Skip Navigation

Ge whiz --Manhattan Rental Market Remains Strong

Started by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
Just when you thought the market is collapsing!!!!! It looks like the rental market is Manhattan is still rather healthy. Gee wonder what the heck happens when the economy turns around and gets stronger does the rental market get weaker???. Take a look see at the following http://www.tregny.com/manhattan-apt-rental-report.jsp "Once again the Manhattan market never ceases to amaze me. At a time... [more]
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Unless I'm reading this wrong, every single category is down year over year... doorman studios down 7%, non-doorman one bedrooms and two bedrooms down 4%..

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008

"nyc10022 yeah that's right every single category down"--lmao

Where Prices Increased:

Harlem— Non-doorman studios (1.3%), doorman studios (5.02%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.51%), doorman one-bedrooms (7.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.87%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.42%)

Upper West Side— Non-doorman studios (3.07%), doorman studios (0.46%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.69%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (0.86%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.68%)

Upper East Side— Doorman one-bedrooms (1.94%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.45%)

Midtown West— Doorman studios (2.42%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (1%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.67%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.57%)

Midtown East— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (6.07%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.5%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.39%)

Murray Hill— Non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.87%)

Chelsea— Non-doorman studios (1.84%), doorman studios (2.34%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.45%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.44%)

Gramercy Park— Doorman studios (.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (6.21%), doorman two-bedrooms (1.55%)

Greenwich Village— Non-doorman studios (4.07%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.76%)

East Village— Doorman studios (2.83%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.56%), doorman one-bedrooms (1%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.52%)

SoHo— Non-doorman studdios (2.58%)

Lower East Side— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (5.24%)

TriBeCa— Non-doorman studios (2.14%), doorman studios (1.49%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (7.44%), doorman one-bedrooms (4.42%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.17%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.97%)

Financial District— Non-doorman studios (4.05%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.05%)

Battery Park City— Doorman two-bedrooms (0.97%)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
about 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

houser, if you really, truly believe that they will be able to sustain those rents for long, you're crazier than I thought.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008

Of course not rentals in Manhattan have been and continue to go down. Please ignore all the stuff above that says otherwise.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Houser, you seem to have a reading problem:

Non-Doorman Citywide Rents: September ’07 vs. September ’08
September ’07 September ’08 Change
Studios $2,167 $2,160 -0.33%
One-Bedrooms $3,036 $2,904 -4.34%
Two-Bedrooms $4,151 $3,992 -3.82%

Doorman Citywide Rents: September ’07 vs. September ’08
September ’07 September ’08 Change
Studios $2,780 $2,584 -7.04%
One-Bedrooms $3,881 $3,756 -3.22%
Two-Bedrooms $5,778 $5,729 -0.84%

I even game the examples before...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008

Where Prices Increased:

Harlem— Non-doorman studios (1.3%), doorman studios (5.02%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.51%), doorman one-bedrooms (7.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.87%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.42%)

Upper West Side— Non-doorman studios (3.07%), doorman studios (0.46%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.69%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (0.86%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.68%)

Upper East Side— Doorman one-bedrooms (1.94%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.45%)

Midtown West— Doorman studios (2.42%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (1%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.67%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.57%)

Midtown East— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (6.07%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.5%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.39%)

Murray Hill— Non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.87%)

Chelsea— Non-doorman studios (1.84%), doorman studios (2.34%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.45%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.44%)

Gramercy Park— Doorman studios (.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (6.21%), doorman two-bedrooms (1.55%)

Greenwich Village— Non-doorman studios (4.07%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.76%)

East Village— Doorman studios (2.83%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.56%), doorman one-bedrooms (1%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.52%)

SoHo— Non-doorman studdios (2.58%)

Lower East Side— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (5.24%)

TriBeCa— Non-doorman studios (2.14%), doorman studios (1.49%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (7.44%), doorman one-bedrooms (4.42%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.17%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.97%)

Financial District— Non-doorman studios (4.05%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.05%)

Battery Park City— Doorman two-bedrooms (0.97%)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Isn't pasting what you can't read over and over just a sign of illiteracy?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008

nyc10022 sorry your in denial--which I can help you.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
about 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

Denial, houser, is the failure to recognize what is happening all around you. We are in the worst financial crisis in 70 years. Wealth has evaporated. Precisely because of overpriced housing. Wall Street is decimated. More Citigroup jobs going to Charlotte, where they'll be running their retail bank from. You don't seem to get the delay factor.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

> nyc10022 sorry your in denial--which I can help you.

You can't read, so I guess I'm not surprised you can't write either...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by mrsbuffet
about 18 years ago
Posts: 134
Member since: Nov 2006

wasn't the real estate crash in NYC in 1989 after the stock market tanked in 1987? Two year lag, right? How is today different? It's going to take awhile for reality to set in.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
about 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

mrsbuffet is correct. Moreover, let's take a look at what's happening to inventory at a Hell's Kitchen building:

CURRENT RENTAL LISTINGS

* $4,733 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 7, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,290 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 31, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,365 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 11, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,290 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 27, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,565 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 18, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,523 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,520 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 6, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,875 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available November 3, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,990 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,818 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 27, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,643 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $2,810 Studio at Archstone Clinton (available November 8, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,420 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 6, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,700 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 6, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,335 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 31, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,735 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available December 5, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,305 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 27, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,260 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,650 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 13, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,358 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 6, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,780 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,720 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 5, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,305 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 23, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,618 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,573 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $4,593 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/29/08.
* $3,095 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available November 10, 2008) posted 09/25/08.
* $3,250 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 09/22/08.
* $2,880 Studio at Archstone Clinton (available October 25, 2008) posted 09/21/08.
* $2,940 Studio at Archstone Clinton (available October 8, 2008) posted 09/16/08.
* $2,930 Studio at Archstone Clinton (available November 7, 2008) posted 09/12/08.
* $2,860 Studio at Archstone Clinton (available November 4, 2008) posted 09/12/08.
* $4,863 2-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 08/15/08.
* $3,430 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available October 7, 2008) posted 07/29/08.
* $3,915 1-Bedroom at Archstone Clinton (available September 29, 2008) posted 06/07/08.

Now don't you think that with that many vacancies they'd start to lower the rents?

Or is it because Archstone was owned by Lehman?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Admiral
about 18 years ago
Posts: 393
Member since: Aug 2008

"wasn't the real estate crash in NYC in 1989 after the stock market tanked in 1987? Two year lag, right? How is today different? It's going to take awhile for reality to set in."

Well, for one thing, the county wasn't in recession in 1987. The economy (GDP) was actually quite strong, so much so that George H.W. Bush was elected president on a platform of maintaining the "peace and prosperity" of the Reagan years. Most of the 1987 crash had been recouped a year later. The country went into recession in 1990, and the slowdown leading into that is what tanked NYC real estate.

But in this case, the recession is about to start now (and so will the real estate decline)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008

"Now don't you think that with that many vacancies they'd start to lower the rents?"

You would think so but guess what

Where Prices Increased:

Harlem— Non-doorman studios (1.3%), doorman studios (5.02%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.51%), doorman one-bedrooms (7.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.87%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.42%)

Upper West Side— Non-doorman studios (3.07%), doorman studios (0.46%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.69%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (0.86%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.68%)

Upper East Side— Doorman one-bedrooms (1.94%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.45%)

Midtown West— Doorman studios (2.42%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (1%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.67%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.57%)

Midtown East— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (6.07%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.5%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.39%)

Murray Hill— Non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.87%)

Chelsea— Non-doorman studios (1.84%), doorman studios (2.34%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.45%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.44%)

Gramercy Park— Doorman studios (.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (6.21%), doorman two-bedrooms (1.55%)

Greenwich Village— Non-doorman studios (4.07%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.76%)

East Village— Doorman studios (2.83%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.56%), doorman one-bedrooms (1%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.52%)

SoHo— Non-doorman studdios (2.58%)

Lower East Side— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (5.24%)

TriBeCa— Non-doorman studios (2.14%), doorman studios (1.49%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (7.44%), doorman one-bedrooms (4.42%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.17%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.97%)

Financial District— Non-doorman studios (4.05%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.05%)

Battery Park City— Doorman two-bedrooms (0.97%)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

"Foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds..."

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by dco
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1319
Member since: Mar 2008

Nothing like we have ever seen before.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by zorter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 110
Member since: Apr 2008

What Steve, DCO and others on this board have hoped for has finally come to pass. The fall of the real estate market took a sudden and abrupt turn though. I can hold my real estate for 10-15 years with a tennant paying my mortgage.My rental apartments aren't going out of business because some asshole wants to lend money to people who can't wipe their own ass. The funny thing is my tennants are in place for another year so I have lost nothing on my real estate holdings. I do not plan to sell for 7-10 years and every year I need one tennant to rent my apartments in white glove buildings. Thats not to say that rents can come skyrocketing down but I am fine today and will look at the rental market 1 year from now. All the bears got what they wished for except it bit them in the ass.How a financial expert like Steve could possibly lose money on stocks and me the idiot landlord lost nothing so far is beyond me.It will be a cold day in hell for me to turn away from real estate and put my money with a bunch of fools on Wall street to lose for me, be careful what you wish for.NYC1022/Fast Eddie Wilson you have also got what you wished for, declines in real estate, but being the asshole that you are you there is a price to pay so you can tell everyone on this board, see I told you so. Families have been wiped out, businesses gone, no more credit, no college loans, a crippled economy, and a worldwide global meltdown. What I see on this board are the idiots Steve, Eddie Wilson, DCO to name a few loving every minute of this so they can say SEE I WAS RIGHT, look at my posts from 6 months ago, I called it everyone I am very very smart.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

wow, somebody is bitter...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Admiral
about 18 years ago
Posts: 393
Member since: Aug 2008

"The funny thing is my tennants are in place for another year so I have lost nothing on my real estate holdings. I do not plan to sell for 7-10 years"

That's like saying a stock went from $100/sh to $60/sh but I haven't lost anything because "i don't plan to sell". Well guess what bunky - sometimes people have to change their plans. They get sick. They get divorced. They lose their job. Fact is, you have the SAME mortgage debt on an ASSET now worth demonstrably less. No loss, eh? The opportunity cost alone is huge. You could sold the place three months ago, bought it back in a year, and made about 25%, i would guess.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

This would also mean that 90% of the folks who claimed they "made" money on their apartments didn't...

A gain is a gain, a loss is a loss. Paper vs. realized is another matter.

But waiting around 10 years to "break even" might just mean compounding a loss...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008

thanks eddiewilson

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by totallyanonymous
about 18 years ago
Posts: 661
Member since: Jul 2007

they flew jetliners into skyscrapers, killed 3000 people and the market came back eventually. we'll get over this too. true, some poor schmucks will get burned. survival of the fittest.

maybe Congress will wise up and never again push federally guaranteed 1%, 3% or 5% down mortgage programs to deadbeats.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by zorter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 110
Member since: Apr 2008

Right admiral I could have sold put my money in AIG the biggest insurer in the world and lost all my money.Obviously you don't own real estate and maybe for you you are better off because you certainly know nothing about the buying and selling of a long term investment BUNKY.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by zorter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 110
Member since: Apr 2008

FAST EDDIE Wilson you are some nut that changes his name on a real estate board every other day and denies it each time. How can you expect anyone to respect what you say????

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by zorter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 110
Member since: Apr 2008

admiral yesterday jp morgan lost 6 per share but was up 5-6 today so i didn't sell yesterday and came out whole today. had i sold yesterday yes i lost but i didn't.don't try to tell me i will be down 30% on my real estate holdinds in 7-10 years even you can't make that prediction

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Pez
about 18 years ago
Posts: 55
Member since: Oct 2007

As I see it, rental prices are down year over year while the costs of operating the owner's apartments have increased significantly due in large part to heating and other maintenance prices.

If you have a low basis in your property you will continue to make money... just less than you used to. If you buy now you would have to determine if future rental prices will increase to keep your basis low relative to rental rates. I am not willing to bet on future rental increases at this time.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by MMAfia
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1071
Member since: Feb 2007

yup- definitely not bottom yet. still got clowns like petrfitz, houser, zorter, admiral clinging on.

not yet boys and gals.

once these ostriches pull their heads outta the sand and stop posting silly denial snippets, then we know we have hit capitulation.

just like the dot com boards during that bust. yap yap yap until finally, game over. capitulation. bottom.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by MMAfia
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1071
Member since: Feb 2007

sorry admiral for accidentally including you in that group of ostriches.

the only thing i can't stand more than ostriches are monkeys. you know, the ones infatuated with picking bottoms all the time.

they are like kiddies on a road trip from NYC to LA. We just passed the bridge out of manhattan and they already start asking "daddy are we there yet?"

NO. we are NOT there yet.

This is just the appetizer kiddos. Wait till the entree arrives in the form of a collapse of confidence in US TBills aka the Dollar. Foreigners around the world are starting to wake up and smell the salt. They do all the hard work and make everything while the US just consumes and gives them worthless IOUs.

That, my friends, is the real issue these ostriches and monkeys should be worrying about. but they can't grasp the concept, and that's why they will always be ostriches and monkeys.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by zorter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 110
Member since: Apr 2008

Mafia ok capitulation it bottoms then what stays flat for a while if I am not selling are you telling me what my real estate will be worth in 7-10 years. Look in that magic ball and tell me the mega million numbers for Friday.What am I in denial about I have rental apartments with leases in place till August 09 where is the denial, I can't sell if I wanted to.When the market goes down my tennants still pay the mortgage and taxes, I never bought overpriced new condos always resales and renovated them myself, something that a person like you would never even attempt to do, because when you can't do you teach or scream on boards like this how you called it 6 months ago.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment