New York has the least number of underwater households nationwide
Started by bardamu
about 18 years ago
Posts: 113
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
i know! it's the only state i really want to see good deals coming along ... how come is holding so well it's amazing. anyway, there are long lags in real estate and even portfolio managers were trying to flip Plaza apartments few months ago... i've seen some listings at below last closing sale price, but only for previous sales done in 2006 on. people that bought in 2003-2005 still have positive equity, which is surprising to me.
so i'll wait 6 months from now and maybe we will end up in the 20% range.
On the WSJ piece, are you supposed to add the 2 columns up for total percentage of homeowners underwater or close to underwater or is the 2nd column the combined percentage?
I am asking because Nevada appears to have 100% either underwater or close to underwater and I would have to believe that they would be almost statistically impossible.
Near Negative Equity includes those already underwater.
admin - thanks! That was much worse...thanks again for the clarification.
admin, the hardest hit areas had big gains on what i would call a "credit cycle" - access to cheap, easy money. Other markets (e.g, much of the Northeast) had gains on more of an "economic cycle," this is especially true of NYC. Sure there was cheap credit here too but I would argue it was less of an influence. I would say the credit cycle peaked in mid-2007 whereas the economic cycle peaked this summer. It would be normal to expect some markets to lag other by 1-2 years based on what drove gains. Nonetheless, just about every liquid asset is back to at least 2003 levels and I don't expect real estate to be any different.
admin, the hardest hit areas had big gains on what i would call a "credit cycle" - access to cheap, easy money. Other markets (e.g, much of the Northeast) had gains on more of an "economic cycle," this is especially true of NYC. Sure there was cheap credit here too but I would argue it was less of an influence. I would say the credit cycle peaked in mid-2007 whereas the economic cycle peaked this summer. It would be normal to expect some markets to lag other by 1-2 years based on what drove gains. Nonetheless, just about every liquid asset is back to at least 2003 levels and I don't expect real estate to be any different.
I wonder if Michigan was hit so hard primarily due to the continued deterioration of their economy over the past 8+ years?
It is not a place that massive numbers of people relocate to and it is not a vacation or "second-home" location or a retirement destination. I also don't remember reading about huge new developments there. Just a thought.
Michigan and the rust belt as a whole are going through a recession from 2005 on at least. manufacturing have being hurting for the last 15, it never recover (job-wise) from any of the last recessions. they keep on losing jobs, never adding. due to unemployment they are losing population among the young, the old are stuck with their homes. one of the few employment opportunities for the young is within health care (nursing). kind of similar with upstate new york, isn't it?
A little similar to upstate NY, but NY does have some non-manufacturing business and some areas that are doing quite well. But, yes, Buffalo and Syracue and to a lesser degree Rochester have struggled for the last 10 years or so.
Admin,
if you check this listing: 445 West 54th Street #1E
you'll find a condo, in Manhattan, which was bought new in 2004 for 845K and is now at an asking price very close to that. It may still sell at above or below its 2004 price but, regardless, factoring the realtor commission and other costs, that owner is underwater.
My company is headquartered in Detroit and they have in the past asked me to relocate. I get out there a few times a year and am somewhat familiar with the downtown area.
Between a promotion and a lower cost of living, it would have felt like a significant raise. I seriously considered it, but ultimately decided Michigan is just too bleak. I'd rather remain in my overpriced miniature apartment.
Detroit never even had a bubble. They're the only state in the nation that's actively losing population. There's no one to purchase the homes that come up for sale. Detroit has lost literally half of its population in the past few decades. They've razed entire neighborhoods.
The pain has been going on for more than eight years. Michael Moore came out with "Roger and Me" in the late 80s (really a much better movie than his later productions). The entire automobile industry has been shifting south for decades, all because unions aren't nearly as popular there.
Surprisingly there's still some old wealth in Michigan, but most of it just depressing.
Trompilico - "underwater" refers to owing more on your mortgage than the property is worth. This individual may lose money on their transaction, but they are not underwater. I am not trying to be picky, but there is a distinct difference and the terms should be used appropriately. You know how things can run-amock here at SE.
Good point Bardamu. Taking a step-back I would have realized how long Detroit/Michigan have been struggling. That must be tough for the people living there.
bardamu,
Could it be argued that it was the unions that destroyed Detroit by not opening up the innovation and handi-capping the companies from being competitive? I just hope a strong 'leftist' democratic government will not lead us down the same path... hard work and innovation must continued to be rewarded..
bugelrex, if you've ever had the misfortune of renting an American car, you'd know how outrageously badly they're designed -- forget about how they're assembled, how much the labor cost, etc.
US car companies are dying because their management got fat and lazy and stayed that way, and just don't care what their customers want. They decided that they can make more money as lobbying organizations than as providers of goods. Their R & D consists (at best) of novelty that can be pushed on consumers, not anything that car owners want.
US airlines did the same thing -- lobbying rather than customer-focused selling of services. Note, for example, that foreign airlines running a flight from DC to New York to London (for example) are not allowed to sell tix for the DC-NYC segment. Lobbying by US airlines, even in an allegedly deregulated environment.
From what I understand, Japanese car-manufacturing unions are powerful and well-paid, and produce excellent cars, which the rest of the world is willing to pay a premium for. That's mostly because the execs at those companies are keenly responsive to the needs of all markets worldwide; their US counterparts can't even keep their fingers on the domestic pulse.
I don't want to get into an argument on the value of unions! I will not state my opinion on unions.
What I will say, however, is that the auto industry's executive leadership would prefer not to work with unions, and they were able to accomplish this by opening factories in the south. When Saturn was founded, GM decided to open factories in the south.
When the Japanese car companies were deciding where to open factories in the US, they would never pick Michigan. Not only were they able to get huge tax concessions in the south, but they were able to dictate wages, working conditions, etc.
I think it will be difficult for Michigan to recover. Maybe the Southwest will run out of water or the price of electricity will rocket and everyone will leave Phoenix and Las Vegas, but I doubt it.
Michigan has a fairly educated population and they need to realize the well paying jobs of the past are gone. They'll do well if they reposition themselves as a location for back-offices. Given the cost of living they should be able to effectively compete on price with the countries that have received outsourcing operation in the past few years.
"Could it be argued that it was the unions that destroyed Detroit by not opening up the innovation and handi-capping the companies from being competitive?"
Absolutely, 100%
> US airlines did the same thing
Yes, another industry totally screwed by union contracts these days...
> From what I understand, Japanese car-manufacturing unions are powerful and well-paid,
And not corrupt. They don't have control of the goverment, like they do here.
US car companies have consistently made ugly, gas-guzzling pieces of crap for the last 25 years without any consideration of their consumers. Only now are they realizing how far behind they are and they have no one to blame but themselves. The unions didn't create this mess. If Americans could buy as good of a car as those made in other countries, but it cost a few bucks more, they would do it. The reality is that the US cars have been so inferior and way more costly. They need to bend the finger in and put the blame for their failures squarely on themselves.
Actually, I've rented a LOT of cars in the last few years and American quality/design has improved dramatically. At one point I was renting weekly. I'm a fan of the dodgge charger, and I always get the malibu which is a really decent car for a cheapie. I think it won some awards. The new Caddilac SLK is a nice piece of work, especially compared to the last 20 years. The gap has closed a significant amount with the foreigners (especially since "foreign" started to mean a lot less).
There might still be a gap, but enough to explain the financial issues? No, not at all.... the union pension piece is by far a bigger component here.
Not to mention, part of the reason its so hard to redesign is the union work rules. When you are restricted from changing plants around, or moving things around, it is awful hard to be as nimble.
> If Americans could buy as good of a car as those made in other countries, but it cost a few bucks
> more, they would do it
The data actually shows otherwise... Americans usually take a few years to recognize quality changes. Same thing happened in reverse with Toyota. They had a better product for years, but Americans didn't buy at first until the reputation "caught up".
NYC - I meant that if American automakers put in the effort and improved the cars people would buy them...and they would. Could it take a couple of years fo that to get noticed? Sure, but come on, the large majority of US cars are just not that good, they guzzle gas and they are ugly as sin. Are their exceptions? Of course. But have they made cars that people will also want to buy in other countries? Not so much. And who's fault is that? The Unions....not at all. The CEO's and the people in R&D? Absolutely.
The people who make the big money get the credit when things go right and the blame when things go badly. And when it come to US automakers over the last 25 years they have been wrong with such consistency that only the Bush administration looks more incompetent.