prime manhattan down 25% by next month
Started by anon3
about 18 years ago
Posts: 309
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
Seriously - 70% down by the time this is all over.....who would ever buy now? GET OUT WHILE YOU CAN. See the story: http://www.abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=5832116&page=1
Already posted.
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/5121-top-broker-nyc-real-estate-in-steep-decline
Rampant conjecture and speculation. You're yelling fire in a theater.
It seems apparent that the drying up of credit and sudden evaporation of wealth for a significant minority of the luxury apartment buying market will have a deleterious impact on the value of NYC real estate. How much of an impact, no one knows for sure. But to start making claims about specific percentage drops - and enormous 70% ones at that - is wholly irresponsible, baseless, and fails to take into account the very critical facts that:
A) There's a helluva lot of wealth out there that belongs to people who have nothing to do with I-Banking.
B) Unlike Miami, Vegas and other distant markets, the enormous increases in prices over the course of the boom was NOT exclusively or even primarily driven up by artificial demand from speculators.
C) Barring a return to Dinkins-era crime and filth, the City is, and will remain, a MAGNET for people from all over the region, country and world. People will sell their left testicle to be here, and they need a place to live. The demand here is constant and real.
D) The really coveted parts of town (below 96th st., Manhattan) constitutes an incredibly small area that ain't gettin any bigger.
E) Unlike the early 90s, interest rates remain near historic lows, and we're not facing a situation in which the immediate past's interest rates were so high as to make walking away from loans a prudent decision.
Be reasoned in your predictions of doom and gloom. Plenty of reason to believe there will be a decline, but also plenty of reason to assume that the other factors in place will serve as a bulwark against a catastrophic collapse.
"But to start making claims about specific percentage drops - and enormous 70% ones at that - is wholly irresponsible, baseless"
Like saying: "Prices will only go up. Buy now or you'll be priced out forever." Or all the brokers and recent buyers out there like SteveF saying "All is well! Buy now! Buy now!"
I love when people call others' comments "irresponsible". Because taking a guess or having an opinion contrary to your own is "irresponsible". SWK - try not to worry so much about what other people on Streeteasy say. It reeks of desperation. Relax, if their words affect the market, then the market is already screwed.
It's irresponsible because widespread panic can INDEED become a self-fulfilling prophecy, causing prices to decline at a much more precipitous rate than they 'should'. That's why I used the analogy of crying out 'fire in a theater' - you do that, and people start to panic, run for their lives, and put others in harm's way...all when there is no danger to worry about at all.
As I've said here repeatedly - I'm not suggesting that there won't be a dip in prices. All of the well-reasoned and oft-cited reasons indicate that one is inevitable. But a correction from the crazed highs may well be good for the market overall. What I really do not want to see is a situation in which panic causes an enormous and unwarranted decline many times worse than what the meltdown on Wall Street 'should' cause. 'Irresponsible' posts like anon's can be the harbinger of just that.
"the enormous increases in prices over the course of the boom was NOT exclusively or even primarily driven up by artificial demand from speculators."
Really? Have you looked at the number of flips in new development? Or the number of rentals offered for prices that can't possibly cover the carrying costs.
What drove up prices in Manhattan were the obscene bonuses paid by Wall Street for assuming an enormous amount of short-term risk. Those days are gone.
"Barring a return to Dinkins-era crime and filth, the City is, and will remain, a MAGNET for people from all over the region, country and world."
That don't mean they gotta live in Prime Manhattan.
"People will sell their left testicle to be here, and they need a place to live."
Women won't, and the fact is the population of Manhattan has grown by only 10,000 per year over the past 10 years.
"The demand here is constant and real."
Demand is everywhere - it depends on the price. And as someone who earns well into the 6 figures, but who lost a lot after they let Lehman go under, I can tell you that I'm not doing anything until the dust settles, and I recover my losses. I'm not alone.
"The really coveted parts of town (below 96th st., Manhattan) constitutes an incredibly small area that ain't gettin any bigger."
The size of an area does not affect prices. Shiller proved that by tracing the price of a single home in Amsterdam - where land is just as constrained - back 350 years. Prices are far more complex than just location.
Hell, 30 years ago nobody would live in Tribeca or SoHo. In fact, they didn't even exist. 100 years ago Bedford Stuyvesant - then Stuyvesant Heights - was one of the most luxurious neighborhoods in the country. Don't think that at the right price, Inwood won't be next.
"Unlike the early 90s, interest rates remain near historic lows, and we're not facing a situation in which the immediate past's interest rates were so high as to make walking away from loans a prudent decision."
Partially true - interest rates are low, but credit is tight and incomes are down significantly, especially from the engine of all of this, Wall Street. Ergo, I believe your entire argument to be fatally flawed.
Widespread optimism can also become self-fulfilling - it's called a bubble. Funny how people rush to squash panic but let euphoria run rampant. It seems to me we only end up with a panic after a period of unchecked euphoria. That begs the question of which is more irresponsible.
As for points A,B,C,D,E above - they are all priced into the market in my opinion and can only become sources of negative sentiment revisions going forward as those conditions deteriorate.
"A) There's a helluva lot of wealth out there that belongs to people who have nothing to do with I-Banking."
Right. That old argument. When prices were shooting up it was attributed to foreigners and Wall Street. Now, of course, Wall Street isn't a factor.
And let's look at foreigners. Global wealth has been hammered (foreign markets actually have performed worse than US markets this year), there is no credit, cash is absolutely king and psychology about the future of NYC real estate has turned decidedly negative. Not to mention, most currencies have actually declined against the $ in the past three months.
"B) Unlike Miami, Vegas and other distant markets, the enormous increases in prices over the course of the boom was NOT exclusively or even primarily driven up by artificial demand from speculators."
Yes, there have been plenty of speculators, but not as many. Let's look at the other drivers: foreigners (the last, dumb money in) whose luck has run out (see above) and who can't cover their costs by renting. These are second homes to them that suck up cash in an economic climate in which cash is at an absolute premium. Look for many foreigners to start selling.
"C) Barring a return to Dinkins-era crime and filth, the City is, and will remain, a MAGNET for people from all over the region, country and world. People will sell their left testicle to be here, and they need a place to live. The demand here is constant and real."
This is as simplistic as saying "demand exists". Again, yes people want to live here, but NOT at ANY price. It's nice to want to live somewhere, but then you have to decide how much you want to pay to do so. Looking at aggregate demand, it is FALLING. I can point to many reasons for that - falling employment, falling bonuses, falling incomes, socioeconomic outlook for NYC, etc. SWK - all you say is "people want to live her". That's a pretty empty argument.
As for crime and filth - no it's not the 80s, but the budget cutbacks around the corner will be of monumental proportions. Net net, services and infrastructure in this city will be declining, NOT improving. The result - schools, transport, safety and other municipal services that everyone takes for granted will either be cut back, cost everyone in NYC more, or, most likely, both.
"D) The really coveted parts of town (below 96th st., Manhattan) constitutes an incredibly small area that ain't gettin any bigger."
This is funny. Except for the fact that massive condo development continues, so yes, it is getting bigger. Hey, London and Miami aren't getting any bigger either, chief.
"E) Unlike the early 90s, interest rates remain near historic lows, and we're not facing a situation in which the immediate past's interest rates were so high as to make walking away from loans a prudent decision."
Now you need to set the crack pipe down. First of all, sates are low, but credit is available to a much smaller subset of people than as recently as one year ago. Secondly, jumbo loans are still non-conforming and expensive. Third, nobody looks back and compares today's rates to 1981.
Fourth - carrying costs are still way above rent for an equivalent unit.
SWK - did you buy recently? Are you selling an apartment now?
There is no question that the market is in for a more challenging period. However, most of the bloggers on this page are so fixated on the here and now. Instead, real estate historically has been, and always should be viewed, as a long duration asset. Sure - near term will be tougher. However, panic always results in opportunity, and Wall Street has ALWAYS reinvented itself and adapted to changing times. Let's face it, we are going through unprecedented challenges, but who would have thought NYC would thrive post 9/11, or post the recession in the early 90s, early 80s, the hell of the 70s, or any other challenging period. For those with capital, and liquidity, the next year or two will offer tremendous opportunity make money over the next decade.
"Wall Street has ALWAYS reinvented itself and adapted to changing times."
DIPIESA - THERE IS NO WALL STREET. You seem not to have been watching the news. There is no MER, LEH, BSC. MS is the next to merge, leaving only Goldman, who will be forced to merge.
The commercial bankers are now in control. They are conservative not only by nature, but by need: they get their money from cheap, federally-insured deposits. They have capital ratios to meet. They CAN'T take on the risks that the (former - RIP) investment bankers did, with 100x leverage. The regulators won't allow it.
There's nothing left to reinvent. It's dead. Forever.
"most of the bloggers on this page are so fixated on the here and now"
DIPIESA - hard to be interested in what the market will be in 20 years, can't predict it. We're interested in the immediate future because that's our decision period.
You could say the same thing about any investment - stocks, bonds, etc. "If you hold it long enough, you'll do fine". But it's an academic, not very helpful discussion.
"For those with capital, and liquidity, the next year or two will offer tremendous opportunity make money over the next decade."
Yes, as prices fall.
Steve - you're clearly a faster typer than I am.
DIPIESA, I think a lot of the posters here agree with you. The next 1-2 years will offer an opportunity to make money...AFTER prices fall to reflect economic realities.
The fact that real estate is an asset many people hold for the long term doesn't justify overpaying for it. Besides, as many have noted, the recent increases have been largely driven by outsized wall street compensation. It's unclear we'll return to 2006 comp levels for a long time (certainly wouldn't be surprising if it took more than 5 years). So, why think RE will retain its recent price levels.
After the market takes a 20-30% haircut may be an entirely different story....
faustus and steve - you both type faster than I do.
I'm living the news, so I'm all too familiar. However, many of my peers at Bear, now have rather lucratic contracts at JP Morgan. Once again, you are looking at the present time, and assuming it will stay this way forever, which history suggests otherwise. Moreover, if these commercial banks want to retain the franchise value of the investment banks they are acquiring, they will have to pay competitively otherwise talent will go elsewhere - it always does. Lastly, you assume many of the investment banks were always as they are today. This is just incorrect. Many of them have gone through many changes. In fact, Lehman Brothers has only been standalone since 1994 - does anyone recall it being a part of American Express? This is only one example. Dead - forever - how extreme.
Dipiesa - do u have any understanding of what just happened this past week? Please stop babbling nonsense. Over the next few months the fallout from last week will rain down on us. I work at one of the 2 remaining I Banks and anyone with a brain knows that they both will have to merge with a commerical bank; that is the only way they can compete.
Once congress starts passing regulations that limits the amount of leverage, goodbye ridiculous bonus. Do you have any idea how many hedge funds will go out of business as a result of the short selling rules? Long/short hedgies are effectively out of business now...we won't even mention the losses they incurred the past two days.
oh and by the way if you have some fantasy that the stock market will rise off of these levels you are incorrect. The market rally will end and start to drift back down to last weeks low levels
I 100% agree with all of your comments, but I'm trying to look out over the next 7 years to determine how to make money in real estate. As I said initially, the market will correct - no question. However, to assume that after its correction, that it will be DEAD forever as Steve suggested, seems outlandish. I get what happened, and I don't pretend to believe the market will rise off these levels, given the sluggish earnings outlook and the overarching problems in the economy. That said, calling the end to the world, has always been a fools game. Wall Steet and the hedge fund community will find away to make lots of money as they have done in the past. After all, is this the first crisis we have endured? You all seem to forget that Wall Street made lots of money even when interest rates were significantly higher, and the appetite for risk was more curtailed.
Additionally, stars on wall street always make money...please don't mention the 2 or 4 people at a Bear or Lehman who are still making tons of money. I'm sure he/she already has their overpriced piece of real estate. I am talking about the large rabble of mediocre types who were making bonus of $500,000 - 2 million. They were the reason that real estate rose to such high levels. that is gone and is not coming back.
by the way, we should start hearing about the laid off lawyers in another 2-3 months
DIPIESA - sorry to hear about it. I also know plenty of folks at Bear, either still looking, left the scene or snapped up by other banks. I have not heard of lucrative contracts except for the stars. In fact, folks who were taken at JPM did get something but it didn't come close to offsetting the lost wealth from the stock, nor is there any long-term security.
Wall Street will reinvent itself, but don't expect comp to reinvent itself anytime soon. And don't expect the numbers of people employed on Wall Street to return to anywhere near pre-crash levels. There will be more commercial/investment bank megaliths and more boutiquey advisory shops. The commercial/investment bank megaliths such as BAC, C, JPM, UBS, DB, Barclays, etc. have such gaping holes in their capital structures that ROE will be abysmal for some time, and their ability to lend (even post-bailout) will be impaired. I think we're looking at at least a two-year hiatus before funds begin to flow and significant fees are generated again.
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/21/realestate/21deal1.html?_r=1&ref=realestate&oref=slogin
No need to panic..Everything's cool..
"At the upper end, said Paula Del Nunzio of Brown Harris Stevens, distinctive properties are drawing buyers. “Everyone continues to keep their appointments, continues to keep their contracts and continues to keep their closings,” she said."
I give up trying to reason with people who resort to hurling invective about crack pipes and assumptions about ulterior motives. It's obvious that people who are hellbent on their notion of impending doom and gloom will resist any counter argument that suggests that there are other factors at play that might limit the extent of the decline. Nobody sane doesn't think that Wall Street won't cause a decline - I've acknowledged that over and over again. I'm only saying - and feel like a broken record - that there are arguments that mitigate against a total, abject collapse, the likes of which the vultures here seem to be anticipating with schaudenfreude and glee. If you deny the legitimacy of any argument that may impact your hypothesis, you fail to appreciate the enormous array of factors that go into shaping the market.
"...prime manhattan down 25% by next month, 70% by the time this is all over..." is not an irresponsible quote.
Uninformed? Yes.
Irresponsible? No.
"I'm only saying - and feel like a broken record - that there are arguments that mitigate against a total, abject collapse."
Who ever said that? I said 50% decline, which only brings us back to 2003.
"the likes of which the vultures here seem to be anticipating with schadenfreude and glee."
Why is it that anybody who predicts a downturn is always accused of "schadenfreude and glee"? Is reality that difficult for you to accept?
"If you deny the legitimacy of any argument that may impact your hypothesis, you fail to appreciate the enormous array of factors that go into shaping the market."
You fail to appreciate that we all know that, we know what effects there will be, we are taking them into account. No one denies that some jobs will be saved and some people will continue to make money. The vast majority, however - not.
25% in a month?
Will drop another 100% by October
"In fact, Lehman Brothers has only been standalone since 1994 - does anyone recall it being a part of American Express?"
I do. And I remember around that time people predicting the end of the world. After all, they would say with their eyes wide, "Look at what's happened to Drexel! To Shearson/Lehman/American Express!" The end of Wall Street? No. A period of retrenchment and (duh) negative growth. And flmd is right... look for a law firm near you to downsize soon. That won't be the end of law firms either.
The bottom will come in Q1 2012 after the spike in prime/option/agency ARM resets.
Will drop another 200% by November
Just walked around SOHO and Tribeca and noticed many of the restaurants were buzzing with lunch traffic. It occured to me that this city is significantly more diversified economically than perhaps it ever has been. The fall-out from Wall Street will definitely cause a period of retrenchment, however, this is not the city of the 90s or 80s. There is more demand from multiple sources than ever before. Moreover, while credit is tight, it stands to reason that, despite the needed improvement in banking balance sheets, that loans will once again flow to those who have the appropriate credentials, as this bail-out plan is implemented. The fact that so many buildings in NYC require 20% plus down payments will almost certaintly cushion the slide as well.
DIPIESA, you might have seen a couple of my friends at the restaurants in SOHO and TRIBECA. WHen they were laid off, they didnnt jump off the building, or start living on the sidewalk. They hung out at cafes and restaurents while they looked for new jobs. THey still have good savings, and can go on for a year or so without a salary with no change to their lifestyles if need be.
will they buy a condo anytime soon? no way, no how, no f'in way - not till their confidence level builds up to where it was a couple of years ago when they believed the mega-sized bonus and strong job market was here to stay.
While I agree NYC is pretty healthy overall that is not what is priced into the market. The market is pricing in "peak income." That's a long, long way from "diversified economically."
No one should be naive enough to believe that strong times are here to stay. Similarly, no one should be pessmistic enough to assume that bad times will be permanent. The ones who will crush it in this cycle will be those who have stashed cash away, and are ready to strike as prices come down. I just don't think at juncture we can know how bad this will turn out. After all, it has been only one week, and the situation still seems quite fluid. We are still still living through the shock, and frankly, exhaustion. I never thought post 9/11 that NYC, or the travel industry for that matter, would boom the way it has. Clearly, the two periods are unique, but the fear factor in some ways is comparable. If I were thinking about selling, I would wait a bit to see how this shakes out before making a potentially rash decision. Those who sold immediately after 9/11 made a devastating mistake.
"noticed many of the restaurants were buzzing with lunch traffic."
That's a reliable indicator. Did you notice what language they were speaking? It could have been the Europeans.
I have watched the market closely for the last two restructuring cycles -- ibankers are always important to young new york real estate flow. Doctors do not get paid what they used to get paid, lawyers make good coin but still bill hourly and unless manhattan is going to become a retirement community of empty nesters who have already accumulated their net worth -- without mortgages and credit -- most people cannot afford to cut checks beyond $1 million. So it is reasonable to expect real estate will come down. Hedge funds are going to be crushed -- along with private equity. Unless we are going to have a city full of wealthy elderly, or trust fund babies -- many people were badly hurt last week and that will have fall out. I sat next to a woman at a salon today who makes less than $250K per year (we were discussing Obama vs MCCain taxes) and she lost millions last week after saving for 40 years. It is all very sad. It will take a long time to recover.
"Unless we are going to have a city full of wealthy elderly"
please not! already felt like being in a cemetery in north italy last time i went. it's depressing to see 4 nursing homes per each tiny kinder.
"Hedge funds are going to be crushed -- along with private equity"
why do you think so, especially pe?
Crushed may be too strong (maybe). However, two reasons PE will have some issues:
1) A ton of PE firms did a lot of deals (and big ones) at the peak. Will be tough to make any money (let alone achieve target PE returns) on those companies.
2) PE business model fundamentally relies on leverage - for buying companies, for doing recaps, for selling. With leverage dramatically constrained, life will be difficult for PE firms.
I know several people looking for PE jobs right now, and very, very few firms are hiring.
The hedge funds do not have money tied up for long periods. Even well performing funds will receieve redemption notifications as investors seek liquidity. PE has the above stated leverage issues.
Smart post Dipiesa. Bravo.
DIPIESA, I agree with most of what you stated specially the part about not making irrational and emotional decisions.
I differ in your view that "it has only been one week". The credit bubble was several years in the making. The effects of its eventual crack and resulting credit crunch, were seen developing as early as 2005 in states such as CA, FL, AZ, NV and others. Mortgage bankers and RE developers have been crushed by the ill effects of the credit bust for nearly three years.
The effect on the NY economy became apparent during mid-2007 but the assets that are now causing the problems were in financial company balance sheets well prior to this. Today, we are witnessing what other parts of the country have been experiencing. The difference being that the NY economy has a very high concentration of financial services & related industries in its economic composition which is a cause for concern.
I agree that we will get though this as was the case during other difficult economic periods but it will take time to absorb the adjustments.
It's one thing to say we'll get through this just like we always have in the past. And I tend to agree. However, it's a totally different thing to use that as justification for buying a risky asset using massive amounts of leverage unless you can truly afford to lose that money. I think we'll be fine but I also think it would be smart for many to sell their home and downsize while they still can such that if we are all wrong about getting through this not all is lost. If you can afford to lose 50% of the value of your home then I agree - probably nothign to worry about.
To: ccdevi
Hedge funds and some P/E are going to continue to be impacted by tight credit. Their big gains depended on high leverage. which is going to be harder for them to accomplish, because it's harder for them to find banks who will lend to them as aggressively. Hedge funds will still make money (especially the creme de la creme), but my guess is that people at a whole segment of hedge funds will go down a notch pay-wise, in the direction of what people running traditional mutual funds tend to make. (More like in the low-to-mid six-figures, rather than in the seven-plus figures.)
I've always been fond of a comment made years ago by Barron's editor, Alan Abelson:
"Worst piece of financial advice I've ever gotten: Don't panic!"
PE will struggle. Not only has the game changed from a credit perspective, but these firms own a bunch of over leveraged, underperforming assets. Their focus is on the turnaround of these assets rather than fresh buyouts. If interested in M&A, go the corporate route. Corporations will lead the buyout world for the foreseeable future.