Skip Navigation

Let's Discuss the Following Two Statements

Started by anonymouss
over 19 years ago
Posts: 137
Member since: Jan 2007
Discussion about
1. Manhattan is like a luxury good. Apartment prices are dictated not by average income but by what peoplea are willing to pay to own a piece of the island. It's like a Mercedes. The other boros are like Hondas. 2. While the costs of renting and owning be about the same in the long run, they can diverge widely for long periods of time.
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 66
Member since: Jan 2007

#2 and #3, what is wrong with you? The OP wants to start a discussion which is exactly what these boards are for. If you're not interested don't read the boards.

OP, regarding the first statement, I think there is truth to it. In Manhattan more than in the rest of the country figures like average salary to average home price are not as meaningful because there are many buyers who are very rich, don't have traditional jobs with salaries, are buying pied a terres, etc.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Manhattan is not a luxury good. PRIME Manhattan is a luxury good. Same goes for PRIME areas of Los Angeles, for instance, but certainly not all of LA by a longshot.

The only differance I care about between renting and owning is (assuming that I owning for the l-o-n-g haul) that the first $500,000 of profit my wife and I earn on our home (if we own it for two years or longer) is TAX FREE PROFIT. And living in NYC where I lose approximately 50% of my income to federal, state, and city government, that matters.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment