. Probably'll be worth 5 MM by the time I'm in my 50s.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007

#14. I also make north of $250 and I can assure everyone that I feel poor every day.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Actually, $2,368 for a 2000 sf apt with a 700 sf terrace and fireplace (and a doorman building) seems quite reasonable to me.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007

#19--Ha! you old timers... you kill me. Your place would probably rent for what, like $10000 a month? My dad always crows about when the subway was a nickel. He thinks I'm crazy to pay $850 for a 1 BR too.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 360
Member since: Apr 2007

To #7 who was able to stay in the market for 20 yrs, that's great - but the reality is your situation is in the extreme minority - how many people can say for sure they will be in the same place for 10 yrs let alone 20 yrs?? For most people, 5 yrs is average because the switch jobs, get married, have kids, get divorced, or some other life changing event, etc., etc., etc. The bottom line is property values in manhattan have outpaced salaries - how many people have received a 100%-200% increase (or more) in their salary over the last 3/4 yrs? This is not sustainable, any many people will not be able to ride out the current bubble. btw I am a old timer, owning/selling 3 times over the last 15 yrs.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

#7 here:

#21 - as I said before, I bought at a time when the market went up, and then it went way down for a while, and then it went up again, and I'm sure it will go down, and then up in the future. Buying SHOULD be a long term game. Trying to time the market and flip real estate (especially in Manhattan) is foolish. NOBODY, and I mean NOBODY, knows what will happen in the future.

But according to you, it sounds like no one should buy anything at the moment because of salaries, the market, and/or not knowing where you're going to be in five years. There's ALWAYS an excuse, I suppose. I guess everyone should just rent, huh? Whatever works for you.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 360
Member since: Apr 2007

#21 here - of course buying is a long term game - BUT buying and holding RE for the long term is easier said than done. Bseides yourself, how many people do you know can hold onto their property for 20+ years? And yes, just like staying in your place for 20 yrs works for you, renting is working for me right now, thank you very much.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 217
Member since: Mar 2007

>>how many people have received a 100%-200% increase (or more) in their salary over the last 3/4 yrs?

A lot actually, but in a sneaky way. Couples / married couples / dual income no kids

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by lalagirl
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

>>how many people have received a 100%-200% increase (or more) in their salary over the last 3/4 yrs?

Quite a few. People who were just starting their careers in the early 2000's, people who working in financial services or technology who saw their bonuses pretty much evaporate in 2001 and return in 2004..

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

7/12/16/22 here:

21/23 - I know many, many people in NYC who have been in their places for 10+, 15+ and 20+ years.The majority of those that haven't sold because they took advantage of the recent boom to cash out and buy something better. For the married couples, remember, that meant the first $500K of profit was entirly tax free money! In addition, I agree woth posters 24 and 25 above, and can concur that I personally have experienced a 100% - 200% rise in my income in the past 3/4 years - as have many other people I know due to the financal market, real estate market, or fine art market sectors. That's really not that unusual.

As I said, if renting works for you, that's great - I don't know your age, or financial position, or anything else, so there's no way that I could be expected to offer any commentary on your position. But in my case, the accrual of equity, the tax benefits, the $500K tax free profit gain allowance, and the low fixed 30 year mortgage monthly payments I have (especially as it compares to annual inflation increases over the past 20 years since I bought) has really worked out extremely well.

And as this thread was a request for old timers (oy - NOW I feel old!) to comment on whether or not they would buy now, I stick by the same principal - if you're looking to flip, or know your living/moving/job situation is most likely unstable, probably not. As NOBODY knows what the future will bring, if you can look in the mirror and honestly say "well, I don't know where I'll be in ten years, but for the moment, my situation is stable, I'm not planning on moving again at this point, and I've found a home that's really terrific and won't unduly leverage me financially," than you shouldn't fear buying now. Because I can promise you that the market will go down. At some point. And then it will go up. At some point. But if you're truly happy with your home, and it's not considered a part of your 'asset portfolio' per se, once you buy and move in you tend to think of it less in terms of value and more in terms of "home."

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by mrsbuffet
over 19 years ago
Posts: 134
Member since: Nov 2006

#7, you say: "I personally have experienced a 100% - 200% rise in my income in the past 3/4 years - as have many other people I know due to the financal market, real estate market, or fine art market sectors. That's really not that unusual."

Can we agree that the financial markets, real estate markets & fine art markets have something in common? Namely that they all have historically been cyclical 'boom-bust' markets? Your statement seems to reiterate the speculative highs inherent in all three markets right now.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by matsonjones
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

#7 here:

#27 - of COURSE they're boom-bust markets. EVERY market to a greater or lesser degree is a boom-bust market! So what? And I said as much if you read my earlier posts that I think the market will go down. At some point. But when is anybody's guess, because NOBODY can predict anything with authority. And then the market will go up again. At some point. The fact that it's a boom-bust cycle doesn't matter at all to me.

Again, my point is that if you're thinking about buying a home (and not an investment), and you believe that your time horizon is going to be a long one, and that you're not unduly leveraging yourself financially, and that you will be happy writing your monthly mortgage and maintenance checks, then you should buy.

The only people who will get hosed are two types of people:

1.both buyers and non-buyers who sit on the sidelines, push around their charts and data all day, and think that they actually have some ability to prognosticate the direction and timing of the market. They can't.

2. those that HAVE to sell quickly for reasons beyond their control. But again, if this happens, it will be beyond your control to time the market at that point. It could be up, it could be down. There's simply no way to know.

Everything carries a risk. But being a homeowner has given me terrific peace of mind, and been an absolutely wonderful investment to boot. I don't care about markets per se, boom-bust cycles, or anybody's faux prognostication, as it applies to my home. I care about being able to sleep well at night.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 217
Member since: Mar 2007

I disagree somewhat. In the last stock market bubble, there was a blatent disregard for a possible bubble. My new theory is to ignore the hype on TV and the newspaper as they always seem to guide poorly.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment