Are you kidding me? I cry but my tears are from laughter
Started by jake
over 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007
Discussion about
After 106 days on the market this apartment is taking off. We move the lsiting from Corcoran to Elliman and voila! the apartment miraculously grows by 50 s.f. And since it didn't sell at $3.350 the Corocoran broker thought lowering the price to $3.195mm might be a good idea. Well it did not sell there either so that must be the wrong strategy says the Elliman broker. List it for higher than the... [more]
After 106 days on the market this apartment is taking off. We move the lsiting from Corcoran to Elliman and voila! the apartment miraculously grows by 50 s.f. And since it didn't sell at $3.350 the Corocoran broker thought lowering the price to $3.195mm might be a good idea. Well it did not sell there either so that must be the wrong strategy says the Elliman broker. List it for higher than the original ask at $3,420. That'll get the trafic coming through the door. Prices are definitely up since March 11th, right? http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/316505-condo-200-east-89th-street-yorkville-manhattan http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/192202-condo-200-east-89th-street-yorkville-manhattan [less]
the market is on fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiire! he must have been an idiot for listing so low in the first place! money is so easy right now, i heard the interest only jumbos are a no brainer!
I know you believe this is funny but what really happens is a standstill. No one selling, no one buying.
julia: and who do you think is hurting more? the seller who is paying mortgage on an empty house, or the buyers who are paying half the rent (compared to buying) on a house they live in?
It's ridiculous because after you buy it, you still have the (significant) expense of putting the units together and trying to create an effortlees flow from two mirrored apartments (plus the agita of dealing with the board to get approval). And add to that the yacky neighborhood....
If you're intent on buying a 4 bedroom unit for $3.5MM+ (after renovation costs), you can find a nicer one (for less), that's for sure.
The problem is time......how long before sellers start to face reality???
empty house?
thats a hot mess and needs too much work for that price. simple.
Wow this strategy is catching on. Take a look at 16A in the Richmond. Good thing these guys did not let the first broker sell it for the lower price. 95 days on market is a clear indication that it is priced too low and that we need to change brokers.
$3,975mm
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/333231-condo-201-east-80th-street-yorkville-manhattan
$4,250mm
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/194564-condo-201-east-80th-street-yorkville-manhattan
Either way a nice profit for these owners who bought it 3 years ago. Maybe because the apartment miraculously grew by 109 sf2 since they bought it.
Closed 09/30/2005 for $2.725mm with 2,141 ft2
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/closing/34930
The tricky "tactics" these sellers are using are frankly insulting - especially to a target audience that is going to spend $4M+ for an apartment. And the blatant changing of the sq. ft. constitutes fraud in my book.
These people really want $1400 and nearly $1900 / sq. ft. for Yorkville?!?!? If I ever pay over 800/sq.ft. to live in "Yorkville", kill me.
"I know you believe this is funny but what really happens is a standstill. No one selling, no one buying."
We all know what happens after the standstill.
Unless, of course, Manhattan is different and people here aren't humans but Martians.
MMAfia, you don't think Manhattan is different? We just went through the largest housing bubble in history, a credit crisis, economic slow down, revamping of lending standards, and with all of this.....prices have held steady. Forget about all of the doom and gloom prognostications, over the last year Manhattan has acted very differently than the rest of the country. How can this be unless Manhattan is different?
> and with all of this.....prices have held steady.
Have they really? What are you basing this on?
And I agree that Manhattan is very different, its less about the economy overall than Wall Street. And now Wall Street is completely f*ed, likely worse than the economy. So we're going to get spanked even more...
"How can this be unless Manhattan is different?"
I agree Juice, Manhattan is different. Its an island, finance capital, global hub, 24 hour city, etc. The question is not whether it is different, but whether that (and more) is already reflected in prices. $1mm gets you some mediocre cookie cutter 1bd room here. In most of the rest of the country, that gets you a huge house with a plot of land that you can retire on. Just about every major area in the U.S. had its reasons for "it being different." Miami was all about being an international hub to latin america, huge immigration, snow birds, great weather, no state tax, tourism, night life, etc. And those things are still true about Miami - but are prices the same?
"We just went through the largest housing bubble "
As far as I know, we are still going through it. According to Case Schiller, Miami prices didn't start coming down until beginning of 07, even after everyone thought it was way beyond time given the ugly dynamics going on there and anecdotes of severe weakness. There is always a lag. And guess what -today, Miami is down 31% from peak in Jan 07 and still falling.
I don't begrudge those who choose not to sell now, or who even choose to buy places now in nyc. Why should I, it's not my money? But at least go in with a full understanding of what is going on and then make the calculated risk based on your true upside/downside than go blindly forward based on a blanket statement which may or may not be true.
good point why should anyone buy an apt in Manhattan??????? Maybe because they can afford too not like me and most others who post on these boards.
"Have they really? What are you basing this on?"
EW, I'm basing this on info I got from the Quinnipiac University Polling Institute
"And I agree that Manhattan is very different, its less about the economy overall than Wall Street. And now Wall Street is completely f*ed, likely worse than the economy."
I don't disagree EW and this has been my point all along. Manhattan is facing different issues than the rest of the country. This will result in different solutions / reactions which will result in a different impact to the real estate market. If we want to compare what is going on today in NYC with something, than we should compare it to other wall st. slowdowns, not the speculative bubble that burst in Miami.
So even you and I agree that the issues are different and that Manhattan is different. Why does MMAfia constantly make Martian jokes about people that think Manhattan is different?
“But at least go in with a full understanding of what is going on and then make the calculated risk based on your true upside/downside than go blindly forward based on a blanket statement which may or may not be true.”
Special_K, I don’t think anyone on this board would argue differently
Well said, Special K.
> "Have they really? What are you basing this on?"
> EW, I'm basing this on info I got from the Quinnipiac University Polling Institute
Pricing data is coming from a poll? Huh?
> If we want to compare what is going on today in NYC with something, than we
> should compare it to other wall st. slowdowns, not the speculative bubble that burst in Miami.
So, '89? 70s? Didn't one bedroom condos lose half their value at one point?
"Pricing data is coming from a poll? Huh?"
Yes, Quinnipiac University Polling Institute polled three and a half owners in the West Village and asked the following question:
Have prices Remained Steady or Gone Down. The breakthrough results confirmed that indeed, prices have held steady.
"So, '89? 70s? Didn't one bedroom condos lose half their value at one point?"
Let's compare the factors that caused the decline and see if they still ring true. What about 2001?
"Yes, Quinnipiac University Polling Institute polled three and a half owners in the West Village and asked the following question:"
Oh yeah, the Perfitz poll. I know that one.... Later he said prices doubled, so I think we have that proven now, too.
> Let's compare the factors that caused the decline and see if they still ring true. What about 2001?
2001 wasn't a RE crash...
Also, the biggest factor nowawdays - the unprecedented run-up - is more of a factor than it ever was. Outside of that, job losses - check, recession - check, inflation - check, oil price explosion - check.
What else you got.
"2001 wasn't a RE crash"
But it was a wall st slowdown wasn't it?
That was cut short by way too many fed rate reductions that created the housing bubble...
The blowback never really happened, and, if anything, its going to make the blowback now even worse. All it did was delay much of the worst until the next bubble pop... which is now.