Property Tax Increase - More Bad News
Started by anon3
about 18 years ago
Posts: 309
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
"Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, worried about the effects of the global financial crisis on New York City’s economy, said on Monday that his administration is considering imposing a 7 percent property tax increase on homeowners in January." This on top of the already cratering market....GET OUT WHILE YOU CAN. By the time this is all over prices will be down 70% from what they are today. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/23/nyregion/23tax.html?hp
blah blah blah
I wonder, if it is a condo with a tax abatement, will it escape the proposed tax increase? Maybe those apartments are looking better, even if most of them are in the Financial District.
What if 7% property tax decrease? Good news?
NYRENewbie,
Tax abatement condos will actually get worse as the "JUMP" in monthly with be atrocious.. If you're trying to sell the place and there is only 3 years left on the abatement, the seller is not stupid enough to not factor in the JUMP in payments coming up
bugelrex: That doesn't make any sense. You're saying it's worse to pay (hypothetically) $0 per month for 3 years and then $1070 per month after that than it is to pay $0 per month for three years and then $1000 month?
Sure, the "JUMP" goes up, but only because you're saving more money in the meantime.
"only because you're saving more money in the meantime."
Actually, no. The benefit of the tax abatement went to the developer, through higher prices.
Can someone explain to me how does this "jump" mean? I have been looking at an apt with 0 taxes, abated for 10 years, and the broker explained that after that period it increases gradually for a 5 -year period. Does this mean that I will pay more that the person next door with the same footage after the abatement?
"Actually, no. The benefit of the tax abatement went to the developer, through higher prices."
Not sold on this, as it's not an easy thing to quantify. Developers surely benefit, but I imagine that at least some of the benefit is passed along to the buyer - it's an incentive for both parties.
stevejhx: We've had this discussion before, and you've acknowledged that the developer might pass along some or all of the savings in the interest of moving units faster. (And yes, the developer also benefits from this, but so does the buyer.)
Moreover, if property taxes increase AFTER the original sale closes, all of those savings accrue to the new owner because there was no way to price them in to the original deal.
mimi: The "JUMP" is just the rolling off of the abatement and reversion to normal tax rates. To the best of my knowledge, all units in the building should be on the same abatement schedule, so you'll always have roughly the same benefit as other people in the building. As to whether you'd pay more than people than people in the next building over, this is almost impossible to say due to the arcane nature of NYC real estate taxes. You should be able to get an estimate of what the unabated taxes will be (it's in the original offering plan for the building) and compare it to nearby buildings. One last word of caution: if you're buying directly into a new development, it's likely the abatement won't become effective for a while (sometimes more than a year), so you'll be on the hook for paying the full taxes during the interim. The ten year clock doesn't start until the abatement kicks in, though.
and with any luck, if McCain gets elected he'll figure out a way to get rid of the AMT, like he's proposed.
Just like politicians. Seize on the bad news week and memorialize tax hikes. This reminds me of the late 90s when we were all wondering how to spend the projected surpluses which projected out into the late 00's.
One good week in the market and we all forget about this "bailout".
just ignore steve, he is a stubborn delusional idiot.
If Condo A & B are both 1000sq in same location, same ammenties but one has abatement with equal price what do you say? retard.
mimi,
You get a tax break for 10year duration plus some in the next 5 years. Then your RE tax is equivalent to those with similar sqf in the area. Waitlist for abatement is roughly 1-2 years.
Isn't the bigger point that this will have a negative impact on apartment prices given that they will all have an increase in carrying costs?
Carrying costs? As I understand, it's just that you pay a very small amount for, say. 10 years and after that period you pay the amount that is assessed by the city, right?
By the way, thanks ba294!
mimi, I'm not talking about abated stuff.
I'm talking about apartments in general. If the majority of apartments have taxes increased by 7% (or more), what kind of impact does that have on prices?
it means prices are going to plummet even further and faster.