Maintenance
Started by tandare
over 18 years ago
Posts: 459
Member since: Jun 2008
Discussion about
Is there a ballpark figure for estimating what a maintenance "should" be in a building? e.g., ___ per square feet ??
depends on many factors, including the size of the building and the amenities. if its a brownstone coop with 24 units or less, maintenance will be higher. If it s a huge complex with multiple amenities like a pool, garage, etc, it can also be high but less psf than a small coop. It depends.
tandare, as totallyanonymous said, there are too many factors and differences between buildings, so it's hard to put a concrete number in there. If I had to though, I'd say anything close to (or above) $2 per sqft is quite high. Somewhere between $1.20-$1.50 seems pretty good for a well maintained building with passable amenities. This might change with rising fuel costs, etc., but for now, that's what I'll stick to.
Nice clear answer there, ta.
My building has really low maintenance at around 0.85 per square foot. No fancy ammenities, but it's a full service building on Riverside Drive in the 100's.
yeah but $2.00 per square foot in a small coop is not out of the ordinary. there's less pockets to share the expenses in smaller buildings. Absolutely, if its a 34 story coop and the maintenance is north of $1.5 psf, then thats high.
Riv_Drive - but often unrealistically low maintenance leads to adoption of a hefty flip tax. The Master, at 310 Riverside, for example, has a flip tax of 5% of sales price or 10% of profit. While it's preferable to "pay later", there is no free lunch.
True - we used to have $10/share, but we just adopted a 2.5% of sales price flip tax. In this economy, I'd rather pay later.
High flip taxes artificially bring down the cost of maintenance. Coop Village in LES charges well below $1.00/psf maint which includes property taxes. To the advantage of future purchasers, 1st sales after reconstitution are charged over 15% of selling price and 2nd sales are 5%. There's lots of original occupants still living there and as the older folks die, they're looking at some big flip tax incomes. The downside to the flip tax is that psf are lower than the rest of the market.
Riv_Drive - In ANY economy, I'd rather pay later. Flip taxes, even as high as the one I mentioned, may not be a deal-killer, as long as there is a reasonable correlation between the eventual flip tax to be paid, and the "presumed" monthly maintenance $$$ saved.
Savvy buyers will evaluate the flip tax / maintenance trade-off, and act accordingly. There are some buyers who will avoid buildings with a flip tax entirely - even if that's not always the wisest move.
Flip taxes are bad for people who intend to live in a place short term. You won't benefit from low maintenance and still have to pay the fee upon exit. It usually means a 5 year minimum time frame.
I think profit from a sale that is paid as a flip tax is deducted from the amount on which you have to pay capital gains. If correct, this means you receive a better tax advantage by paying lower maintenance and a flip tax than higher maintenance for years on end. Also, special assessments are tax deductible for capital gains purposes, so in that sense it is better to impose periodic special assessments than to keep increasing maintenance to pay for capital improvements to the building.
$2/ft is high by any standard. With labor and fuel costs continuing to escalate, it is all but certain that maintenance fees will be going up all over. If a building already has high maintenance, you better factor in what these further increases will do to the value upon resale--granted increases will be had across the market, but at the high end they really stand out to buyers. I think $1.50/sq. ft. is about as high as I'd go right now and it better either be reflected in a substantially lower asking price that takes it into account or be for an apartment building with stellar and wide-ranging amenities that you want and will use.
Thanks for all the great information -- very informative.
I wish real estate listings were more standardized so it would be easier to search for buildings with lower maintenances or which buildings had low maintenance but some flip taxes. I'm very hesitant about buildings with higher maintenance fees b/c like those have posted here, we just figure fuel costs and such are only going to go up....
avoid co-op conversions with more than 20% original owner tenants from the conversion and/or rent control or rent stabilized tenants. Their financials are as a general rule going to be much more sloppy than a condo.
@urnfna -- what buildings would meet that criteria?
Realize high maintenance alone is not a reason to steer clear if the building is well-managed (your attorney will figure this out during due diligence) AND the cost of the apartment is lower by a degree that adequately reflects the higher maintenance. The Chelsea Mews at 148 West 23rd St is an example of a well-run building with relatively high maintenance but apt. costs that are well-below the market. the combination may be right for some people.
Someone mentioned 310 RSD's high flip tax. True, but that building also has a very liberal sublet policy, which helps make buying property there a pretty decent long-term investment.
Liberal sublet policy also makes for lousy long-term living. I, for one, have no desire to live in a building full of subletters. People with a stake in the building make for better neighbors. Investors do not.