New on market, what do you think?
Started by Lucid
about 18 years ago
Posts: 68
Member since: Oct 2008
Discussion about
I have friends in this building and know that it is pretty well run. But is it a buy at this price?
http://www.prudentialelliman.com/1045183
This would have helped.
Not a bad looking place. If the size estimate is correct, it's pretty decent for the price. Plus it sounds like it's turnkey. You'd be in the back of beyond for now, though, but once the 2ed Ave subway line is up and running you'll be rolling in clover.
Check this one. Better value and half a block from the park.
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/317860-coop-16-east-96th-street-carnegie-hill-new-york
I think these will go under a million when RE starts to go down. Very nice but not special
Thanks. Jtreadwell, I think you are right that the one you link to is a nicer place, but not sure the neighborhood is as safe at night. But that 1/2 block to the park... that's worth a lot.
I am watching to buy when prices come down some, but if something special comes along that I can live in for a long time I don't mind doing it early. Still not quite sure what I want yet.
Lucid - I almost bought in this building in '07 and feel that it is a very good building. The apartment is just a touch high, but my biggest statement to anyone looking at this apartment is that the broker - Anne Ellington is about as dishonest and sleazy as they come. Trust her less than you would trust the worst broker you've ever dealt with.
Waverly, she seems to have sold at least half the apartments sold in that building in the last few years. Someone else told me she used to be a flight attendant before that. What sort of sleaze are we talking about, cause I'd like to go see the place.
She lives in the building and is very close with the board. She will not present offers to sellers that are from someone using another broker and lies everytime her lips are moving.
My wife and I were negotiating on an apartment and our bids were not being communicated to the seller. She was telling so many lies to us that she couldn't even keep them straight, whcih led to her constantly changing her story. Ultimately, the apartment was sold to someone for about $12k less than we had bid, but the owners never knew this because Anne didn't want them seeing any bids from people where she didn't have the full commission. I am not going to say how I know this information, but trust me, this is how she operates. Proceed at your own risk with her, but at least you will know this going in...unfortunately we didn't.
Also, this apt
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/234875-coop-401-east-74th-street-upper-east-side-new-york
is available and I saw it. It's not a great renovation and sort of shabby except for the kitchen. Also, the 2 apts are identical mirror images of one another, and the square footage is correct in 7B but overstated by 100 sq ft in 8C. 7B was way overpriced when I saw it back a few months ago, but is now the same price.
Anne is "generous" when it comes to listing the square footage. The best things about the building to me are:
- seems to be in good shape / clean
- nice staff
- pretty low maintenance / good financials
- good mix of people / families
- very nice rooftop space
- wide hallways with nice lighting (it does make a difference)
I do think that the higher floor apartments in buildings like this are always much better (and quieter) than lower floor apartments and the best ones in this building have an unobstructed western view.
That is just me.
The negatives are that it is really far east and I hate to count on the 2nd Avenue line being done anywhere near on schedule. And, frankly, part of the negative is Anne Ellington. She wouldn't stop me from considering another apartment there if I liked it, but she would force me to drastically change how I would go about negotiating for it.
I am in a sales business and I have a major problem with dishonesty. My reputation is everything and I would rather lose a deal today by doing the right thing than lying to close a deal. I also know that I will make more down the road by being the person that people want to deal with and who they refer people to. She does business in a very short-sighted way and is oblivious to her behavior. I have a hard time with trying to reward someone for this kind of behavior and frankly, I don't think most people would want her selling their apartment if they knew how she did business. Possibility of changing her....nil. Possibility of taking action against her in the NYC RE world....less than nil.
Lucid, how could think 96th street between 5th and Madison is not safe at night? Have you ever been in the area? Its one of the safest placest in the city. The block has about 8 doorman buildings. Its south of Mount Sinai, not north of it. I've lived in the area for many years and feel perfectly safe at 3AM, even more so than 74th between 1st and York.