Interest Only Loan
Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Discussion about
I am looking for mortgage. A mortgage broker told me that with interest only loan, I can pay extra money towards principal anytime without being charged a fee or penalty; and my monthly payment will be reduced immediately. However, a bank loan offer told me that the extra money that I paid could be just put in an escrow account; I could be charged a fee each time I pay extra because they have to do recalculation for me; and my monthly payment will not be reduced in most cases. How does the interest only loan really work when I pay extra once a year with my annual bonus?
#2, you are getting hysterical without knowing what you are talking about. You are equating an IO fixed loan (which I assume is what the OP is looking at) with an ARM.
1) The mortgage broker is paid a fee for find you (the borrower). Once you get the loan, he is out of the picture. So he does not "profit from every dime you send". He gets the same fee based on the size of your loan, regardless of what terms you choose.
2) I do not like ARMs, they are a gamble on interest rates. However, an IO fixed loan has a FIXED interest rate for 30 years. Its just that for the first 10 years, you do not pay down your principal, helping your cash flow (lower required payments). NOTE that the interest rate is typically higher than that of a "regular" 30 year fixed, so you do pay some extra interest overall in exchange for lower required payments for 10 years.
3) Will there be a glut of sales in 10 years because there are a lot of people selling due to the IO portion of their loan running out? I dunno. Sounds dubious to me. First of all, its 10 years from now! I am pretty sure I will move again before then. Second, the value of your home will likely appreciate to enough to make the "missing" principal payments irrelevant. (I have a regular 30 year fixed now... after 5 years, my principal has gone down only 7%, but my apt has increased in value by 90%, conservatively.)
4) Everyone I have spoken to has said there is no fee to prepay. If there is, DO NOT choose that loan! Nobody has mentioned anything about escrow accounts or fees for recalculating. (Think about it... if you set up the info in an Excel sheet, it can recalculate instantly. Its not hard at all.) Just make sure it is an IO FIXED loan, with no prepayment fees or restrictions.
5) #2 - Perhaps you are confusing the OPs question with the glut of IO ARMs out there. Those loans have been sold to less qualified borrowers, with enticing 2 year teaser rates, which then become adjustable and "suddenly" burdensome. (Think 2.9% for 2 years, then the rate jumps to 8 or 9 or even 11 percent.)
I totally disagree with #2. A IO fixed loan is 100% different than an ARM. You are not gambling on where interest rates are headed, and you are not being "begging to be foreclosed on". PLEASE NOTE an IO fixed loan is NOT an IO ARM loan, where typically you get an initial, IO teaser interest rate, then after 2 or 5 years, the interest rate goes up dramatically. Those types of loans are leading to problems with less qualified borrowers.
With an IO fixed loan, in exchange for a higher interest rate, you get the flexibility of IO payments for the first 10 years. This means better cash flow for the duration.
#2 also doesnt know what he is talking about, since his comment that they "profit from every dime you send" is incorrect. The mortgage broker is paid a fee for hooking you up with the lending agency and that's it.
Everyone I have spoken to about these loans (I am a buyer also considering such a loan) have indicated that there is no fee for prepayment (though you should confirm, of course!). And if you specify that your excess payment should go towards principal, then your next month's required payment will be reduced accordingly. (Its not much work... reduce the principal amount, calculate the interest. A computer does it instantaneously.)
Geez, I am reading the rest of #2's posting and he is completely wrong again. How you finance your apartment has no effect on how it sells. Remember than an IO fixed loan locks in your payment for the entire 30 years. IO for the first 10 years, and then basically a fixed 20 year "regular" mortgage after that. Yes, the monthly payments will be higher for the last 10 years (since you are paying off the principal over 20 instead of 30)... but you can refinance if it is advantageous at that point, and (depending on your situation) you may sell before the 10 years are up. Personally, I am almost sure that I will move again within the 10 years. If I end up staying... well
What SHOULD be illegal are the IO ARMS that get offered to those with bad credit. In those instances, you get some crazy teaser, like 2.9%, for 2 years. But then it jumps to prime or libor plus 3 or 4 and next thing you know, your monthly payment has quadrupled. That does lead to foreclosure, since typically the borrower was not qualified to buy the place to begin with.
Just recognize that with an IO FIXED, you do pay a higher interest rate (1/4 - 3/8 percent typically) in exchange for "back loading" your payment plan. My plan is to use my bonus to pay down the principal each year. The other 11 months, I get the benefit of a lower *required* monthly payment... of course I could pay more if I wish. I currently have a regular 30 year fixed, and in 5 years, my principal has gone down only about 7% anyway!
OP - try contacting a different bank. And let us know how it turns out. Again, everything I have heard (including asking the bank directly) is that there is no charge for prepayment.
Ooops. Sorry, I typed out two replies and somehow both ended up being posted (I forgot to cut). lol. Apologies.
There is a big difference between an IO or an IO/ARM and a negatively amortizing loan. I would never advise anyone to take out a NA loan, but an IO makes sense for a lot of people.
I had an IO/ARM on my last apartment. I was careful to calculate the maximum payments should the ARM reset to the hightest possible level and to ensure that I could still afford the payments (most ARMS have a max increase). I only paid the minimum. I could have paid more, but I was earning enough equity through market appreciation. I owned the apartment for 4 years, and sold at a huge profit having had minimal ownership expenses. The first 4 years of a 30 year-fixed mortgage are almost all interest anyway.
The average first time homebuyer owns their first home just under 7 years. If you are likely to own the home for only a few years, don't pay for a 30 year fixed rate. Get an ARM. But don't get a NA loan, don't get an ARM that doesn't have a cap, and don't get any loan that you can't afford if it resets to the cap.
But... but... but nobody in NY uses these financial products! Or so the housing heads protest. *BARFS*
## 2 and 6 are clearly non-sophisticated numbskulls. I had a 7 year ARM and sold out after 2 years. The average person owns their homes less than 7 years so, I think 7 year ARMS are great. Fixed rate mortgages are for people who have zero financial acumen and/or are extremely fiscally conservative. These products, if used correctly, are not evil. Of course, you have to read the operative documents, not just rely on the lender's or the broker's oral reps.
7Y or 10Y Arm can be wise, but IO loan is stupidity
ARMS and I/O loans when employed correctly can often make sense for a borrower.
A Fixed Rate I/O loan made great sense for me and my wife because we took out a very modest Loan To Value (LTV) of 33%. Since we are only paying interest our payment is 100% tax deductible and we really don't envision oursleves being in the same home after the ten years when the amort kicks in.
To the OP's question we do not have a pre-payment penalty, and any contribution made above the montly requirement automatically reduces the principal.
I recently closed on an apartment and decided to opt for the fixed rate IO product. It is IO for the first 10 years and then will amortize over 20 years for the remainder of the term. I can freely prepay the loan so all of my excess payments will be applied to the mortgage principal should I make escess payments. I can afford the apartment based on my annual salary. The interest rate is the same for both the io and amortizing loans because it is a jumbo loan and that was the best rate that the lenders were offering at the time. The reason why I opted for the io loan is because a nice percentage of my salary is paid in my bonus. Therefore, I plan on making a lump sum at the end of each year. I benefit from the same fixed rate over the life of my loan and, If I paid the amortizing payment, it will amortize the same as if I had chosen the amortizing loan (and in the earlier years very little principal is actually amortizied). In addition, if for any reason I down the road I need or want to make a smaller payment than I am now, I will be able to because as the loan amortizes the io payment will be reduced.
I am not advocating the use of this type of loan to allow someone to buy a property they cannot afford but sometimes it may make sense to a particular borrower.
Sound advice from #2 & #13.
OP you should NOT enter into an ARM loan if the lower payments are the ONLY way you could afford your home. If so you're prob getting in over your head. You SHOULD do it if it makes financial sense to you.
Also keep in mind that an ARM will change as interest rates change....meaning that if rates rise so will your monthly payments (depending on how often the rate adjusts).
Good luck!
What's with the name calling, people. Grow up. Please.
#13 I am doing the exact same thing -- about 25% of my salary is a lump sum bonus, that if it looks as if I will be in the place longer than 7 yrs, I will start applying to overall principat to get my monthlies down to where the standard fixed would have been, while giving me some breathing room the first few years . .. agreed that it is a smart option for a certain type of buyer . . .
While some comments here are intelligent and caring and some are completely ridiculous, none are really sound. You need to look at your own financial position to decide what is best. For some, IO is an incredible product. For some, a neg-am mortgage is an incredible product.
For example, if you are heavily bonused, a 30 year fixed/10 yr IO might be great. If its a 50% down building, an IO is great. Why put more in when you earn the same return without adding principal? Do put the extra in the market or in tax free bonds.
For neg am, say you go 4% with a 3% neg am. You still make the return on your real estate investment and get a few percent back to re-invest elsewhere. If you think the NYC market is goin up at 10% or more for n years, again, your initial investment makes the same money. Its a great way to pull money out for re-investment without any penalty or further costs to you.
Too bad oto many people used these vehicles to buy properties they could not afford. We do not know our situation, but if you have cash, consult an investment advior and find out what is best if you cannot figure it out on your own. These products are great if used properly. Do not use them to buy more than you can afford. Use them to make your money work for you, and not sit making nothing.