Jonathon Miller compares now to late 80's-91 downturn
Started by steveF
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2319
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
stevejhx are you reading.... Can you explain how do the current economic conditions compare to historical market downturns and how deep and long did those last? Jonathan J. Miller: When I think of historical market downturns, my frame of reference is the ‘87 stock market crash and subsequent recession in 2000-2001. New York was hit hard and the housing market followed the economy. To the typical... [more]
stevejhx are you reading.... Can you explain how do the current economic conditions compare to historical market downturns and how deep and long did those last? Jonathan J. Miller: When I think of historical market downturns, my frame of reference is the ‘87 stock market crash and subsequent recession in 2000-2001. New York was hit hard and the housing market followed the economy. To the typical characterization, “but this time it’ll be different,” it may be different, but in both positive and negative ways. The Manhattan housing boom in the 1980s was characterized by a rental to co-op apartment conversion frenzy and a 421a tax abatement incentivized condo construction boom with emphasis on smaller investor apartments. When the music stopped in 1987, marked by the 25% October drop in the Dow, the housing market was left with an absorption rate of about 84 months and 30 year mortgage rates were 12%. Co-ops were deemed the pariah of the housing market with many sponsor defaults, bank foreclosures and speculative insider flips. Condos weren’t much better off because of the revisions to federal tax laws in 1986 that reduced the financial incentive for individual investors to purchase the newly constructed condo units that were flooding the market. This time, New York has been one of the last regions in the country to see weakness in housing. Across the country, housing helped lead the economy into recessionary conditions rather than the other way around. That’s largely because the nation actually experienced a “mortgage boom,” rather than a “housing boom,” which was brought about by a complete lapse of regulatory oversight, historically low mortgage rates and the disconnect by all parties including ratings agencies, commercial banks, investors, Wall Street and borrowers over the relationship between risk and reward. But that’s another story. Despite all of this, Manhattan currently has modest inventory levels (a 7.9 month absorption rate) and new development added to the housing stock is largely expected to end next year due to elimination of condo development financing. During the boom, co-ops did a better job vetting buyers than banks did and speculative activity represented less than 5% of all sales (nearly 40% in Miami) and the weak dollar fostered a lot of foreign buyer demand. Ironically, Wall Street, arguably one of the driving forces of mortgage securitization, will impact the New York region with layoffs and lower bonus. Apartment sales activity is already down by 27% year to date compared to 2007 and price trends are leveling off after years of increases. Foreign demand caused by the weak dollar is beginning to slow down as foreign economies are experiencing their own troubles. It’s pretty tough to forecast housing trends until the credit markets are at least stabilized. The proverbial “cart before the horse.” The scope of the problem is historic, global and complicated. The drive to purchase real estate is still remarkably strong, but that really means little at the moment until the credit situation is stabilized. [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
17 Comments
-
9 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
8 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
bizarre first sentence: '87 stock market crash and subsequent recession of 2000-2001. Doesn't he mean "89-1994"?. Or the dot-com bubble crash of 2000 followed by the subsequent recession of 2000-2001?
It would be great if you can cite where Miller's text comes from. A link to the article or interview would be very helpful.
7.9 absorption rate?? who is he kidding? just because this appraiser collected some data on manhattan doesn't make him any less biased and ridiculous.
sure kas...http://matrix.millersamuel.com/?p=2311
http://realestateqa.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/10/17/expert-qa-a-downturn-for-new-york-real-estate/?scp=1&sq=Q&A%20miller&st=cse
Special K live in denial to feel better...typical emotional reaction. J Miller is the least biased out there. He was pointing out nationwide inflated appraisals during the subprime mortgage boom.
he leaves out the "wall street boom". The unprecedented earnings that ended up being 30% of NYC income. I don't think we've ever seen an income dropoff this big in NYC... ever.
steveF, i don't live in denial. there's nothing for me to deny. i don't own and i can buy at any time. i choose not to because it's abundantly clear to me that prices will drop another 25% from here. u on the other hand, are stuck long an asset that you hope and pray every night will not go down. but sadly, despite all your clamorings to the contrary, it will. you will lose a huge portion of your net worth and what makes it worse is that you could easily have avoided it by selling.
for crying out loud, barbara corcoran herself has seen the light! steveF, are you going to be the dumb money stuck with the hot potato??
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/5692-even-barbara-says-the-market-is-going-to-be-a-crashing
funny stuff special_k.....25%? were did you get that?... "ya I think(burp) 25% down..ya that's whut i say" "nah, how's bout 50% ya 50%! heck we going to 100k one bedrooms yes sir(burp) that's what i think!".....and your analysis sir?...."heck i feeeeeel it"
btw, i'm refinancing my equity or 1031 exchanging to buy another one.
ok steveFool, if you insist, then 50% it is.