Average prices down 7%, median 6% in Manhattan
Started by cccharley
about 18 years ago
Posts: 903
Member since: Sep 2008
Discussion about
It has finally started! Let the fun begin
you have a link?
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/14/realestate/14deal2.html?ref=realestate
May not seem like much but it's always worse than it seems. Wait till after this winter non bonus season kicks in
i read that article and it actually says "above the levels of a year ago. "
so prices are down modestly from last quarter but up from a year ago. That is called a YOY gain.
Read it how you like - it will get worse = much worse. Everything is getting worse not better
It includes a lot of low-end in Harlem. Interesting, nonetheless.
thanks ccc... 6-7& qoq is huge, but all these movements are clouded by mix issues. just like the yoy gains from last Q were completely skewed by new condo construction signed at the peak. anyways, i agree that things accelerate down from here.
You can also read into it even though there is lots of low end it's the only thing really selling bc everything else is overpriced
I still don't understand, why anybody would be buying, in this market. Every indicator is pointing to a huge NYC correction. The new inventory alone would bring prices down, now add in job lose/uncertainty, tighter credit (Just about everything, is a JUMBO) and a weakening economy.
The best play in the next year will actually be stocks. I will be waiting for the 30% mark and then I will be very comfortable, being long stocks. I much rather use my potential down-payment, to buy stocks at that point. Th troubles weighing on the economy will keep housing falling for years ans a recovery even further away, making buying a much easier decision year from now.
I expect we will soon be hearing the mantra, "Buy the dip, buy the dip." Somewhat reminiscent of what we heard in the late nineties as regards stocks.
dco, i agree. people will be in for a shock when their "one way" real estate bets far underperform stocks over the next 5 years. nyc real estate is leveraged to all the worst parts of the economy: finance industry, european wealth, etc. And none of the problems have been discounted yet as a 2-year lag is typical (I've gone back and studied high end real estate in other markets - it almost always moves with a 1.5-2 year lag to the surrounding real estate market, both up and down). Stocks have already discounted fairly extreme levels of economic malaise and should generate pretty good returns if the economic situation simply stabilizes.
"I expect we will soon be hearing the mantra, "Buy the dip, buy the dip." Somewhat reminiscent of what we heard in the late nineties as regards stocks."
Yep. I find it funny how stupid people make the same investment mistakes across different asset classes. I have a friend who lost a lot in equities over the years. He wanted to invest in real estate...but waited until about a year ago! He just closed on another place in a marginal neighborhood. His places have nowhere to go but down.
The same folks who will be saying "buy the dips" next month will, in 5 yrs, be saying "real estate is the worst investment ever!". And that will be a buy signal to the rest of us!
And the band played on.
In another posting I suggested supply has every reason to remain robust given current - and even moderately discounted - prices.
Let's assume it costs around $400 per square foot to construct an average residential apartment today.
I think you then have to add land costs. I believe these tend to run in the area of $200 per square foot. But presumably that figure can be spread over all the floors so it isn't a huge factor.
Kind of makes you edgy about paying even $1,200 a square foot for your new apartment.
No signs of a reduction of cranes on the horizon.
Nothing is moving. Follow the streeteasy figures:
Hovering around 8,000 listings not in contract, but total listings - including in contract - continuously fall, now down to just over 16,000. Meaning that what was in contract is closing, and everybody is trying to flip.
Lehman is the beginning of a precipitous fall in Manhattan real estate. I sold Merrill at $75 two years ago. It's down to $16 and change. It will be down to $9 Monday.
If Paulson thinks he can unwind Lehman without a government guarantee, he's sorely mistaken. If it goes belly-up on Monday, look for the next Great Depression. Dow down 3,000.
dco
about 8 hours ago
ignore this person
report abuse I still don't understand, why anybody would be buying, in this market. Every indicator is pointing to a huge NYC correction. The new inventory alone would bring prices down, now add in job lose/uncertainty, tighter credit (Just about everything, is a JUMBO) and a weakening economy.
The best play in the next year will actually be stocks. I will be waiting for the 30% mark and then I will be very comfortable, being long stocks. I much rather use my potential down-payment, to buy stocks at that point.
What? Are you on drugs? There is NO reason to buy an apartment? How about people want to buy a home rather than live in some rental box? How about that the potential decline in housing is still potential, you may have good data and be well thought, but you don't KNOW. And how about if the potential decline just isn't big enough for a buyer to worry about?
Then, best bet in stocks, sure they could be considered attractive. I also don't KNOW. Market timing is notoriously difficult. And what if stocks go down 29% and then start to rise? You will have missed your buying opportunity. How would you explain that? Why not be sensible and buy a little bit monthly from here on out regardless of decline or increase?
"There is NO reason to buy an apartment?"
No, none.
"How about people want to buy a home rather than live in some rental box? "
Rent somebody else's condo.
Very absolute point of view stevejhx.
I find inflexibility and absolutism boring. I'm sure most others here do too.
i find it boring when people feel the need to assume that most others agree with them. i am sure most others here do too.
Of course. And if that is your assumption, stating your position seems to be unnecessary unless you like to hear yourself talk.
Inflexibility, absolutism, and narcicism. What are the other sins? Greed, gluttony, ...
I think it really depends on the person.
I'd actually much rather be a Manhattan "owner" - all things being equal. There is, indeed, something to pride of ownership - and you can "customize" your "home" precisely to "your" tastes. Even if you do eventually sell, you will typically get a significant percent return on your improvements - even if not 100%. Admittedly, others place little value on some of these factors.
Alas, I just find the valuations so stretched for Manhattan residential property that I don't want to buy - "now."
In my view, Manhattan prices are now wildly out of synch with the rest of the country. And, of course, there are those nasty "price-to-rent" ratios which have doubled over the past ten years. Then there is the general Manhattan economic environment which is so sensitive to the prosperity of investment banks. I also think that price-to-replacement ratios are high; hence all the building that is taking place. More and more supply. And a buyers' strike.
I'd love to own - just really hope (and expect) that will occur at much lower prices.
linwhatever...stating that you are not qualified to state my position for me is essential...i did not say i agreed with steve or you, i merely object to your assuming everyone agrees with you...herd behaviour can be proven to be the root cause of every pain on this planet. and it always starts with some idiot stating "i am sure you agree with me" with a degree of great conviction and gravitas which somehow convinces the populace around that since he said it with so much confidence and in such a deep voice, it must be true, so let's follow him off the cliff..
learn to spell, don't be scared or at least be so obvious about it and get a sense of humour and / or irony (which is what my original post was...jeez)
lintintin "And what if stocks go down 29% and then start to rise? You will have missed your buying opportunity. How would you explain that? Why not be sensible and buy a little bit monthly from here on out regardless of decline or increase?"
I agree with dollar cost averaging. You misinterpreted what I said. I will START buying at 30%, because I still think, that their is much higher risk, of it falling even further. I also agree that calling a bottom is very difficult within 5-10% and clearly I think we have much more to go.
I have said this before and I'll say it again. Calling a bottom in housing is much easier then you think. It's much less liquid and it takes time for conditions to change. Brokers are the ones that like to say you can't call a bottom, because remember according to brokers "it's always the best time to buy". And to prove my point. Can someone tell me, one broker that has said, we will see declines greater then 5-10%? Out of thousands of Brokers in this city, not one see a large decline on the horizon. Give me a break. Just like the folks at CNBC, "this will signal the bottom" or a Bank CEO saying "we are well capitalized at this time and have no need to raise money". They have to lie, however all the ling in the world will not stop this train from derailing.
Lets have some fun. The following were or are events that have signaled the bottom and worst being behind us.
1. Bear
2. Countrywide
3. IndyMac
4. Fannie
5. Freddie
6. Lehman
Feel free to add to the list of bottom calling.
Now lets see the next bottoms.
1. WaMu
2. Merrill
3. Wachovia
4. Citi
5. GM
6. Ford
7. Chrysler
Again feel free to add. It going to get worse and the reason is simple. Housing will continue to fall.
NewYorkNewYork ... your argument style is so odd I can't even tell you are arguing with me except when you tell me I need to learn to spell and then use the word humour, which may be appropriate if your name is CanadaCanada or EnglandEngland, but certainly not NewYorkNewYork.
ps, is that ironic enough for you?
dco, how about the good economy? Companies that everyone has heard of, that are no stretch: J&J, McDonalds, Hershey. How about JP Morgan Chase which is down but has actually outperformed the S&P500 year-to-date? US Bank?
lastly, NewYorkNewYork, I'll put $20 on you being from the Indian subcontinent. Reading your gramatical style, spelling, and style of speaking leads me to that conclusion.
Not that there's anything wrong with that.
Just my forensic analysis of your writing.
lintintin- Sure their are "better" stocks, but there is no good economy. I wouldn't bet on Chase yet. Housing is still falling and as long as it does just about every bank will be in trouble. Just wait until prime borrowers start to go bad. Every model, resulting in the past loses, was based on sub-prime. What happens when "prime" borrowers start to go under, which logically would start to happen well after subprime loans. Then we'll see who's left standing. How about Credit Card debt? Watch CAPITOL ONE, they will one of the first. I could go on and on...... When you see the good economy let me know.
Rintintin: "Very absolute point of view stevejhx. I find inflexibility and absolutism boring. I'm sure most others here do too."
Inflexibility = Know what the fundamentals are. You don't like them, kewlness.
There are bright spots in the economy, which I don't think is in a recession. But what is happening in America is not what's happening on Wall Street, aka Manhattan, where it's triage. 50% down in a year. No one to buy what's for sale right now, and no one in the short- to mid-term either.
50% down. Lehman is the end. Merrill will be the double-end. AIG will be the triple end. WaMu will be the quadruple end.
Who will survive? JPM, BAC, Morgan Stanley, Goldman. All the rest are dead, as are their bonuses, the fiction of it, and the Manhattan market.
To stevejhx, as Fred Gwynne said to Joe Pesci in My Cousin Vinny, "are you on drugs son?"
stevejhx: kewlness?
What is 50% down in a year? Bonuses? Maybe. But bonuses aren't wealth, just as much as deficit isn't debt.
You'll find that the financial services industry still employs more than in 2002. You'll also find a large swath of private capital still being put to work or looking for places to be put to work.
Harvard is one excellent example of the private money out there. And they've been up, amazingly.
We officially have a new most tiresome pointless narcissistic know-it-all and to top it all off totally humorless poster. Give a hand to lintintin.
> so prices are down modestly from last quarter but up from a year ago. That is called a YOY gain.
And in 6 months, perfitz will be telling us, "yes, but its a decade over decade gain".
There are always a few geniuses to ride the market all the way down...
> You'll find that the financial services industry still employs more than in 2002.
And is still cutting.
And, where are prices relative to 2002?
Oh yeah, forgot about that part.
"Are you on drugs son?"
Nope, but thanks for asking.
"What is 50% down in a year?"
Stock prices. Some even more.
"But bonuses aren't wealth, just as much as deficit isn't debt."
What?
"the financial services industry still employs more than in 2002"
Of course - because in 2001 they cut 30% of their staff, after the dot.com bust.
And the financial services industry exists beyond NYC, and consists of low-wage earners like tellers, as well as high-stakes traders. Where the money is - at the high end - to support Manhattan prices, that is dead.
> "But bonuses aren't wealth, just as much as deficit isn't debt."
> What?
I think he means that salary/income isn't net worth.... that in theory these guys have a billion in the bank, so that doesn't matter.
But, problem is, their wealth went to crap, too.... a whole bunch of it was wrapped into company stock.
And the assumption that there was a ton of it in the first place, no so good. You think bankers are savers?
lintintin- I don't think anyone here is debating that, NYC has a tremendous amount of wealth. The problem is, that it's not spread out over tens of thousands of people. And the ones that have this money, already have a place they live.
Of course wealth people may look to trade up or perhaps buy another property, but it's not going to produce the demand of young rising professionals, that will see a huge set back, in earning potential over the next few years. In essence it isn't the total net worth, but how that net worth is distributed, that will drive demand.
Article says prices are actually up from last year not down. Still looking forward to the crash that was suppose to happen in 2005, sorry I meant to say 2006 oops sorry again 2007 oops sorry again 2008. The Manhattan RE crash is coming in 2009 and if doesn't come then 2010 for sure.
Spunky still has a little fight left in him...he's staggered on the ropes but he's still standing.
Spunky, prices will never decline? That's like the Romans saying that the Goths aren't ever going to cross the Danube. Nope. Ain'g gonna happen. If you haven't noticed sales volume has ground to a halt. Without volume prices don't tell you very much. Rich people (2-3MM+ apartment buyers) are still spending. But then it's really fun to spend money when everyone else is broke. As for everyone else, if you can't borrow, you can't buy. So the market has seized up. We haven't seen the worst. The worst is when one of these hot new condos defaults and the sponsor runs off with the buyer's deposits similar to how the Crazy Eddie guy ran off with the money back in the 90's? Anyway, there are more shoes to drop than just a Lehman insolvency.
As for financial services hiring, most of the headcount added since 2002 was in Credit Derivatives and Risk Management. The two places that Wall Street has failed most miserably. And there were some new hires in the technology infrastructure groups, they'll have jobs for life trying to piece together the infrastructure mess at whatever combined firms survive. And they make a couple hundred thousand a year so they'll take that 1BR for $550K. The Master's of the Universe days are coming to an end. I say until 2011.
The pendulum always swings too far - and too long. And then it swings back too far - and too long.
Certainly happened with stocks in the late nineties. Greenspan spoke about "irrational exuberance" in late 1996. But eventually things did, indeed, correct. (And they are probably still correcting.)
Ah, spunkster! Is it better to buy right now, or to rent?
don't know stevejhx. I've owned for over 10 years now and I must admit I'm not as smart as everyone who can time predict when Manhattan RE will be going down or up.
80sMan never said Manhattan prices will never decline. Never said they will continue up forever either. I can say with confidence that they will go up and down and be flat (not necessarily in that order) over the next 15 to 25 years. Picking the bottom and top should only be left to those who know how to time this market. The consensus feel that Manhattan RE will crash in 2008 and 2009. Why should anyone argue with that?
The market timers say 2010 will be bottom.
"down"
The first time I've heard spunky say that.
"Is it better to buy right now, or to rent?"
I do recall it was spunky who used to post that repeatedly on every thread where I posted. Seems even the brightest of the bulls feels a little tarnished: "don't know stevejhx."
linwhatever...you don't understand what I am saying because i am jumping from thought 1 to thought 10 -- because it is very hard (not to mention time-consuming) to remember the other person is not seeing 2-9...and there is an opportunity cost to my time if i start explaining from "once upon a time"..
i guess that confused you too eh ? really, get a sense of humour / humor...potatoes, potatoes, tomatoes, tomatoes....apartments, mbs, cds, gld, vix... it all comes and goes...be happy and find peace. and i am going to end this now because i find it awkward to write posts which contribute nil to the discussion at hand.
SORRY to everybody else (it was only meant to be one little humorous post earlier...boy, did i learn my lesson).
What's causing the significant disparity between list prices and current economic conditions? Factoring in circumstances surrounding Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac debacle, Lehman, etc.
lay off the curry NewYorkNewYork
Psychology.
Thats quite profound.
The mix issues only make it better not worse. Only desirable apartments are transacting in this market.
People who think its always a good time to invest for the long term are smoking crack. The time to buy for the long term is when things are cheap. It seems pretty clear the trajectory is down from here. Only question is how much and when will it bottom. Interest rates are too damn low, its will keep the market from crashing until it doesn't.
[excuse the nested quoting - needed for context]
""What is 50% down in a year?"
Stock prices. Some even more." - steve
Individual stocks, but not the market as a whole. S&P and Dow aren't 50% off their all-time highs. Nasdaq is, but that all-time high was in 2000. Old news. Its nowhere near 50% off its 5-year high.