DB analyst sees further drop in NY/NJ home prices of 31%
Started by jake
about 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007
Discussion about
DB analyst Karen Weaver on US home prices: Different MSAs reached their home price peaks at different points in the cycle. For those MSAs in Figure 1, the respective home price peaks for each MSA are shown at the top of the bar. The home price peaks range from 4Q 2005 (in Las Vegas, NV) to 2Q 2007 (in New York/NJ and Orange County, CA). We believe this is the main reason why some of the MSAs are... [more]
DB analyst Karen Weaver on US home prices: Different MSAs reached their home price peaks at different points in the cycle. For those MSAs in Figure 1, the respective home price peaks for each MSA are shown at the top of the bar. The home price peaks range from 4Q 2005 (in Las Vegas, NV) to 2Q 2007 (in New York/NJ and Orange County, CA). We believe this is the main reason why some of the MSAs are near bottom (at least on the fundamentals), while others, such as New York, appear to have much more correcting to come. It also highlights, once again, the importance of looking at individual markets and the insight that is lost in nationwide figures. Looking over the 100 markets written up in this report, we see some markets clearly under siege, with rising unemployment, high inventory levels and a disproportionately high level of foreclosures (e.g. Las Vegas, Miami or Orlando). But there are also those markets (unfortunately fewer and often smaller) that have low unemployment, low inventory and never were particularly reliant on subprime or jumbo lending (e.g. Dallas). Figure 5: Deutsche Bank%u2019s peak-to-trough and current-to-trough home price outlook for 100 U.S. metropolitan areas a DB Home Price Outlook b MSA Peak-to-Trough (%)1 Current-to-Trough2 Los Angeles -43.4% -21.5% Riverside -46.7% -17.6% NY/NJ -38.6% -31.2% DC Metro -42.9% -31.4% Orange County -34.9% -14.5% San Diego Essentially for NY/NJ prices have come down about 8% and will adjust downward by another 31%. NY/NJ is only about 1/4 of the way through this correction. [less]
Can you provide the link?
Stop with the nonsense, this is NYC, stop comparing it to Miami.
Sorry I do not have the link. DB sent it to me as a pdf. Sun sentinel picked up the report in may. maybe they will pick this one up as well.
http://weblogs.sun-sentinel.com/business/realestate/housekeys/blog/May08_Home_Price_Update.pdf
Not sure I buy the theory of a complete mean reversion, but there is some food for thought.
It's also worth noting that the NY/NJ MSA is essentially the tri-state area so one can assume there will be pockets which would fare worse and others than would fare better if one gives the forecast any credence...
Thanks for the article, jake.
It is interesting to ponder that within the NY/NJ MSA "area" different areas like Manhattan peaked even later than the MSA "area" peak of 2Q2007. Accordingly, Manhattan may have further to correct than the rest of the MSA which has already corrected modestly.
I'm guessing that Manhattan peaked about 1Q2008.
That is eaxaclty right tricks 73.
One point the research piece makes is that the areas where there was not such a large run up in prices will not see such a large correction. For example, one could argue that the high concentration of coops with more stringent down payment requirements and limited investors helped to temper the run up in prices in NYC and therefore the downturn will not be anywhere near as severe.
The counter to that however is that the new condo developments did allow aggressive leverage, investors and flippers who never intended to live in the unit or to be a landlord.
It seems to me the bottom line is that prices are going down in NYC. There is much to debate about the magnitude of the price decline and the longevity of the price decline. You will be able to buy an apartment cheaper in the future. How much cheaper and how far into the future is difficult to say.
Thought you might find the following ten-year (Dec 97 to Dec 07) returns of interest:
Miller Samuel (Price Per Square Foot):
Manhattan Coops: +306%
Manhattan Condos: +274%
(I think the condo data may be better than the coop data.)
Case Shiller:
NY Metro Area: +236%
Bottom line: Manhattan has had a substantially great price run-up during this period than New York metro area.
Oops - I transposed the coop and condo data. Should read:
Manhattan Coops: +274%
Manhattan Condos: +306%
Reached a bottom. Funny.
When things are priced over $200/sqft in bumfuck, utah I wouldn't think any market has reached a bottom.
NYC is not Miami... but why do people forget than Manhattan real estate plunged 30% in the early 90s and why do they forget the most expensive words in the dictionary are "it's different this time"?
That is interesting. Funny how percentages work too. If prices rise 50% and then go down only 33% you wind up where you started. With a 275% increase and the forecasted 40% decline in the next year the 12 year home price appreciation would be about 60% or around 4% annualized.
You are talking about very long time periods. According to my calculations, the average annual price increase would have been:
NY Metro Area: 12.9%
Manhattan Co-ops: 14.1%
Manhattan Condos: 15.0%
I don't know how 'substantial' of a difference that is. It definitely shows you the power of compounding returns and why effective asset allocation is an important long term consideration.
What is curious to me is that the data does not seem to support the concept that surrounding communities are 'high beta' - as I have heard espoused in the past. If that were the case, one might have expected prices to climb faster during the good times in the NY Metro Area ex-Manhattan (e.g. Hoboken's revival). I wonder if this has an implication for price depreciation in those areas during a downturn.
Which is why the 30% in NYC in 1990s doesn't necessarily need to fully repeat itself but you probably need 20% at least. Depends what interest rates do, it was dictate what people can borrow, therefore afford, therefore pay.
High beta applies to "fringe" Manhattan markets like some of the dicey neighborhoods around prime Manhattan. It does not apply to Greenwich, CT and other prime areas of the New York metro area which represent large proportions of the market capitalization-weighted Case Shiller index.
With no doubt, $1.5mm Williamburg 1 beds for jackass single i-bankers will fall more than Park Ave coops. Not only are they fringe, but they are generally bought by people who need to borrow more.
thrinald:
"NYC is not Miami... but why do people forget than Manhattan real estate plunged 30% in the early 90s and why do they forget the most expensive words in the dictionary are 'it's different this time'?"
I think John Kenneth Galbraith said it best,
"Contributing to...euphoria are two further factors little noted in our time or in past times. The first is the extreme brevity of the financial memory. ...There can be few fields of human endeavor in which history counts for so little as in the world of finance. Past experience, to the extent that it is part of memory at all, is dismissed as the primitive refuge of those who do not have the insight to appreciate the incredible wonders of the present."
A Short History of Financial Euphoria, Viking, 1990
I don't mind people ignoring history...It annoying when they say the 90s didn't happen in Manhattan. And in the late 90s prices were very low and the economy was strong...so its not like you need a massive recession...the '91-92 was historically mild.
"Let us be thankful for the fools. But for them the rest of us could not succeed."
Mark Twain
The problem is the market can stay irrational far longer than we can stay solvent. Who knows how high interest rates can get and how soon. Clearly the differences in Manhattan this time are interest rates and crime. The former can probably change faster than the latter but who knows.
The problem is the market can stay irrational far longer than we can stay solvent. Who knows how high interest rates can get and how soon. Clearly the differences in Manhattan this time are interest rates and crime. The former can probably change faster than the latter but who knows.
Quotes by smart men...
1. Miami, 2005 - Home prices are only going up. Time to buy
2. Miami, 2006 - Home prices cant fall from here, time to buy
3. Wall street executives, 2007 - Home prices cant fall more than x percent nationwide, lets double down on this. Time to buy
4. NYC 2008 - NYC is not Miami. Time to buy
BTW - All of us here venting at Bear, Lehman, UBS, Wachovia etc for not reading the writing on the wall or being too bullish - give credit to DB for at least attempting to point out what NYC can do. write or wrong, they tried.