Question on Buyer Brokers
Started by Crackerjack
over 19 years ago
Posts: 98
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
I was just thinking of this whole "buyer broker" thing and I have a question. They supposedly are supposed to help the buyer find, properties, research buildings, and aid buyers in deciding on the best offer to make. There is where my question comes. If a buyer broker is paid a commission on the sale price of a property, aren't they really looking for you to buy the property at the highest price, since that is what they get paid on? Am I missing something?
The difference in 50k in purchase price is only about $750 after a broker pays his firm. Most reputable brokers will help steer you in the right direction as the more you spend only changes his commission by a fairly small amount...jmo
#2 is absolutely correct. the difference is minimal.Ad regardless of what many people on this board have to say about it, there are many brokers who really pride themselves o doing the very best job for you.
I agree with both #2 & #3 and if that broker does right by you, it's more likely that you will refer people to them. So it's not worth it for the broker to do wrong by you. They in fact lose more that way.
OP here. Thanks guys. That is quite interesting to me. Are you all brokers though, or just speculators?
I am #3 and I am a broker. But I have never known any broker who felt otherwise--even with a buyer who was a one time buyer (as opposed to a repeat buyer where there tends to be an enormous amount of loyalty--example: I just pushed my buyer into bidding on an apartment where I get 2.5% as opposed to 4% because I felt she would be happier there with my knowledge of the neighborhood and so forth) Seriously, even the many brokers who are not quite so ethical just want to make a deal, and the discrepancy in commission with a higher price just doesnt factor in.
I am # 2 and NOT a broker. I think you would find a bit more shady activities with selling brokers...
Sure - but if you buy without a buyer's broker, you can probably negotiate a lower price because the selling broker wouldn't have to split a 6% commission check with anyone. Informed buyers who know what they want could probably in many cases do better without a buyer's broker, especiall given how easy it has become to find listings.
That is why selling brokers can be shady. They will try and sell to the person w/out a broker.
#2 again
Agreed that buyers brokers may not do much to steer you to a more expensive property, but they do have an inherent need/desire to get you to buy something. In my experience, that has lead the buyer's brokers I have used (2 different times) to try and get me to bid higher out of the gate so I would "win" the property. It may have been smart the first time, but I think it caused me to bid way over the second time. It is hard to counter when your broker, who should be in the know, says "you have to bid at least ask if you want to be taken seriously."
We used a buyer's broker to buy an investment property in Manhattan. We were really small potatoes for NYC (<400k), and newbies to the process as well, but the broker was very helpful and professional. She did try to steer us toward properties at the upper level of our price range, but I really think it was because she thought they would be better investments; the difference in the amount of money she would have made was probably very small. We ended up with a somewhat lesser property at a price we were comfortable with. The broker was also a great help in getting it rented out. She probably made a commission on that, too, but it was well worth it.
I really believe it is worthwhile to pay for service in situations where the process is complicated and requires knowledge that is beyond my area of expertise. You don't have to let them lead you around by the nose, but if you use your intelligence it can be better than trying to go it alone. JMO.
Reposting because this got garbled above!
We used a buyer's broker to buy an investment property in Manhattan. We were really small potatoes for NYC (<400k), and newbies to the process as well, but the broker was very helpful and professional. She did try to steer us toward properties at the upper level of our price range, but I really think it was because she thought they would be better investments; the difference in the amount of money she would have made was probably very small. We ended up with a somewhat lesser property at a price we were comfortable with. The broker was also a great help in getting it rented out. She probably made a commission on that, too, but it was well worth it.
I really believe it is worthwhile to pay for service in situations where the process is complicated and requires knowledge that is beyond my area of expertise. You don't have to let them lead you around by the nose, but if you use your intelligence it can be better than trying to go it alone. JMO.
Oh, well, not going to retype all that. Basically I said if you don't know what you're doing (like us) it can be worth it to pay someone to help you.
#6 is she providing you with any FAVORS? ;) Please give me a break!....4% vs. 2.5%....how benevolent.
#6 no lambs here!
I am using a buyers broker for a high end apt. search on the UES. We want a co-op and where I am finding the broker valuable is her knowledge of the buildings and what each individual board wants in the way of a potential purchaser. Also, if you are working with someone from a well respected firm who knows his/her way around, I feel you are taken much more seriously by the seller's broker. And lets face it - if you don't have the seller's broker on your side or if he/she doesn't think you are a "good fit" for the building then you are not going to get much attention. I suppose one could do this on ones own but I think I have saved myself a lot of time by getting the "bottom line" on a building early on.
buyer's brokers are only useful if you are not interested in doing an internet search yourself. You also may find yourself in an advantageous situation where the direct commission is lower with the selling broker. We had a lower bid accepted against bids with a buyer's broker due to the lower commission the seller had to pay.