Does the existence of this forum show how much demand there is in Manhattan?
Started by kspeak
about 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
the usual metric for screaming buy is when the equivalent rent is the same as the mortgage (30 year fixed).. what percentage decline would that entail?
I won't buy until I see a flattening out of the curve, a stabilization of prices, for a decent period of time (many months), and a general economic outlook that is mostly stable. If that is 15%, then it's 15%, if it's 50%, I'll be waiting.
kspeak, we are not thousands of users in this forum. We form a real estate niche, as there are many others in NYC (tango nuts, karaoke nuts, martial arts nuts, you name it...) Some of us are looking because we want to buy in the future, others because they speculate with RE, others because they just got hooked. Most of the people I know are not thinking RE, they are just thinking what to do next, how to pay for the private school, how to pay the mortgage, how to find a new job, how to survive in the future retirement, how to offset recent financial losses.
there seem to be only about 10-20 people here not thousands and they all always argue vociferously about the same issues.
They have convinced me that a 50-70% correction in prime Manhattan is upcoming. I will not buy anything till that happens, and then I plan to buy as many as I can without turning anorexic
> But just ask yourself this - once prices fall 20%, would you start buying? If so, doesn't that
> suggest that a 50% price decline won't happen.
That question has already been asked, and I think there would be few takers at a 20% discount. Hell, we are probably already at 20%, given we hit 10% down (mean and median) in Manhattan in August, and that was pre-panic.
All the sideline sitters seem very comfortable on the sideline...
The bad news in the financial markets keeps coming and RE typically lags so we're likely to see price reductions and new inventory for some time to come. Judging by the reductions in the past couple of weeks, it looks like either things are moving a lot faster than expected or some smart people see the writing on the wall and would rather take a 20+% hit now than wait any longer.
My searches have been updating with a lot of price reductions but so far there hasn't been a new listing that I want to see yet since late August. Up until then I was seeing new 3-4 interesting new things a week. I guess the new inventory will take longer.
Btw, do you think anything much is going to happen post-bonus season? I think most people should have a pretty good idea what shape they'll be in by now and if they need to sell, they're frankly speaking much better off trying to get out now.
I'm with lo888 - the inventory that is out there is poor
I think bonus season is going to be the "oh shit" monment for a lot of people. The predictions on lower numbers have been talked about for a a while. Hell, Bloomberg predicted it over a year ago. But not too many people listened. Once those numbers become official, I think its going to take the confidence level in RE to a new low.
Slow motion... that's the real estate market. When does it fall off a cliff? Maybe if there was a public health calamity like the black plague. This market will slowly unravel bit by bit. 50%...70% oh! the wishful thinking of the would be real estate buyer. Dream on! 30% would be amazing. Those searching for a primary residence and, a 8-10 year time hoizon would be lucky to scrape something up at 20% off. For investment purposes, residential 2010 , comercial 2011 at the soonest. This town always changes. When I was a kid in the nineteen seventies we would be on avenue A and dare kids to go to D. There were few takers. East 87th and East 88th street were rife with hookers and drug dealers stright out of central casting. If you would have told me in 1972 that some day I would be visiting Times Square to have a family night I would not have been able to comprhend such an idea. My Point...things change. Slower than you think, more dramatic than you think. My Advice...stop predicting the future. This is now! We know whats happening now. This is where the well is deepest! It's the last place to get dry and the first place to get wet. What do we know now? The dryness has finally reached us...just last week. Now be prepared for the slow motion. It takes time to experience the demise. It takes time to run out of money. It takes time to panic. The main reason the prices will come down is the simple lack of credit. The pool of qualified buyers will be reduced,those looking to flea will increase...supply and demand. Watch'n wait...I promise...things change.