Manhattan prices
Started by MMAfia
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1071
Member since: Feb 2007
Discussion about
Manhattan NYC has had it's share of boom and bust cycles. There have been quite severe retractions in the past, notably in the early 80s when prices declined well into the double digit territory. Clearly, as historical data shows, prices in Manhattan DO come down, and can come down a LOT. Fast forward to today. Manhattan has been holding up well, *relative* to the rest of the nation. Here are some... [more]
Manhattan NYC has had it's share of boom and bust cycles. There have been quite severe retractions in the past, notably in the early 80s when prices declined well into the double digit territory. Clearly, as historical data shows, prices in Manhattan DO come down, and can come down a LOT. Fast forward to today. Manhattan has been holding up well, *relative* to the rest of the nation. Here are some thoughts as to why: 1. More than 75% of apartments in Manhattan are Coops, which require at the minimum a 20% downpayment by the board. In addition, most require proof of liquid assets AFTER paying downpayment and closing costs of at least one year's worth of mortgage/maintenance/tax payments, either in escrow or in a savings bank account. Even for condos, regulations in the City put closing costs at $25-$50k, depending on who pays for the transfer cost (new vs old condo building). In other words, sub-prime issues won't crop up as immediate problems in the city due to its unique regulations that minimize the risk associated with mortgage loans to unqualified people. It will still affect the city, but in more subtle and indirect ways. This has been evidenced by charts provided by the Post which show that foreclosures south of 100th street is almost non-existent, but is very rampant in the other boroughs, especially Jamaica Queens et al. 2. Still some interest from foreign buyers, mostly European (thank you sinking USD). 3. Local economy (i.e. financial services industry) is still doing well. Key word is still. If there is a large unraveling (thank you super-levered hedge funds and banks working together like 'WinTel'), it could very well have a tangible impact to the local economy. 4. Influx of retiring baby-boomers (aka UES, Beekman and Sutton areas within the city). There has been some evidence of such demographic movement, although the impact is not as clear (i.e. these retirees still need to SELL their house to move into NYC, and that's the hard part). Any other ideas? So far, the local Manhattan market has been strong, but activity is slowly unwinding, as it normally does during the cyclical selling season. Eventually, Manhattan *will* get affected by the generalized housing recession. MMAfia [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
1 Comments
-
10 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
17 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Thoughtful writeup. I would add:
As the US becomes more urban-friendly, the model city enjoys the benefit as being seen as the original and therefore aspirational.
Despite the chagrin about high prices, taxes and cost-of-living, it's a damn fine city, with a wonderful stream of new and interesting inhabitants.
NYC is still scary to most of the country, but less so each year, and it never was scary to the rest of the world, which as you said, can now buy more dollars.
You have to remember one thing: New York (particularly Manhattan) is a unique place, both on the international and national levels. It's the only real mega-city in US. Those people who lived elsewhere in the US can attest to that - Chicago and LA is a joke in a "city sense" compared to NY. In the global urban sense only European and Asian giants (London, Paris, Moscow, Tokyo) can be compared to NY. But the real estate prces in those cities are already surpassing NY (especially coupled with the weak dollar).
That's why NY will continue to be strong.
Agree with the above and let me add my 2 cente -
People keep comparing today with the eve of the last great downturn in the Manhattan market, circa early 90's. But the comparison is wrong for these reasons -
(1) Economy was going through an unprecedented white collar recession involving massive layoffs on Wall St.
(2) Both the rental AND sale markets were down
(3) NYC was dirtier and there was more crime, drugs, squegee people, beggers on the subways (remember the "west side wild man?")
Today the NYC economy is strong, rental market is tight and the city is safer & cleaner. Once full of transients, Manhattan is now including more empty nesters, families and Europeans. NYC is increasingly becoming a more global city on par with London, Hong Kong, etc.
My point that basing views on past experience isn't realistic because significant changes in the market result from unexpected events. Current signs point to a stable RE market for NYC at this moment. Enjoy the ride!