Skip Navigation

Large Money Supply increases from fed's actions leads to increased asset prices

Started by steveF
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2319
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
Tony Cresenzi: I've been arguing that in order to facilitate the stabilization of financial firms and shore up the value of financial assets the Federal Reserve would have to expand its balance sheet. The Fed did so with a vengeance this week, according the new date released by Fed late yesterday. The Fed's H.4.1 release indicates that total Federal Reserve credit expanded by an average of $43.06... [more]
Response by serge07
about 18 years ago
Posts: 334
Member since: Aug 2008

I agree that there is the possibility of asset inflation as all this liquidity tries to find a hone. I've been adding to oil, copper, forestry positions. Hard assets may also benefit as an alternative to all the paper that will need to be printed to finance this fiasco.

As to RE, that will require debt financing and it is still unclear how these Treasury/Fed moves will increase the willingness of financial institutions to leverage their balance sheets, again. The details will be available next week and we'll see what ultimately is approved by Congress.

I will say that this business of the federal government running the world's largest hedge fund & having this type of control over the US economy is difficult to swallow. The massive deficit increase resulting from this will also is something the economy has to contend with.

Interesting times. I hope it works as intended.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

> with U.S. equities posting advances of over 20%.

I count 9.6% increase since the bottom. Where are they getting the other 10%?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by faustus
about 18 years ago
Posts: 230
Member since: Nov 2007

SteveF/serge07 - you are falling into the common trap that many others have as well, which is the belief that "if the Fed/central banks print money, we will definitely experience inflation" or hyperinflation, as even many folks believe.

Of course printing money is "inflationary", but it will only serve to partially offset deflation.

Here's why - the inflation/hyperinflation that so many are afraid of HAS ALREADY OCCURRED! We have already had 7 years of "too much money chasing too few goods", which was fueled by an enormous money supply consisting of monetary funds + CREDIT. That's right, we need to look at our standard definition of "money supply" and understand that in a credit-driven economy, it has to include credit. In Weimar Germany there was no credit, which is why so many people make the literal (and simplistic) association of inflation and hyperinflation with central bank printing presses.

But credit is an enormous component of money supply (for purposes of our inflation discussion). This even stands up intuitively - it was all that cheap credit that drove asset prices up, including your NYC apartment. Now where is all that credit?

It's gone. *poof* What we've experienced is a contraction of money supply the likes of which we've never seen before.

So will the Fed's printing cause inflation? Doubtful. Will it offset deflation? Sure, somewhat. Think of the money supply as a bucket that just emptied out due to the credit crisis. Fed printing may cover the bottom of the bucket.

The inflation we have had was credit-driven, exacerbated by a weak dollar (which has firmed although is pulling back a bit), aggregate global demand for oil and agricultural/energy policy.

So I wouldn't make economic decisions assuming we're going to have high inflation. We've already had it. This is a deflationary credit-contraction cycle. It's 1929 in the U.S., not 1923 in Germany.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by faustus
about 18 years ago
Posts: 230
Member since: Nov 2007

By the way, the Fed is NOT printing money.

The recent infusion from the Treasury consisted of:
(1) The Treasury issuing notes (at VERY low rates, mind you), which takes cash out of the system
(2) The Treasury depositing that cash with their savings bank, the Fed

What's happening to the Fed is that they're simply going from a risk-free enterprise to an investing, risk-assuming enterprise. They are becoming a hedge fund using their existing funds (i.e., not printing $$). They had $800B of cash and have invested much of that in:
(1) short-term notes to investment banks (Primary Dealer Credit Facility)
(2) an AIG note for $85B which pays a high interest rate and carries warrants
(3) some $29B in Notes backed by Bear Stearns assets
(4) up to $200B in Fannie/Freddie
etc.

The AIG investment actually sounds pretty sweet. There are some investors who are considering challenging the Fed for that investment.

The next investment is the bailout, i.e., severely discounted mortgage-backed securities. That bears risk, but they should be able to invest in them at tasty prices. Nor do they need to sell them anytime soon.

Yes, a ton of risk has been shifted to the Fed's balance sheet, but if they make a killing, damn will we be happy campers.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by junkman_r_u_serious
about 18 years ago
Posts: 230
Member since: May 2008

so this is what they meant by "investing" all those social security dollars....

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by serge07
about 18 years ago
Posts: 334
Member since: Aug 2008

faustus, good advice but we shall see. Among the strongest groups today & yesterday were industrial metals & energy. Gold has also been an excellent performer over the past several years & recently but I am not a gold bug. The forestry equities have been on fire, some at all time highs which is impressive performance given the recent carnage.

I do realize that the Fed is issuing Treasury notes in exchange for the toxic waste. Perhaps I'm mistaken but I suspect the notes will be sold by recipient institutions. I can't see them keeping low interest T-notes in their vaults if they expect earn a decent return on assets/capital. In any case, the Treasury will be flooding the economy with newly issued highly liquid T-Notes in exchange for non-marketable assets. That added liquidity combined with the other Fed measures taken this week, will seek what is perceived to be attractive asset classes. It usually does if we can use the past as an indicator. As investors, our mission is to find where. :)

BTW, I have never believed that the US had an inflation concern (not in the standard economic definition), not with stagnant wages combined with high productivity gains. Demand based on a historic credit expansion can create periods of growth but as we have seen, the story always ends the same, not pretty. As I'm sure you're aware, there is an unprecedented amount of paper assets floating around the global markets (significant amount of which is radio active) and based on market action, it seem that investors are looking to diversify into asset classes that are a tad harder.

AIG was a sweet deal for the Gov. It appears an investor group wishes to break the deal and arrange to repay the loan in exchange for the 79% equity. That was the news today.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jrd
about 18 years ago
Posts: 130
Member since: Jun 2008

To clarify faustus's post, the fed is not exchanging cash for collateral (which would increase M1), they are exchanging treasuries for collateral.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment