The "What are They Smoking?" Thread?
Started by jess
about 18 years ago
Posts: 142
Member since: Jan 2006
Discussion about
So, I thought I'd start a thread for any listings you see that are grossly overpriced vs. comps. Let's define grossly as 30% or more over the avg ppsf. Case in point: 525 Broome #3, Closed in June $2.15, asking $3.45 three months later... http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/351530-condo-525-broome-street-soho-new-york StreetEasy History 07/27/2007 Previously listed with Elliman for $2,590,000 01/31/2008 Elliman listing unavailable at $2,590,000 03/04/2008 Previously listed with Elliman for $2,350,000 06/19/2008 Previous sale closed for $2,150,000 09/25/2008 Listed with Halstead Property at $3,450,000
That's because that's what they NEED to get out of it to buy the trophy property they really want and feel they deserve!
This is EXACTLY what happened in Miami after the collapse began: people trying to flip for a 50% profit in a week. Apartments there have languished on the market for YEARS because they won't take a loss, yet the owners won't lower their prices. So - let the inventory build, pay the carrying costs, and let smart people, along with Nancy Reagan, just say no.
Take it from someone who just took a loss on the stock market - far better to take the loss and invest in something else (though I invested in the exact same thing) than it is to hold onto a loser forever.
"than it is to hold onto a loser forever."
This is also good advice for the unhappily married...
Looks like it was initially sold as a raw space and has now been added to. Don't think it justifies the massive increase either, but it ain't exactly a straight $1.3 mil markup.
"far better to take the loss and invest in something else (though I invested in the exact same thing) than it is to hold onto a loser forever"
Huh? Am I the only one who thinks the above makes no sense?
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/352722-coop-135-west-79th-street-upper-west-side-new-york
Apt. 5B
09/27/2008 Listed with Elliman at $1,250,000
Here's the history for Apt. 11B
08/23/2007 Listed with Elliman at $975,000
09/06/2007 Elliman listing entered contract
11/08/2007 Sale closed for $999,000
25% above a top of market comp seems pretty crazy in this market. Hard to imagine this will go above $1M (and wouldn't be surprising to see it trade in the $850-900k range.)
John that isn't even a real 2 br. Only 2 bath and no closets in the "2nd" bedroom. It's a junior 4
I completely agree, Charley. The purported second bedroom is really a dining room or a den (in fairness to the listing agent, it is described as a "bedroom/den" on the floorplan.
It really is hard to understand what the seller and broker were thinking in listing this? Do they realize it's 25% above a recent comp? Do they realize how bad the market is?
Another listing to add to the discussion (though I wonder if the original selling price is low - first floor apartments are harder to value)
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/346386-coop-260-west-end-avenue-lincoln-square-new-york
08/02/2007 Previous sale closed for $450,000
04/17/2008 Previously listed with Halstead Property for $760,000
09/05/2008 Listed with Corcoran at $695,000
09/27/2008 Price decreased to $645,000