How will apartment size impact price decline?
Started by JohnDoe
about 18 years ago
Posts: 449
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
A lot of commenters have noted that buyer psychology has shifted and people are very unlikely to want to commit to real estate ownership in the near term, given limited potential upside but enormous potential downside. I'm wondering if this phenomenon will impact smaller apartments (e.g., studio, 1BR) more than larger ones. The potential buyers of these apartment will generally not have children... [more]
A lot of commenters have noted that buyer psychology has shifted and people are very unlikely to want to commit to real estate ownership in the near term, given limited potential upside but enormous potential downside. I'm wondering if this phenomenon will impact smaller apartments (e.g., studio, 1BR) more than larger ones. The potential buyers of these apartment will generally not have children and therefore have much less need for the stability in housing that might push one to buy. If that's the case, studios and 1 BRs may see even larger price declines as it's unclear how strong an impetus anyone will feel to buy them. On the other hand, larger, and therefore more expensive apartments, may just become unaffordable to too many of the potential finance-industry buyers who have lost jobs or seen salaries slashed, which could drive significant downward movement. Thoughts? [less]
In the early nineties, studios really got whacked. According to Miller Samuel data, Manhattan coop studios went from $131 per square foot in 1989 to $25 per square foot in 1993. A total wipeout! (A friend bought a studio around that year and his percentage apprecation since has been huge, of course.)
Maybe history will repeat. I'm not sure. I note that all the new construction seems to be super luxury construction for investment bankers. I see very little more modest construction of studios. So I wonder if we will actually see particularly large drops for two and three bedroom luxury apartments. Their price per square foot is far higher than the price per square foot of studios today according to Streeteasy. Simple demand and supply. I'd also note that it seems that recently it has been the top end of the market that has seen the biggest percentage price appreciation per square foot.
As I recall, the smaller apts mainly studios, 1 beds and Junior 4s were hammered in the 1990s. The larger apts (spacious 2 beds on up) weathered the storm better and were also the first to lead the recovery. They were however also caught in the RE fire storm which lasted five to six years.
I do believe that the early 1990s makes for an comparable economic environment to the current. The exception being that this one is far more violent perhaps due to the wide spread use of derivative securities which were not widely used 20 years ago. There wasn't that crippling counter-party risk then that is clearly evident today.
I've been told that banks actually stopped giving mortgages for studios last time around. Maybe that's a tall tale, though.
I had a very hard time believing the Miller Samuel psf data. $25 psf would mean that a 400SF studio would sell for $10K. Yes, the downturn in the 90's was severe, but I am pretty sure that's just not right.
If you look at some of their other psf numbers and trends, they are all over the place. Unless someone gives a better explanation, I just assumed that data is inaccurate.
I know people who bought Jr 4s (900 sq. ft) on the UES in 1993 for $95K. 2BR cost 125K -- 200 K.
Yeah, those number (while so low they make me jealous), make more sense. $100-200 psf sounds amazing, but $25 psf I just don't believe.
Ahem perhaps Miller was referring to this:
"Jonathan J. Miller, the president of the Miller Samuel appraisal firm, often recalls appraising a studio that had so little value he could have put the entire purchase price on a credit card. "
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/21/realestate/21deal1.html?ref=realestate
"I had a very hard time believing the Miller Samuel psf data. $25 psf would mean that a 400SF studio would sell for $10K. Yes, the downturn in the 90's was severe, but I am pretty sure that's just not right."
You are leaving out the maintenance factor. 5th ave co-ops went for $1 because the expenses got so high (higher than rent).
Hell, you could buy at citylights in Queens for $25k.... but, you were really still renting because the underlying mortgage was so big that you paid over $2k in "maintenance".
nyc10022, that's a very good point. I was not in NY in the early 90's (and was too young to pay attention to real estate anyway), so I wasn't familiar with those stories.
nyc, that is really interesting. Is the ratio of maintenace to purchase price higher with smaller apartments? If so, that would suggest they should get hit harder in any decline (assuming equal percentage decline in total costs people are willing to pay).