For those who know how to predict the future of Manhattan RE
Started by houser
about 18 years ago
Posts: 331
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
I really do think this basically sums up all the doom and gloom forecasts on this board. For all geniuses who predicted a crash in rental prices for the past two years. This report came out yesterday on the following link. http://www.tregny.com/manhattan-apt-rental-report.jsp "Once again the Manhattan market never ceases to amaze me. At a time when the financial markets seem to be in turmoil,... [more]
I really do think this basically sums up all the doom and gloom forecasts on this board. For all geniuses who predicted a crash in rental prices for the past two years. This report came out yesterday on the following link. http://www.tregny.com/manhattan-apt-rental-report.jsp "Once again the Manhattan market never ceases to amaze me. At a time when the financial markets seem to be in turmoil, unemployment is on the rise, and the housing market is in jeopardy of an even more serious slow down, the rental market appears to be bucking seasonality trends and possibly starting to gain footing. This year, the summer upswing that we would normally expect to see was absent, making September’s gains appear as a rebound. And while August’s slump questioned a link between the sales and rental markets, it seems the rental market is finally seeing a benefit from sluggish sales. As Congress debates a credit market fix, Manhattan property owners have created their own “rental market fix.” Making a concerted effort to lower vacancies and prices, inventories have fallen for the second consecutive month. This much needed correction is giving Manhattan a fresh breath of stability, which is good news for both renters and property owners alike." [less]
:)
houser, you already posted this elsewhere. While I agree that some posters here are too quick to declare that "everything's already fallen 20%," I think it's a bit early to speculate too much. Many rentals are probably holding fairly steady up until now. As the layoffs pile up on Wall St, you may start to see pretty substantial drops in very high-end rentals in Tribeca, Soho, etc. I do think pretty basic rental units (walkups in decent areas) will hold though.
You're watching the History Channel. Everything in this report is based on the market before 5 financial institutions collapsed. Since then, even the Mayor has indicated that a slowdown of endemic proportions is about to hit New York.
Jobs will be lost.
Homes will lose value, some will foreclose.
Tax revenues will decline precipitously, as will personal incomes.
Of COURSE rents will only increse, houser...
Nope this report just came out yesterday and no I do not beleive rental prices will only go up. I do beleive that those who try to predict the future direction of Manhattan RE market are usually incorrect.
As noted in the other report, houser can't read.
In the report HE noted, every single category of rental - one bedroom, studio, 2 bedrooms, doorman and not - were down YoY, when inflation was 5% at least...
Its one thing to play loose with stats. Its another thing to just lie. I guess the bulls don't have much more they can do...
EddieWilson why are you using another screen name what's that all about.
I'm with EW here, every category is down yoy. Houser - how can you cite this as being bullish?
Houser -- are you kidding me. Show me a report in 3 months. After a 777 drop and panic everything will drop, yes even rental prices. Your report does not take into account the history of the past 14 days. Nice try.
goingdown so what are you saying goingdown that everything is ahhhhh goingdown. Why am I not surprised that someone with a screenname of goingdown is in a goingdown frame of mind
> I'm with EW here, every category is down yoy. Houser - how can you cite this as being bullish?
The simple answer is "illiteracy".
Houser: if you want to read rosy stuff about RE, read Real Estate Weekly, it's like a collection of PR press releases presented in newspaper form. BUT, even Real Estate Weekly basically says ALL types of RE EVERY WHERE in the US are going south.
"even Real Estate Weekly basically says ALL types of RE EVERY WHERE in the US are going south" then please explain the following stats
Where Prices Increased:
Harlem— Non-doorman studios (1.3%), doorman studios (5.02%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.51%), doorman one-bedrooms (7.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.87%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.42%)
Upper West Side— Non-doorman studios (3.07%), doorman studios (0.46%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.69%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (0.86%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.68%)
Upper East Side— Doorman one-bedrooms (1.94%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (4.45%)
Midtown West— Doorman studios (2.42%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (1%), doorman one-bedrooms (0.67%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.57%)
Midtown East— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (6.07%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.5%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.39%)
Murray Hill— Non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.87%)
Chelsea— Non-doorman studios (1.84%), doorman studios (2.34%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.45%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.44%)
Gramercy Park— Doorman studios (.51%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (6.21%), doorman two-bedrooms (1.55%)
Greenwich Village— Non-doorman studios (4.07%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.76%)
East Village— Doorman studios (2.83%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.56%), doorman one-bedrooms (1%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (1.52%)
SoHo— Non-doorman studdios (2.58%)
Lower East Side— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (5.24%)
TriBeCa— Non-doorman studios (2.14%), doorman studios (1.49%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (7.44%), doorman one-bedrooms (4.42%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (3.17%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.97%)
Financial District— Non-doorman studios (4.05%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (3.05%)
Battery Park City— Doorman two-bedrooms (0.97%)
Where Prices Decreased:
Upper West Side— Non-doorman one-bedrooms (7.00%)
Upper East Side— Non-doorman studios (0.60%), doorman studios (2.21%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (0.21%),
doorman two-bedrooms (0.65%)
Midtown West— Non-doorman studios (0.2%), doorman two-bedrooms (1.24%)
Midtown East— Non-doorman studios (6.54%), doorman studios (2.22%), non-doorman two-bedrooms (2.23%)
Murray Hill— Non-doorman studios (2.34%), doorman studios (0.46%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (2.65%),
doorman one-bedrooms (1.44%), doorman two-bedrooms (3.48%)
Chelsea— Doorman two-bedrooms (2.35%)
Gramercy Park— Non-doorman studios (3.38%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (1.88%), doorman one-bedrooms
(2.58%)
Greenwich Village— Doorman studios (0.89%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.17%), non-doorman two-bedrooms
(1.69%), doorman two-bedrooms (2.20%)
East Village— Non-doorman studios (5.04%), doorman two-bedrooms (0.75%)
SoHo— Doorman studios (1.2%), non-doorman one-bedrooms (0.7%), doorman one-bedrooms (1.56%), non-doorman
two-bedrooms (2.48%), doorman two-bedrooms (0.6%)
A Quick Look
Manhattan Rental Market Report September 2008
I have read this site for more than a year -- I think it is always emphasized that sales, not rentals, have a long way to fall. Stevejhx has been correct in his analyses on the whole.
The RE bulls are really scratching in the dirt here.... even a broken clock is right twicw a day....
"even a broken clock is right twicw a day...."
Interestingly, this is exactly what was said about the "bears." Boethius would be proud...
Those are asking prices from unrealistic fools. Let's see what they sell for.
Is NYC RE on the no short list. PERFECT time to short this lipsticked pig.
Once the shoe shine guy starts talking about "toxic paper" you know its a bottom. Lets face it. Many on this board are anonymous Internet equivalents to shoe shine guys.