Need Help and advice (thanks to those that help)
Started by martinland
over 19 years ago
Posts: 7
Member since: Jun 2007
Discussion about
hello, i live in a rent stabilized building on the ues on a very nice address. Recently our building was sold from an 88 year old building owner to a new investment group. I have sublease (which i have signed on paper) under prime tenant who has not been living in my rent stabilized apartment all year. He's working in a different state but wants to keep the apartment for future use. Recently the... [more]
hello, i live in a rent stabilized building on the ues on a very nice address. Recently our building was sold from an 88 year old building owner to a new investment group. I have sublease (which i have signed on paper) under prime tenant who has not been living in my rent stabilized apartment all year. He's working in a different state but wants to keep the apartment for future use. Recently the new management group noticed he has not been a primary resident of the state of NY, meaning he has been outside the city more than 183 days. I also noticed that the new management group rent for my unit was only 1,200 although I had been sending the prime tenant 1,500 for rent monthly. The new management group (who wish to renovate the aprt and list at higher price) just mailed the prime tenant who lives in another state a notice saying they will not renew his lease when it expires august 31. The old building owner/management was aware that I was a subtenant but I am not sure my prime tenant has notified the new management group which took over in May. What rights do I as a subtenant have? I signed a lease for 18 months going to January 31, 2008. If they refuse to renew the prime tenants lease because of a rent stabilization violation (not living in the city, residence in a different state), does that mean i'm forced out also? I really like where I'm living and do not wish to move. I feel somewhat deceived and would be so thankful for anyone who takes the time to help me out. any thoughts or suggestions greatly appreciated. [less]
sorry i accidently posted this twice.
Hmm. Hoping a L/T lawyer will chime in, but my feeling is that the new owners are not obligated to honor a contract the the leaseholder had no right to make. In other words if he is violation of his contract such that his prior assumed rights to have a lease past 8/31 are taken away, your "lease" would become null and void because he does not posess the space to offer to you. Having said that you probably can work out a deal with the new sellers to allow you to stay until the end of "your" lease and leave quietly thereafter. That would probably suit them better than potentially having to go through legal eviction of you. (I am not suggesting you would threaten that, but that possibility would definately be on their mind)
#3 here again--having said all that, if the prior ownership formally approved the sublease as opposed to simply "knowing" about it, that may change things
the former ownership was well aware of my sub-lease. It was indicated to him by the prime tenant (the person who i was leasing from) and confirmed in telephone conversation. He have our conversations dated and confirmed on phone records...
Phone conversations aren't worth much. You don't have proof of the content of the conversation.
Do you know the prime tenant's intentions at this point? If he doesn't plan to fight the loss of his lease, you can easily strike up a (written) agreement with the new owners to stay at the current rent until your sublease is up, and commit to leaving at that point. The owners won't want to spend the legal costs and time for a drawn-out battle. But of course consult a lawyer for help.
The argument for rent control was to allow long-term tenants to stay in buildings when they could no longer afford market rents, and some other story about maintaining the existing community.
So, you're not a long-term tenant, you know the prime tenant lied to an 88-year landlord to effectively steal a rent subsidy and you conspired with the prime tenant to sign a sub-lease from which you think you the new owners should be forced to continue to subsidize your sad self.
I'd love to help the new owners throw your crap on the front sidewalk. You're the living, breathing example of what's wrong with rent control and ethics in general.
Why is anybody offering advice to OP?? What he and the prime tenant been doing is blatantly unethical and arguably illegal, so why should anyone help him? OP, why don't you spend your time looking for a legit place to live instead of wasting your time posting crap like this?
I am very against rent stabilization and despise when people take advantage and get some holier than thou entitlement attitude, but fail to see what the OP has done wrong.Alot of rent stab leases permit the primary tenant to sublease for a certain duration of time provided they charge no more than a certain % above the rent. Now clearly the primary tenant charged the op "too much" but given that they signed a sublease agreement, and given that the primary owner was well aware of the sublease and of the fact that the OP was residing there, I don't see how the OP is at fault, and s/he is simply asking if theyr sublease will be honored.
try asking at www.tenant.net -- you'll get a lot of good advice :)
The same thing happened to me...I was the lease holder in Stuyvesant Town paying $849 for a one bedroom...I legally sublet my apartment and left New York for a two year period. When my lease was up they refused to renew based on the fact I was out of new york for more than one year. It happens and unfortunately there isn't much you can do about it.
Hey #9, what do you really think the answer is to the question of whether this supposed sub-lease will be honored? The prime tenant has a lease that is probably 50% away from market rents. The prime tenant created a sub-lease with the OP to keep a subsidy he is not entitled to, and he and the OP split the profit. The only loser is the 88-year old owner.
Obviously, the OP does not have written approval from the owner or he never would have posted the question. Now you ask whether the new owners should honor the sub-lease? What if this sub-lease expired in 2018?
This is why government should not get involved in regulating prices. Nobody wins. Except the people who shouldn't, like the prime tenant and the OP.
You sublease is with the tenant...it should have been co-signed with the landlord.
uh, goldie, this is #9, and this is really not my fight. Nor did I ask whether the sublease would be homored--I simply said that this was what the OP was asking. Do I think OP has a leg to stand on? Nope. My point was simply that much as I despise these rent regulations and the people who take advantage of them, I don't feel that OP deserved the nastiness thrown at him/her by a couple of posters (Note that this does not mean I feel he/she is entitled to said sublease--just that compared to some of the crappy behavior we read about on these boards I didnt feel the OP actually deserved the abuse)
wait wait wait you guys have it all wrong!!!!
I started this post. I the whole time have been mailing my 1500 rent by money order to the prime tenant. I was told from the start that the apartment was 1500 by the prime tenant and I honestly believed it. I thought hey, a 1 bedroom on the ues, less than 2 blocks from the park that makes sense.
well only did I learn that the real rent was only 1200 when the new management slipped a letter under the door saying what was due for May. I was completely shocked.
I contacted the Prime tenant and he confessed to me that he had charged more than 10% over but that was because the apartment was furnished. Only now do realize that even if the apartment is furnished a prime tenant still cannot charge more than 10%.
the new owners are aware that the prime tenant is not a primary resident, but they have not been informed that he has been overcharging me since the lease started last year.
I feel i have a right as sub-tenant to fulfill my lease running through 07' even though the new owners will not renew the prime tenants lease. For all i know the prime tenant kept the few extra hundred dollars he was making off this for himself. Remember I do have a contract with the prime tenant showing i agree to pay 1500, signed and dated.
I think a few of you mis-understand the situation.. I wish you would really read closely to what i'm saying. remember also that the previous owner was well aware that the prime tenant leasing to me, the subtenant even though he was well aware the prime tenant had been living in a differeant state for over a year.
help, follow ups , please. thank you all so much.
The landlords were being nice to allow the prime tenant to sublease, but you dont actually have much legal standing for your very good deal. Most things which are too good to be true - are just that. Sorry but rent stabilized apartments are intended for that original tenant not for subleases which are really likely illegal and below market for random sub-leases. I highly doubt you have much of a leg to stand on.
best of luck - from a recent market rate renter (who just bought).
If the sublease was always illegal (which it sounds like since the prime tenant was out of state), that contract is not valid. So what you have a contract for an illegal activity.
Your time is probably best used trying to find out where else you can live and afford because my bet is you will not have the privilege of this illegal sublet. You will have to do what the rest of us do. . . .get moving and searching.
The primary tenant pays $1200 and you seem to be complaining that he is charging you $1500 for a furnished apartment on the UES. You should be happy you had the apartment for as long as you did.
OP-- These posters have absolutely no idea what they are talking about. Under Rent Stabilization, the prime lessee may sublease for a period of up to two years. There is nothing "illegal" about subletting a rent stabilized apartment. However, the rent charged to you may not exceed more than 10% more than the rent charge the prime tenant. I didn't look at your numbers so you do the math. The prime tenant must also have properly given notice to the landlord regarding the sublease. There may be other rules/regs that must have been followed. Again, you very well may have the right to stay in the apartment provided the sublease was handled properly and the prime tenant very well may have the right to a renewal lease. I advise that you either consult with an attorney or google New York's Rent Stabilization law and regulations promulgated thereunder. New York City has a handy website which encapsulates said law (NYS Division of Housing and Community Renewal). I am an attorney, however, not a LL/tenant attorney so you should do further research. And please, do not seek legal advice on an anonymous forum. it is almost always completely incorrect.
#20 here-- I see that the rent charged to you exceeded the allotted sublease cap and thus your lease probably is invalid. Sorry.
OP-- These posters have absolutely no idea what they are talking about. Under Rent Stabilization, the prime lessee may sublease for a period of up to two years. There is nothing "illegal" about subletting a rent stabilized apartment. However, the rent charged to you may not exceed more than 10% more than the rent charge the prime tenant. I didn't look at your numbers so you do the math. The prime tenant must also have properly given notice to the landlord regarding the sublease. There may be other rules/regs that must have been followed. Again, you very well may have the right to stay in the apartment provided the sublease was handled properly and the prime tenant very well may have the right to a renewal lease. I advise that you either consult with an attorney or google New York's Rent Stabilization law and regulations promulgated thereunder. New York City has a handy website which encapsulates said law (NYS Division of Housing and Community Renewal). I am an attorney, however, not a LL/tenant attorney so you should do further research. And please, do not seek legal advice on an anonymous forum. it is almost always completely incorrect.
http://www.housingnyc.com/html/resources/faq/subletting.html
All you jealous idiots.... I am a prime tenenat of a 2 bed / 2 bath prime location rent stab apartment which I illegally sublet for over a $3000 profit. This helps me pay off my $3M loft. Hope that helps:_)
#24 do you feel good ripping off the landlord and also ripping off the subtenant..
Why should #24 feel guilty. The LL owns/bought the building knowing the unit(s) were rent stab and the subtenant is probably paying below market since most sublets are below market given the illegal nature and uncertainty.
OP, I think it's you who has it wrong - everyone on this post understands. You should be happy that you had the apt for as long as you did and start looking now for a new place. You were paying below-market rent and should have spent the time saving $$ instead of whining about being entitled to stay in your place and pay even less rent.
The prime tenant was ripping you off while violating the rent stablilization rules - and fortunately you both had a landlord who looked the other way. Bending the rules and working the system are very commonplace when NYC renting is concerned. Again, consider yourself having been lucky and move on.
#24/26--yet another reason to scrap rent stabilization/control
OP -- #6 and #10 offer you the best practical advice. Don't assume your new landlord is a greedy ogre who won't work with you for the several months until Feb 2008. He's in it for the long term.
Avoid the opinions of DHCR, the agency that oversees rent stabilization--they're tenant-hostile.
Others -- this is a legal/business question, not a moral play or matter of personal ideology -- even if you may be right on those points.