Skip Navigation

NYT: Condos Tighten the Rules

Started by alanhart
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007
Discussion about
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/20/realestate/20cov.html?_r=1&ref=realestate&oref=slogin Why do owners in NY feel the need to be so controlling, based on all kinds of "what-ifs", while condos in the entire rest of the country manage just fine without approval processes and sublet restrictions? It's especially strange in that condos in sunbelt states, where most of them are, are made of chicken-wire and papier-mache, while most NY condos and coops are more solidly built.
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

I think it's quite reasonable that without subjecting potential condo purchasers to a malicious and unwieldy process, we certainly have the right to know simple basic facts about a possible neighbor. Are they felons? Where do they work, and are they capable of affording the unit they wish to buy? Do they have a sketchy job history, or have their been substantive problems with their last managing agent/building? Do they plan to put an unreasonable amount of people or animals in their unit? Will they be using it as a residence, office, or rental/sublet?

My god, even RENTERS have to pass basic backround checks in many rental buildings - why would I as a homeowner expect any less of a backround check from a person who will OWN something in my building?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007

But the question is why only in New York (and its colony, south Florida)?

Don't they have felons all over the country, and all over the world? In those places, you just buy a condo and do what you want with it, as long as you don't mess with the common areas or anything that's visible from the outside.

Isn't it the bank's problem if they can't afford their mortgage? (Charges are a pittance, and taxes are paid separately, so certainly there can't be any issue of arrears affecting the condo association . . . that's the wisdom that prevails everywhere else for condos.)

And how would you as a homeowner handle the same issues in a suburban area (or even a townhouse street)? Can you require background checks for the person who's buying the house next door? Will you live in fear if you can't?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Houses are VERY different. My wife, children, and I share common areas, the running of the building, and contiguous walls with others. I think that the security issues are pretty obvious....

As to other areas not doing it, my guess might be that people pay much more for their homes here, so more is at stake. As to what's the banks problem, if someone defaults, they're not paying their monthly common charges, which means the other homeowners have to take up the slack.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 227
Member since: Jan 2007

Continuing in line with #4, the cost of the homes are much higher than the rest of the countries and so are the common charges. The common charges/taxes which are paid per month are multiples above what is paid elsewhere.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 227
Member since: Jan 2007

#5 posting here - sorry i meant that the rest of the country NOT plural!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

The problem with condo's subjecting prospective buyers to invasive and rigorous examination is that condos have very limited recourse. They basically have two options: they can allow the purchase or they can exercise right-of-first refusal and buy the unit themselves. They can not simply block the sale.

Right-of-first refusal is a very expensive proposition. The building needs to have a special assessment to raise the purchase price and buyer's closing cost (high for condos) and then has to pay the seller's closing costs (also substantial). Given the time frame of buying and then immediately selling, there is seldom opportunity to sell at enough of a profit to cover the closing costs.

The likelihood that a prospective buyer has such severe financial shortcomings that their failure to pay the common charges will exceed the costs of exercising right-of-first refusal is pretty low. That's why you rarely see buildings exercise right-of-first refusal. I recently bought a condo: I would have to fail to pay my common charges for almost 50 years to equal just the buyer's closing costs!

Also, there are huge legal concerns about excluding buyers. Condos are not co-ops and they do not have many of the same protections.

So the number 2 I ask, what are you personally willing to pay to ensure that your neighbors can afford their unit? If this is such a concern, why didn't you buy a co-op?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 227
Member since: Jan 2007

If you read the article, one of the reasons cited was not economic. There was a buyer who turned out to be a convicted sex offender in a building with families and children. So given that circumstances, the condo did use its right of first refusal.

Further, the article talks about how condos are requesting more information as part of the process which itself can be a deterrent for the wrong buyers.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

Extensive information requests are not an effective deterrent to buyers, unless they are fully aware of the extent of the process BEFORE going into contract. If boards are continually going back to buyers with additional ad-hoc requests, there is no way a potential buyer could know the extent of the process.

A potential buyer who has a few hundred thousand dollars on deposit is NOT going to walk away (leaving their deposit behind) simply because they don't want to provide additional information.

No seller in their right mind is going to agree to a contact that is going to allow a buyer to walk away from a contract with the deposit if the buyer ever becomes unhappy with the board process. The seller has nothing to lose if the buyer is rejected, so why would he ever let the buyer walk away from the deal with the deposit?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

Is the issue of a child-molestor living in the building really a condo-issue? Isn't it a broader social issue about the re-introduction of certain types of offenders into society and the line between the rights of the community and the rights of those who have served their time?

If all buildings refused to rent or sell to child-molestors, would they really all leave NYC? Or would they end up living in SRO's and on the streets? And would living in SRO's or on the streets somehow make them less of a threat? Isn't this the real issue?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 214
Member since: Feb 2007

broader social issues and philosophical big picture musings are all well and good in theory, but most of us are damned if we are going to have a chid molester living next door to our kids.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

I have 3 children and understand not WANTING to have a child predator living next door. But I really don't feel any safer having him live on the street next to the playground or hanging out in front of the school. We don't have the power to lock up predators for life, and we have to deal with them re-entering society.

I don't have a lot of control in this situation.

But I do know that criminals who are unable to find housing after release and end up on the street are MORE statistically more likely to re-offend and are MORE dangerous than those who are able to find housing/jobs/etc.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007

#11 -- what makes you think you haven't had a child molestor living next door to every place you've ever lived, in every town of every state? Especially because molestation is usually done by family members of the victims, we can assume that only a tiny percentage is ever reported to the police, let alone result in conviction.

Perhaps you've been watching too much of a certain sensationalizing TV show.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Man oh man. It's as simple as this - It's a shared building in terms of costs and personal interactions, and I feel I have a right to know the basics about someone else who is going to move in and be sharing the financial burden with me, as well know that my family is as safe as can be reasonably expected inside the enclosed common areas of our shared home.

If you assholes can't get that, then, well, move into a condo and fill it with all the financial deadbeats and felony offenders you want!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

You can feel that you have the right to whatever information you want. You can feel that you have the right to exclude whomever you wish. You would be wrong, but you can feel that way.

At the end of the day, all a condo can do is exercise right of first refusal and buy the unit. That RARELY happenes because it is very rare that a prospective buyer is so potentially harmful to the building that a super-majority of the owners are willing to buck up to block the buyer.

I don't particularly like many of my neighbors...that's life.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

1. We DO have the actual right to ask whatever information we request.

2. We DO have the right to exclude people who have been convicted of felonies such as pedophilia, murder, manslaughter, and/or serious assault - this right has been already been upheld in NYC courts on multiple occasions as it applies to condominium boards.

The only person who is wrong here is you, #15, and you can feel any way YOU want, but I AM right.

As to any other issues aside from those, the condo board's 'right of first refusal' (usually a two week window) starts ticking from the beginning EVERY TIME the board requests additional information from the prospective tenant. We can keep requesting info in dribs and drabs until the cows come home. That's OUR legal right. And by that time, the potential purchaser will be so disgusted, they'll pick up their marbles, take back the deposit (which is contingent on right of first refusal being signed off on) and go buy elsewhere.

I'm sure that you don't like many of your neighbors - and I can tell by your obsequious tone that they must not like you either, sport.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

You can only exclude people from a condo if the condo excercises right of first refusal. No board has the power to exercise right of first refusal without a majority or super-majority of the condo members. It is not an exclusive right of the board.

While a board can ask for additional information, a prospective buyer can not just walk away with their deposit if they are frustrated with the process. They would lose their deposit. A seller doesn't care if the board exercises right of first refusal or not: the seller is made whole regardless. So why would a seller ever excuse the buyer from the contract without retaining the deposit? It just doesn't happen.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

It really doesn't matter if the board or a board member likes a prospective tenant. No board in NYC has the right to exercise right of first refusal without the input of all the condo owners. Have you ever tried to get a majority of condo owners to agree on something that ISN'T going to cost them a collective fortune?

Consider how many people bought their units for a fraction of today's prices. The proverbial little-old-lady who bought her unit for $5,000 50 years ago. She isn't going to vote in favor of a special assessment of tens of thousands of dollars per share to buy the apartment because someone on the board is concerned about a prospective buyer. People would rather live next door to a drug dealing prostitute than buck up for the condo to buy the unit.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

I will repeat again for those of you who can't seem to read...

We DO have the right to exclude people who have been convicted of felonies such as pedophilia, murder, manslaughter, and/or serious assault - this right has been already been upheld in NYC courts on multiple occasions as it applies to condominium boards. I just don't know what part of that you can't quite seem to undestand.

Let me repeat - THIS RIGHT HAS ALREADY BEEN UPHELD IN NYC COURTS ON MULTIPLE OCCASIONS.

In the case of condos, since they have the right to approve and add amendments to their house rules, they certainly CAN (as we already have) set up demands that would make a buyer think twice - we can ask for multiple years maintenance in advance, pass rental/sublet exigencies, demand disclosure so overwhelming that the buyer would be VERY uncomfortable in the building, pass flip taxes, etc.

And I can tell you for certain in our condo (14 units) that getting the approval to exercise right of first refusal has easily happened before, and can easily happen again. The good news is that to a large degree the financial level of our condo is such that we CAN be highly self regulating, thereby keeping out assholes like #18 who would be comfortable having their young chidren live next door to a drug dealing prostitute rather than stepping up to the plate like a responsible adult to protect their children and their investment.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 227
Member since: Jan 2007

To #18 The response you posted already shows you are a co-op owner. Condo owners dont vote in shares - as they own REAL property.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

"We DO have the right to exclude people who have been convicted of felonies such as pedophilia, murder, manslaughter, and/or serious assault - this right has been already been upheld in NYC courts on multiple occasions as it applies to condominium boards. I just don't know what part of that you can't quite seem to undestand."

No one is debating this. There is disagreement about HOW a condo can efectively exclude persons they wish to exclude. The board can not unilaterally make a decision. All the board can do is ask for a vote to exercise right of first refusal. The actual exercise of right of first refusal is a rarity in Manhattan. The board can't block a sale without substantial support from the building.

You live in a tiny building, #19. Do you have experience in a building with several hundred or a thousand families? Getting a majority vote, when many voters will never even see buyer if they do move in is RARE.

And #18 is correct. In a condo, you need a majority (or supermajority depending on the rules) vote in order to excercise right of first refusal. Shares are a non issue, and #18 never raised the issue of shares.

Also, did anyone read that someone WANTS to live next to a drug-dealing prostitute? But unless a MAJORITY of the owners agree to a special assessment, what can you do? That's life. If you care that much about your neighbors, you buy in a co-op or you live on a large property.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

You don't get it. When people are saying "you can't exclude", they aren't talking about legal rights.

They are saying that YOU (as an individual and as a board member) can't exclude people. No individual and no condo board has the power to exclude anyone. That is a decision to be made by all the condo owners.

For someone who thinks they are so smart and everyone else is so dumb, you have terrible reading comprehension skills.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

You exclude them quite simply - by telling the seller that you have found, after a background check, that the potential buyer is a convicted felon with a conviction for pedophila, or murder, etc., and that the courts have upheld the board's right to exclude that person as a potential buyer. No majority, no supermajority, or anything else like a vote is required. END OF STORY. There is NO disagreement how to effectively exclude a buyer in that case. There is simple case law and legal precedent. Right of first refusal does not enter the picture in this case. The potential buyer can be rejected, PERIOD.

As to your last point, that is EXACTLY why I live in small condo of like minded individuals who all share the same approximate financial level - we can call our own shots, and don't have to put up with small minded bullshit like "But unless a MAJORITY of the owners agree to a special assessment, what can you do? That's life. If you care that much about your neighbors, you buy in a co-op or you live on a large property." We DO care about ourselves, AND our neighbors. We don't want people in our building who are financial trainwrecks or are potentially harmful to our children. We have the best of condo ownership with the protections of a coop.

And I'm willing to bet that as more high end condos continue to be built in prime Manhattan locations, you'll see a move more and more in this general direction in the future.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

"You exclude them quite simply - by telling the seller that you have found, after a background check, that the potential buyer is a convicted felon with a conviction for pedophila, or murder, etc., and that the courts have upheld the board's right to exclude that person as a potential buyer. No majority, no supermajority, or anything else like a vote is required. END OF STORY. There is NO disagreement how to effectively exclude a buyer in that case. There is simple case law and legal precedent. Right of first refusal does not enter the picture in this case. The potential buyer can be rejected, PERIOD."

Ummm. No. It really isn't that simple. A standard contract for a condo does not include provisions for either side to cancel the contract if the board does not approve. Standard contracts include clauses for right-of-first refusal, and that is it. Condo contracts do not include clauses for board approval. So if the board doesn't "appove" the candidate, there is no impact on the contract. You can tell the seller whatever you want. But unles you acutually buy the unit at the contract price, you are SOL.

It sounds like you prefer the Manhattan version of NIMBY. Congratulate yourself. I guess...

I have been living in the same pre-war condo building for 35 years now. I've been on the board for 5 years. Believe it or not, we have never had a problem with a serial killer moving in and molesting children in the laundry room while dealing drugs to the prostitutes who operate brothels out of their units.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Sigh - and I was the president of my coop board for two years previous to moving into my condo (where I now sit on the board), and so I shall (yet again) repeat myself as you seem completely unable to read and digest information....

You exclude them quite simply - by telling the seller that you have found, after a background check, that the potential buyer is a convicted felon with a conviction for pedophila, or murder, etc., and that the courts have upheld the board's right to exclude that person as a potential buyer. No majority, no supermajority, or anything else like a vote is required. END OF STORY.

It REALLY IS THAT SIMPLE. Based on NYC court rulings the contract is considered to be breached in those situations, the money is returned, the buyer and seller are released from the sale, do not pas go, do not collect $200, the contract is considered to have never been a valid contract in the first place from a legal POV, what part of this are you so dense that you cannot understand?

NIMBY? Damn straight!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

The contract is not breached when the buyer is discovered to have a criminal background. Anyone who has even the slightest familiarity with contracts law can tell you that.

Further, a breached contract is just that: breached. It is not invalidated. One parties claims under a contract are not nullified by a breach.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

NYC contracts for multiple dwellings (condo/coops) DO demand disclosure for anyone who has been convicted of a sex crime or a serious felony assault charge.

The contract IS invalidated in those cases.

If you had the slightest familiarity about NYC multiple dwelling laws, you would know that.

In that case, the contract is considered never to have been valid in the first place. Read case law, and NYC legal decisions in recent cases.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 311
Member since: Mar 2007

#25- Holy crap! You are one big jerk! Who the heck would want to live in your building?????

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

#28 - not you, thank god. So so so so sorry that us wanting to know the basics about someone new moving in to our condo and sharing the financial burden with us, as well knowing that our families are as safe as can be reasonably expected inside the enclosed common areas of our shared home(s) is just too much for your little offended sensibility to deal with.

Why don't you go move in with #18 or #24 who seem content with any old crackhead living in to their building(s) with total abandon and no questions asked....

To each their own.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 311
Member since: Mar 2007

You really are a jerk. My issues isn't with the fact that you want to know who's living in the building; I live in Coop. My issue is with your TONE OF VOICE (notice the caps...mimicking you). I hadn't even been paying attention to this thread, just read it and was stunned....mostly at your condescension...wow!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Poor baby - do the BiG cApItAl LeTtErS threaten you so much?

Being that poster(s)13/15/17/19/21/22/24/26 have to be explained the same thing over and over and over and over and over and over again, a modest amount of emphasis was called for.

If the tone of voice bothers you, I suggest you go back and reread the posts. The only condescension here is holier-than-thou attitude people cloak themselves in of rightous indignation while they claim to know the law, and further seem to feel that having anybody at all living next to your children is okey-dokey because, at the end of the day when all is said and done, they just can't be bothered. And then they have the nerve to suggest my attitude stems from NIMBY, when their apathetic attitude stems from SEP.

That's condescension...wow!.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 311
Member since: Mar 2007

Your last post just made my case.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

As did yours mine.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 259
Member since: Oct 2006

Moral Question -

Would you sell to someone who you knew was a convicted sex offender if there offer was $200,000 more then the next closest offer?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

veree funee...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007

#33 -- I think if you re-read the posts, you'll see that the other poster perfectly well understood what you were saying. He just didn't agree with it. So you had to shout it again and again until he came around. My guess is that you bullied your fellow board members and condo owners in much the same way you've been doing on this thread.

And now you feel safe from ex-convicts, etc. Just as we Americans now feel safe from those Iraqis. Mission Accomplished. No more problem.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007

Anyway the OP question is why NY and not other very pricey markets -- SF, DC, London, etc. Those cities also have ex-cons, drug dealers, securities traders, prostitutes, real estate brokers and sex offenders.

Charges aren't significantly higher in NY condos -- it's just heat and hot/cold water that differs, not taxes and underlying mortgage. Common charges are always chump change.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

You keep repeating the same thing over and over and over again to someone who (for very good reasons it seems) does not agree with you. Repeating the same position and insisting that you are right and everyone who disagrees is stupid is not exactly convincing.

You talk about breaching a contract and invalidating a contract as though they are the same thing. They are not. A contract can not be breached by a third party and they can not be invalidated by a third party unless that third party is judicial.

A condo blocking a sale is very rare for good reason.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 311
Member since: Mar 2007

#33 must be an attorney, but not a very good one.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007

Boy - talk about sour grapes. Just because you're all wrong and now are chalking up to opinion. There is no opinion. The courts in NYC have ruled recetly on this matter. That's the law. Disgaree all you want. It doesn't matter. You're wrong. Period.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

You think that a condo board can declare a contract to be in breach or to be invalid? That is hysterical. Wrong..but very funny.

But feel free to point us to the case law that allows a condo board to declare a contract in breach or invalid b/c the potential buyer is a felon.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 12397
Member since: Feb 2007

Oh, you're just begging for a barrage of capital letters, aren't you, 41?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007

I know, I know. I'll be reminded, in all caps, that THIS RIGHT HAS ALREADY BEEN UPHELD IN NYC COURTS ON MULTIPLE OCCASIONS.

Of course, unless he can post some relevant case law that indicates that condo boards have some judicial power to invalidate contracts, I'm still not buying it.

There is plenty precedent for a criminal background being grounds for denying housing....but that is hardly what our friend the expert is claiming. He is claiming that the contract is nullified when a potential buyer has a criminal record and the condo board can block the sale without exercising right of first refusal. And this simply isn't true.

If a condo board chose to exercise right of first refusal because a potential buyer were a felon, they would be on strong legal ground. But they have no standing to wave their magic wand and declare the contract invalid.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment