Lets start questioning some basic assumptions. Starting with-
Started by rationalobserver
about 18 years ago
Posts: 19
Member since: Sep 2008
Discussion about
So one assumption is that real estate is supposed to go up in the long run (in real terms, not just norminal terms). Why? Everyone takes that as an assumption. Please don't say because it is true because its occurred on avg over the last 50 or 100 years. Question what happened over the last 50 years that caused house prices to go up? Look at the cause, not the effect. 1. If 300 million americans... [more]
So one assumption is that real estate is supposed to go up in the long run (in real terms, not just norminal terms). Why? Everyone takes that as an assumption. Please don't say because it is true because its occurred on avg over the last 50 or 100 years. Question what happened over the last 50 years that caused house prices to go up? Look at the cause, not the effect. 1. If 300 million americans have 400 millions homes, can prices still go up? Will demand exceed supply forever? 2. If the Nikkei can stay below its 20 year old bubble level so far, why not real estate? 3. If wall street and banks in general will remain under pressure and the cost of credit goes up (oh yeah, it will), will affordability ever improve? (I think we gotta wait a couple of years, but who knows) 4. Why has the price of computers continued to fall over time when houses hasn't? aah! better technology, easier to produce.. okay... price of wheat or rice? its a relatively limited resource? And gas? I know its at $4, but in real terms, not that much higher than 50 years ago? 5. Will the sentiment reason alone drive prices? (Maybe the next generation won't find that extra emotional value in owning over renting and go with pure financial reasons. Couple of generations ago, borrowing wasn't cool. Look at where we are now, Society's values change) 6. Once all Americans have an average of 1000 sq feet of living space per capita, will they spend disposable income on larger homes? or more travel? or consumer durables? eating out? because if its not more homes, how will home prices go up? I don't have the perfect list of questions. Just created a few. And now ppl may just barrage one of those points and PROVE why I am wrong on one of those. But that is NOT the point. I am saying we all make assumptions. Some are right, some are wrong. I want to see how many of us question them. So lets hear from those who believe prices go up in the long run. Even the super bearish here believe in that...Give us the reason. [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
17 Comments
-
9 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
8 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
I suppose that the expectation is that the population will grow, so 300 million Americans becomes 400 million within a decade or so. I'm not a demographer and I'm not really familiar with the actual projections here, but it would be the result of 1. longer lives 2. reproduction rate exceeding mortality rate (I know that Europe has a problem here, but haven't really read anything about the US) or 3. net immigration. The second that this housing issue arose, my though was always that we should encourage increased immigration. Not that people seeking the American dream are going to be buying multi-million condos in NYC right off the bat. However, if per capita GDP stalls at least an increased population would spur aggregate GDP growth. Of course, too many Americans are too scared of immigration (can you remember when it was supposed to be the #1 issue in the presidential election?) for the government to discuss a policy of increasing immigration, even if it was done in a 'smart' way.
> So one assumption is that real estate is supposed to go up in the long run
> (in real terms, not just norminal terms).
Shiller showed that the long term real return on RE is just above zero.... so anyone with the assumption that it is supposed to go up in the long term in real terms is wrong...
And the market is not making that fairly obvious.