At the closing table today: "sellers have unrealistic expectations"
Started by WaxPoetic
over 19 years ago
Posts: 60
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
We closed on a Manhattan cooperative apartment today, [YIPPEE!] and the seller's broker noted that many sellers still think prices are as high as they were last year, but in reality prices are *down*. This has created a situation of unrealistic expectations and frustrated sellers. The two apartments that I would have bought one of, had we not got this lovely place, are STILL on the market -- I... [more]
We closed on a Manhattan cooperative apartment today, [YIPPEE!] and the seller's broker noted that many sellers still think prices are as high as they were last year, but in reality prices are *down*. This has created a situation of unrealistic expectations and frustrated sellers.
The two apartments that I would have bought one of, had we not got this lovely place, are STILL on the market -- I viewed them in March-April. We made an offer on one of them, our offer was flatly and nastily refused by the seller/broker, who changed her mind within 24 hours and wanted to counter-offer, but because her attitude was so hostile especially because I had already made more appointments for viewings by then, I put her off. That's when I saw our apartment, which I fell in love with!
Lesson No. One: If you're a seller, use RECENT data to set your asking price. That means within the last 6 months, tops. And never be nasty to somebody who offers you a low-ball offer because it's probably not their final offer and if you seem too unreasonable, they will keep looking, and if you re-consider their offer, it may be too late for you.
Lesson No. Two: If you're a well-qualified buyer, knock 10% off the asking price and make an offer. Yes, 10%. Remember, you can always go up but you can't go down. We ended up paying 6% less than asking price.
[less]
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007
Perhaps your post would be more helpful if you told us:
Where you bought (not the street address, of course, but at least the area and perhaps the cross streets to give us a more exact idea of where you're referring to)
How many beds/baths/square feet.
A general idea of the price range you were looking in.
Otherwise, for all we know, you bought in Inwood where the prices SHOULD be low and the sellers should NOT be overly aggressive.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 46
Member since: Aug 2006
Buyers are generally of the age where we don't need "lessons".
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 2841
Member since: Feb 2007
#1 thank you for your insight...#2,#3 you're obviously very nervous owners who do not want to fact reality...I too am a owner but am staying put and facing the facts.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007
#4 - how could I be nervous by simply asking some very basic questrions of the OP for better clarification? I would have to say the only one trhreatened and/or nervous is you, if asking some simple questions generates such an uptight response from you.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 214
Member since: Feb 2007
Agreed. The location, size, price and numerous other factors make all the difference when determining the state of the market.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 60
Member since: Apr 2007
HI, original poster here.
The apartment is in 10021 (that's upper east side), and under $500K. Mint condition, super nice building with stellar financials. I should emphasize, perhaps, that we didn't come in marginal financially, either; we were very well qualified buyers.
I was a little nervous offering a low-ball offer on an apartment I really loved, but the strategy paid off for me. Buyers (and sellers) might want to visit urbandigs.com for what I found to be outstanding advice.
BTW I received wonderful advice on this site, and the motivation for my post was to just offer a little something back.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 22
Member since: Jun 2007
to #7 (OP). I wonder what is considered well qualified buyers, since with co-ops, you need 20% down and liquid assets. Do co-ops really care as long as u meet this?
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 400
Member since: Apr 2007
Hey OP-- You're broker's a schmuck. Translation is that sellers with cheap crappy apartments like yours have unrealistic expectations.
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 1183
Member since: Feb 2007
Well, that explains alot. OP is buying in the UES for the under $500K range - a studio. Hardly a prime unit, especially on the UES - what, are you over by 2nd Avenue? No wonder you made the deal you did. Try to do that with a one bedroom facing the Park on Fifth in 10021....
Ignored comment.
Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 861
Member since: Apr 2007
No offense but how can anyone possibly think getting 6% off the listing price on a sub 500k apt teaches anybody anything about the market. Btw, do any of the doom and gloomers realize that these things are all relative to the rationality of the initial ask. I'm in contract to sell my 2 bedroom in the USq area for about 1% over ask. Does that prove the market is strong? But if I had priced it 10% higher (at a price higher than anyone has ever gotten in my building) and gotten what I got, it would be this sure sign of market collapse and the intelligence of the lowball approach. and #4, you're just an a$$.
Perhaps your post would be more helpful if you told us:
Where you bought (not the street address, of course, but at least the area and perhaps the cross streets to give us a more exact idea of where you're referring to)
How many beds/baths/square feet.
A general idea of the price range you were looking in.
Otherwise, for all we know, you bought in Inwood where the prices SHOULD be low and the sellers should NOT be overly aggressive.
Buyers are generally of the age where we don't need "lessons".
#1 thank you for your insight...#2,#3 you're obviously very nervous owners who do not want to fact reality...I too am a owner but am staying put and facing the facts.
#4 - how could I be nervous by simply asking some very basic questrions of the OP for better clarification? I would have to say the only one trhreatened and/or nervous is you, if asking some simple questions generates such an uptight response from you.
Agreed. The location, size, price and numerous other factors make all the difference when determining the state of the market.
HI, original poster here.
The apartment is in 10021 (that's upper east side), and under $500K. Mint condition, super nice building with stellar financials. I should emphasize, perhaps, that we didn't come in marginal financially, either; we were very well qualified buyers.
I was a little nervous offering a low-ball offer on an apartment I really loved, but the strategy paid off for me. Buyers (and sellers) might want to visit urbandigs.com for what I found to be outstanding advice.
BTW I received wonderful advice on this site, and the motivation for my post was to just offer a little something back.
to #7 (OP). I wonder what is considered well qualified buyers, since with co-ops, you need 20% down and liquid assets. Do co-ops really care as long as u meet this?
Hey OP-- You're broker's a schmuck. Translation is that sellers with cheap crappy apartments like yours have unrealistic expectations.
Well, that explains alot. OP is buying in the UES for the under $500K range - a studio. Hardly a prime unit, especially on the UES - what, are you over by 2nd Avenue? No wonder you made the deal you did. Try to do that with a one bedroom facing the Park on Fifth in 10021....
No offense but how can anyone possibly think getting 6% off the listing price on a sub 500k apt teaches anybody anything about the market. Btw, do any of the doom and gloomers realize that these things are all relative to the rationality of the initial ask. I'm in contract to sell my 2 bedroom in the USq area for about 1% over ask. Does that prove the market is strong? But if I had priced it 10% higher (at a price higher than anyone has ever gotten in my building) and gotten what I got, it would be this sure sign of market collapse and the intelligence of the lowball approach. and #4, you're just an a$$.
nuggits all around