Artificially limiting supply?
Started by cj2008
about 18 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
Can anyone comment on what seems to be a new trend by brokers/sponsors to artificially limit the supply of a new development? I've noticed several developments that are due to come on line shortly--mostly from the Developer's Group--that mention X amount of total units but only list Y. Why are they not offering the full listings out? Do they think they can drive demand by limiting the number of units they list and showing progress on those? Any thoughts would be appreciated.
why do you think this is a new trend? managing the pacing of listing is an old practice.
cj2008-- "Do they think they can drive demand by limiting the number of units they list and showing progress on those? Any thoughts would be appreciated"
BINGO- You guessed it. It's well orchestrated, by the "NYC RE Marketing Machine", to keep inventory numbers low. Nothing is more devastating, to a RE market, then accelerating inventories. If you add all the New Construction units, to the inventory numbers tomorrow, it would double. There are thousands of units not counted in the current inventory numbers. This will also get worse, as new developments, try to close. Many buyers, that have signed contracts for a year or more, will find it very difficult to get a mortgage. If you don't have 20% and the proper income, you're going to find it very difficult or impossible to get the mortgage. Of course this will force more units back on the market.
cj2008- Kudos for the observation.
Agree that rolling out units in "phases" is nothing new.
While there may be some legitimate reasons for introducing in stages (budgeting, project management, etc.), there's no denying that the main effect is to limit the inventory and to try to build a sense of urgency for the "few remaining units".
In "normal" times (i.e., a rising market), introducing in phases has the added benefit of selling units in later phases at moderately to substantially higher prices.
its not new. its been a practice for at least the decade i have been looking at nyc apartments.
thanks all for the feedback. lorenzonyc, you're obviously the man in nyc real estate. been at it a long time huh?