Price reduction-
Started by dco
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1319
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/348056-condo-15-east-26th-street-midtown-south-new-york That was a fast cut. I guess somone works on wall street.
dco: Your gloating gives bearishness a bad name. Anyway, that reduction just puts the price back around where it was in 2006:
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/36204-condo-15-east-26th-street-midtown-south-new-york
West81st- Gloating, I guess it wasn't gloating, a year ago, when all the bulls, were laughing and calling renters and people who couldn't afford to live in this city, bitter for missing the boat.
Gloating works in both directions. Referring to my enthusiasm about my analysis being correct, gloating, is not factual. Lets be clear, my gloating is about being correct, when others called me crazy. So, yes I feel vindicated and just how correct my analysis will ultimately be, will be known in the years to come. I like to think that perhaps I saved at least one person from making a terrible financial decision because some ling broker told them "act fast, it won't be here tomorrow". If not, the so be it.
dco: You wrote, "I guess someone works on Wall Street". What does that have to do with whether you were right or wrong about property valuations? You have no way of knowing the seller's circumstances; you're just taking a gratuitous swipe at an entire industry - one on which, sadly, this city is overdependent. On top of that, the price reduction you're pointing to doesn't substantiate your theory of massive declines. Show a comparable sale at a much higher price, and this reduction might mean something. Otherwise, it's just another overpriced apartment coming back to where it should have been in the first place.
Dco, for the most part, I AGREE with your assessment of the market's condition and direction. But you are far too eager to declare victory over the forces of darkness, and far too gleeful about the collateral damage. So maybe the seller works on Wall Street. Does that make him/her worthy of ridicule?
This is exactly the kind of place that I think will be hit pretty hard. It is in NYC in an okay neighborhood, but is very expensive for what it is. It costs $2300+ a months for maintenance/tax and the apartment is an okay size. Doesn't $1000/foot seem more reasonable for this kind of place?
Not every apartment in NYC is the same, so when people scream 30% declines it doesn't my apartment or your apartment will decline 30% or even decline at all.
Of course, you're free to gloat all you want. This is just an Internet message board - the closest thing to a free marketplace of ideas. So let the triumphalism fly. But if you really want to influence people and get the respect you think your opinions deserve, a bit of restraint will go a long way. Just my two cents.
West81st- "a bit of restraint will go a long way. Just my two cents."
Like I said, it amazes me, that when the market was going up, up and away, no one referred to it as gloating. When I had to read about secretaries getting $300,000 bonuses at GS, that was OK. Now we learn that it was all a pyramid scheme and tax payers are going to pay for those bonuses, of Christmas past. I'm sorry, but those same people I'm suppose to feel sorry for just cost me, a tax payer, a lot of money, so excuse me if I don't apologize.
This brings up a point that was discussed in the past, one of the arguments was that New Yorkers were smarter and better equipped in handling their finances. I hope they are right, I have my doubts. If you made over $500,000 for the last 5 years, IMO there is not way you should be losing your house. And if you are, you are certainly not qualified to handle my money.
I'm truly sorry that people are going to face tough financial times, however I do take it to heart that this will cost me a lot of money over my lifetime, mostly through taxes. I'm suppose to feel good about this? Come on guys, don't be fooled by the tears. No one gave a dam when about the consequences and now they are paying the price.
"Of course, you're free to gloat all you want. This is just an Internet message board - the closest thing to a free marketplace of ideas. So let the triumphalism fly. But if you really want to influence people and get the respect you think your opinions deserve, a bit of restraint will go a long way. Just my two cents."
West81st, glad to see there are decent people on these threads still. Thanks.
Please, it's so facetious this "there are still decent people" attitude. Please. First of all, there are countless REAL tragedies in the world affecting the most vulnerable, dispossesed and innocent people at any given moment, if you want to get all solemn and puffed up with sorrow, rather than cry for Wall Street and its former millionaires. Frankly, it only makes me sad inasmuch as it damages the world economy and it's probably worse for all those who are already doing very very very bad. I mean, unimaginably bad. That said, for those of us with children, modest middle class incomes and a desire to stay in NYC rather than be priced out to Jersey, what is there not to gloat about in the impending real estate catastrophe? I WANT to live in NYC, even in a recessionary version of it. Now, maybe I will be able. I'm HAPPY for myself and my family, which are of course the most important people in the world for me. If all this leaves any money to spare I'll even donate some to Doctors Without Borders. But I don't think they need any of that on Wall Street, right? Please, "decent people" my a--.
Trompiloco, easy on the tirade. I've seen a lot of posts that go overboard taking swipes at others here, not to mention a lot of chest-thumping and pronouncements of "vindication" after "being insulted and ridiculed for so long." Please - it's pretty childish behavior, no matter what what said. I don't particularly feel bad for people on Wall St who engage in malicious behavior and have suffered as a result of their actions, but there are many many people who will suffer (to varying degrees of course) regardless of their association with these actions, and I find no need to revel in that, even if it's not "tragic" by most definitions. So don't label my "attitude" as facetious - I'm just a little tired of that kind of ridiculous posting here.
bjw2103: Thanks, but... (see below)
Trompiloco: My advice to dco was purely pragmatic. Nobody likes a sore winner. In this case, dco made up an explanation for the price cut ("I guess someone works on Wall Street") that seems more linked to dco's hostility toward investment banking than the facts at hand.
dco: Gloat if you must; but if you're a football fan, I have two words for you: DeSean Jackson. (Translation: Make sure you're across the goal line. THEN celebrate.)
That was a low blow west81st (am an Eagles fan)
what he's going to gloat about, being able to post links? summarizing day, week or months old news and analysis. W81, I appreciate the sentiment, and of course you're absolutely right, but you're giving him way too much credit.
ccdevi- Try golf, it will relieve some anger.
again no anger, just because you keep saying it doesn't make it so.
ccdevi- What's your story? Really, what gives?
we've actually been through that, but whats the point of the question? I call you on your nonsense, what story does one need for that?