Make no mistake home prices are headed down
Started by jake
over 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007
Discussion about
I think home prices will fall more than most think and for far longer than most think. Home prices doubled in many parts of the country between 2001 and 2006. Low mortgage rates, low levels of inflation, a change in the capital gains tax rate, the largest tax cut in history, lax lending standards and investors looking for the next new thing after the dot com bubble burst all contributed. 1) low... [more]
I think home prices will fall more than most think and for far longer than most think. Home prices doubled in many parts of the country between 2001 and 2006. Low mortgage rates, low levels of inflation, a change in the capital gains tax rate, the largest tax cut in history, lax lending standards and investors looking for the next new thing after the dot com bubble burst all contributed. 1) low mortgage rates - Alan Greenspan and the folks at the Fed kept the funds rate at 1.00% for 18 months in 2003 and 2004. Remember those fears about deflation and how the U.S. was starting to look like Japan in 1990? 2) Low inflation meant that real incomes were rising. Home buyers were keeping more of their income to spend on things like housing because food and energy were relatively cheap. 3) Lower capital gains rates meant that gains on transfers of real property were taxed at one of the lowest rats in history and made speculating in real estate very attractive. condoflip.com and other web sites sprouted to expound on the virtues of flipping in and out of real property. 4) The Bush tax cuts were the largest in history and let all Americans keep more of what they earned particularly middle to high income earners. Home buyers with more income competed with each other for housing and bid up home prices. 5) Lax lending standards allowed previously unbankable borrowers to particpiate in the dream of home ownership. Additional demand from these borrowers bid up prices. Good and bad borrowers used exotic mortgage products to stretch for more house. As we have learned many of these borrowers could not afford the homes the lenders helped put them in. Looking to the future all of these variables point to home prices heading lower. 1) Interest rates are rising. Even after the Fed cut the funds rate by 325 basis points mortgage rates today are higher than last September when the first cuts were made. Lending standards are sharply tighter. It is much harder and much more expensive to get a loan to day than a it was a year ago. Given the losses posted at the banks and at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac it will be much harder to get a loan a year from now than it is today. And the Fed is now saying they are more concerned about inflation than growth and that the funds rate needs to be higher. 2) Inflation is going higher due to higher food and energy prices. Headline CPI will print 5.0% in August. We are spending a greater percentage of our incomes on food and energy. We have less to spend on housing. Real incomes are falling fast. 3,4) The tax cuts sunset in 2010. Budget deficits are rising and we have a war to pay for. Congress will not enact new tax cuts and we are headed for more tax and spend policies no matter who wins the White House. Americans will take home less and have less to spend on housing because of higher taxes. Take a look at the code on estate taxes which will incent people to die in 2010 versus 2011. This is America? 5) No more 10% down. Changes in the appraisal process. Over 100 lenders bankrupt. Tighter lending standards. Instead of condflip.com we got flippersintrouble.blog and iamfacingforeclosure.com! True. Check it out. I did not even mention the supply/demand inbalances that have inventories at 11 months of supply, unsold new developments taking down regional lenders like Suntrust, Key Bank and Nat City, and the fact that in many regions there are more foreclosed properties on the market than existing homes. Make no mistake home prices are headed down and will be for several more years. If you buy now it will be many years before you see prices return to what you are paying today. And yes New York City is still part of the USA. [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
17 Comments
-
9 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
8 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
No.
jake- Don't you know the crisis is over and Manhattan price never decrease.
jake, as dco said: real estate in Manhattan can only go up.
Manhattan is NOT part of USA.
None of those rules apply to Manhattan.
The foreigners will save Manhattan silly!
Wall St. and credit problems have absolutely NOTHING to do with Manhattan.
Get over it already. Stop trying to scare people here on this board.
All of us here are calm and happy now since- stop trying to scare people!!!
Stop trying to talk Manhattan real estate prices down to levels where you can afford something decent. It's just nonsense. Horrible, really. What kind of human being are you?
*yawn*
MMAFIa actually only gold goes up and real estate only goes down. Come on now get with the program
Jake is right and you guys are real estate brokers, let's face it !!
no more sweet deals...:)
Except on Park Avenue:
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/179439-condo-77-park-avenue-murray-hill-manhattan
Price History
02/04/2008
Listed in StreetEasy with Day Realty Associates at $1,150,000
02/13/2008
Price decreased to $1,125,000
03/15/2008
Price decreased to $1,100,000
04/18/2008
Price decreased to $989,000
04/22/2008
Price decreased to $985,000
04/29/2008
Price decreased to $984,000
04/30/2008
Price decreased to $959,000
05/08/2008
Price increased to $989,000
05/10/2008
Price decreased to $950,000
05/23/2008
Price decreased to $949,000
05/29/2008
Price increased to $951,000
06/15/2008
Price increased to $1,100,000
did u see the floorplan? your guests have to go through the kitchen to use the guest bathroom - this is not what Park Avenue is all about - sorry, won't sell so fast at this price range.
Okay - so on the serious side...what does one do now? I saw a 1 bdrm condo in a new development that I liked this weekend and am interested in purchasing but now I'm nervous that I'll still be paying too much (even with the recent price reduction). Should I make an offer or wait?
wait
at least 3 months from now
didn't you just back out of a deal?
Why are you in such a hurry to buy if you don't need to?
Wait.
In this market it is completely beyond me why one would purchase a new condo. Between the brand new finishes aging over the next 5-10 years and the tax abatement evaporating just in time to sell the place, I'd steer clear unless it is a sterling property in an established, excellent area with protected, good views and serviceable floorplan.
yes, spunky your are correct. gold and oil are both stupid to be going up these days. inflation is fake and nonexistent. our US dollars are worth more today than ever before. in fact, we need less US dollars to buy the same goods and services today compared to before.
ahh what idiots to think that inflation even exists? to think that oil and gold would go up? to *dare* think thank manhattan real estate could go down?
*smart* people like spunky know that:
1. Manhattan real estate only goes up
2. Commodities like Oil and Gold can only go down
3. Anyone looking to rent in Manhattan's market today is an idiot when buying makes so much more sense
yes, people, those are what the *smart* people on this board think. get with the program silly!
Someone that choose a nickname like MMafia doesn't sound very reliable to me.
What's wrong mafia? you are not able to close a deal..afraid that peopled might be scared and wait?
don't underestimate people and don't call anybody idiot, behave.
MMaffia states the following:
1 Gold only goes up
2. Manhattan RE only goes down
3. MMAfia is never wrong.
BTW MMafia has been recommending buying gold when it was at 980,970,960,950 and 940 and ounce.
steve - i didn't just back out of any deals. thanks.
And, for a bit of fun, the guy behind HousingPredictor used to run RealEstateAdd.com. In fact, that site is forwarded to HousingPredictor. And let's see how reliable those predictions were. Here's his prediction from 2005: "The state of Texas may provide the next big boom market in
the nation. The U.S. Census Bureau says 46% of the nation's
population will live in Texas, California and Florida by 2030.
All three states are gaining in population. Despite the series of
hurricanes to hit Florida over the last two years, 1,100 people
a day are moving to the sunshine state, according to state
officials." You can find it at http://thephantomwriters.com/free_content/d/c/real-estate-ma… The title? "Real Estate Markets Heating Up Reports Real Estate Add." Nice prediction--top of the market we hear that Florida, California, and Texas are "heating up."
Then that was somebody else - sorry!
I wouldn't be in a hurry to buy anything unless you're absolutely positive that you're going to be staying there for a very long time and can afford it with a standard 30-year 80/20 mortgage. Anything else is real-estate roulette, in my opinion.
I agree with spunky - it's very easy to predict that prices are going up when prices are going up, and that prices are going down when prices are going down.
Much harder it is to predict that prices are going down when prices are going up. Therefore, I retract everything I've ever said: spunky's right, prices are going up, and Citigroup is a good stock to own.
It's hard to believe that the "Manhattan Real Estate Market" will fall in any kind of a uniform manner. Back in the early 90s, there was a tremendous over-supply of 1-Bedroom apartments, and it really seemed like 1BRs took a much bigger hit than other sized apartments (e.g. were 3BR apartments impacted at all in the early 90s??). I wonder if a similar thing will happen this time, except in reverse. Seems like large (3-4 BR) luxury apartments have been overbuilt this time around, and when executive-types relocate to another city, they will certainly be selling 3-4 BR apartments. Also, that segment probably quadrupled in value over the past 10 years or so. Wouldn't those apartments take the biggest hit? If so, maybe smaller units won't see much of a downturn at all. Just a thought.
In addtion to the issues I started the thread with which are nationwide problems, Manhattan has the added features of layoffs in the financial sector and the prospect for much lower pay going forward. Also, who pays that 11% coupon I was receiving on my Yonkers munis because of the failed adjustable rate auction? Who pays for the higher coupons on the state dormitory bonds? That's right it is you the tax payer. State and local taxes are also going up. And it means less income to spend on real estate.
And Obama wants to raise taxes on people who make over $250k a year - not only income taxes, but payroll taxes which are more onerous at a flat 6.5% of income more or less.
The State Assembly also wants to put a tax surcharge on high wage-earners.
Property tax rates will have to rise in NYC to offset the decline in value and reduced income-tax revenue. Property taxes are levied on condos at a much higher rate than older co-ops, and both of those have much higher tax rates than single-family houses in, say, the outer boroughs.
Ergo, Manhattan is going to bear the brunt of tax increases.
Yipee!
"BTW MMafia has been recommending buying gold when it was at 980,970,960,950 and 940 and ounce."
LOL liar! Nice try though spunky brewster. Don't make me pull up links to the good 'ol threads and call you out.
"Someone that choose a nickname like MMafia doesn't sound very reliable to me.
What's wrong mafia? you are not able to close a deal..afraid that peopled might be scared and wait?
don't underestimate people and don't call anybody idiot, behave."
Swit, come on now- EVERYBODY knows that Manhattan real estate only goes up!!! It can only go up. It's the best investment around in the world for crying out loud!!! Why do you think all the foreigners are buying? PEOPLE, listen up- BUY don't rent!!! Who on earth would want to rent now?
Only those who get scared off by reading lies on the internet. Don't get swindled!! Manhattan ONLY GOES UP!!!! BUY NOW!!! Wall St. layoffs have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with Manhattan real estate! Look at all the SMART foreigners buying!!!!
Does MMAfia remind anyone of any of the Howard Stern show characters?
Gary the Retard?