Large Co-op drop?
Started by mbz
over 18 years ago
Posts: 238
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
Steve, I noticed the Co-op index you track took a big drop. Is this accurate? Thoughts? http://350bleecker.com/policy/sales.html
That website is accurate.
I would be extremely wary of comparing per-share prices across apartment types. The recent sales were three-room apartments (i.e. one bedroom). The peak sales were five-room apartments (two or three bedrooms.) There might be a trend, but more likely what you're seeing is a sampling effect.
That is true, plus LJ is a really shitty apartment.
That said, there's this:
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/196813-coop-350-bleecker-street-west-village-manhattan
That's quite a drop in asking price:
Price History
03/21/2008 Listed in StreetEasy with Elliman at $2,695,000
05/04/2008 Price decreased to $2,450,000
06/06/2008 Price decreased to $2,250,000
Nonetheless, the initial asking price was a 110% increase in just 4 years:
08/04/04 3DEF $1,282,000
See how outrageous things got? 20% PER YEAR!
LMAO.
Even the current price would be a 15% per annum increase in 4 years.
It's nonsense.
Then let's look at this listing:
3WX** 2-BR/2-Bath $1,632,000
01/24/07 3W $433,000
09/03/03 3X $335,000
Total: $768,000 over 4 years.
Or 112.5% in four years.
Never in the HISTORY OF THE WORLD has real estate gone up so so much so fast and stayed there. Anybody who doesn't see a massive correction right back to 2003 is fooling themselves, or just not reading the news.
> There might be a trend, but more likely what you're seeing is a sampling effect.
Whats funny is that no bull cares about the same *very* pronounced effect in the median market numbers, but its like the first thing that gets mentioned here...
EddieWilson: I'm a bear; I just understand a bit of elementary statistics (as well as lies and damn lies).
I make exactly the same comment when stats are misinterpreted in the other direction. The median sales numbers peddled by the industry are garbage. Actually, the numbers themselves are fine. It's the way they are spun that stinks.
Never in the history of the world.
lol