Skip Navigation

Maintenance prices -- will they go down?

Started by LP1
about 18 years ago
Posts: 242
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
Please educate me on the maintence price calc. If the actual sell prices on apartments fall in manhattan due to a poor economy, will the maintenance price remain at their current levels (or go up b/c of tax increases?). To me the difficult pill in Manhattan is not just the px/sq ft, but the monthly maint bill. On many 2bd/2ba apts I've seen the main is in the $1800+ range. Thx
Response by bramstar
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1909
Member since: May 2008

They'll keep going up as fuel/electric prices rise. Also, as fewer units turn over some smaller buildings may find themselves with a depleted reserve fund for repairs and such (flip taxes are used to replenish these funds), which could lead to assessments and increases in those buildings. Maintenance prices have absolutely nothing to do with the value of the apartment.

$1800 is actually not terrible for a 2-bed, 2-bath.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc212
about 18 years ago
Posts: 484
Member since: Jul 2008

If anything, even WITHOUT the fuel/energy cost and flip taxes considered, the maintenance charges will go up if many owners/share holders default on their payments, foreclose, etc. and the board cannot collect maintenance from these people. This is because fewer people will be responsible for the running cost (e.g., utilities, doormen, super, facilities, etc.) of the bldg.

Also, for 2BR/2BA in Manhattan, $1,800 seems quite reasonable. Of course, It'll depend on the sqft.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by semerun
about 18 years ago
Posts: 571
Member since: Feb 2008

I am treasurer for my condo- and while common charges are not the same as maintence charges- the comparison is close enough. The main differences are 1) taxes are included in manintence and 2) any underlying mortgage would be included in maintence.

Let's assume the building has either no mortgage or a fixed rate mortgage for similicity- and cost stabilization aspects (you can later add that difference for an Adjustable rate mortgages if applicable).

Taxes are increasing- so that alone can send maintence prices upward. Fuel prices have increased- so that can send maintence prices upward. General inflation has increased in the past year due high oil prices- so you may see contracts that need to be renewed at higher prices. Food costs have increased because of high transportation costs which in turn means that your doorman or super needs a higher salary just to get by. Even our garbage backs have skyrocketed in prices over the past year due to the fact that they are petroleum based.

There is not a single line item in my budget that is decreasing in cost except for when we seek a cheaper lower quality alternative.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by waverly
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1638
Member since: Jul 2008

Maintenance costs are like allowances for your kids....they only go up.

Most well-run buildings should be getting very little of their money from flip taxes and their budgets should take into account the need for repairs in the future. Fuel/energy costs and emergencies can dictate assessments, but assessments are not the end of the world. You pay a little extar for a bit and it is over.

NYC - foreclosures and defaults on coops in NYC are extremely rare. Plus many people have had to put 2 years of maintenance payments in escrow for the coop to guard against this happening.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by semerun
about 18 years ago
Posts: 571
Member since: Feb 2008

sorry that should have read garbage bags (not backs)in the 3rd paragraph

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc212
about 18 years ago
Posts: 484
Member since: Jul 2008

waverly, we consistently have quite a few defaults on maintenance payments in our building, and it is potentially significant enough to make a difference over a period. Some people are unhappy with the bldg and withold payments in protest (knowing that there's very little we can do to collect on a timely fashion), and others simply cannot afford to pay.

I wouldn't say defaults are "extremely rare" since I don't think our building is unique in facing these challenges. Maybe, waverly, you are confusing this issue with the discussion in another thread, which deals with ENTIRE condo/coop BUILDINGS going into foreclosure??? Or, maybe you just live in an unusually stable bldg.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nm92622
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Jun 2008

I have also been puzzled by the cost of the common charges (i.e. excluding real estate tax/mortgage for coop) in NY. What would be the percentage range of total charges for the following items?
- doorman
- live-in super (understanging the big difference there can be between a small and big building)
- heating cost (why are most coop buildings not moving to a gaz local heater - everyone pays what he/she consumes, and prevents abuses like windows opened in winter?)
- garbage collection
- common areas cleaning/flowering/lighting
- Elevator maintenance
- Gym
- Pool
- big projects over 5 years (external wall regular cleanup,...)

what else?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Many of these depends on the size of the building. For instance, take $100k in doorman costs (which isn't even full time)... divide by 10 apartments or 100 apartments. You get *very* different costs...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by lo888
about 18 years ago
Posts: 566
Member since: Jul 2008

I would say that in the type of building you describe, about $1 - $1.25 per SF is average. Some of the newer developments and buildings with many amenities have higher maintenance (pools require a lot of maintenance and a full time life guard.) Also, if you have outdoor space, you probably need to factor in and additional $0.50 per SF.

If not financed through reserves or maintenance increases, special projects may be handled through special assessments which can range anywhere from keeping your annual rebate to a spefic amount payable every month for several months or over a year. Tough to tell what amount - completely depends on the project.

Obviously if we are faced with 7% increase in RE taxes, you know who is going to pay for it...

Prices can and will come down but I doubt maintenance ever will.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc212
about 18 years ago
Posts: 484
Member since: Jul 2008

nm92622--In addition to the items you list, we have many rent controlled tenants who has stayed from pre-conversion in the 1980s and pay next to nothing for their gorgeous, HUGE, Manhattan apartments (incl. the PH units!). The share holders cover the costs for them, which jacks up the maintenance fees.

Interestingly, our Board has noticed that rent-controlled tenants are often the most demanding folks--asking for various improvements and filing complaints, although they are probably only paying something like $1/sf/month in rent...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nm92622
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Jun 2008

indeed. Wouldn't it be great to have a database for various buildings and their corresponding costs? We would know the "good", the "bad" and the "ugly" :-)
I sublet, so I don't know what it is in my current building, but I do know in other capitals maintenance (for similar bldg) is much much cheaper. Understood you gotta love NY or leave it, but that doesn't mean getting overcharged.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by waverly
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1638
Member since: Jul 2008

lo888 - I believe the general rule of thumb in NYC for coops is that you don't want the maintenance to be more than $1.60/square foot (used to be $1.50 but energy costs have hit all buildings). So, an apartment that is 1,000 square feet, the maintenance should be between $1.25 and 1.60 per aquare foot. Significantly higher than that will have a negative impact on the value of the apartment.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment