11/28/2006 Previously listed in StreetEasy by Halstead Property for $1,110,000 04/05/2007 Previous sale closed for $1,110,000 10/08/2008 Listed in StreetEasy by Elliman at $1,350,000 10/13/2008 Price decreased to $1,295,000 When do we see real year over year drops for ordinary size apartments?
Gleeclub,
There are plenty of real drops on "ordinary size" apartments listed here (e.g., the sellers of a 2BR on the UES asking for 25% less than they paid). http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/3339-if-you-can-demonstrate-market-movement-with-comps-please-post-here
Second, the fact that the sellers are asking for more than they paid doesn't mean that they'll get it. Especially in this market, high asking prices are in no way an indication of high values (whereas low asking prices are a better indication since apartments are less likely to close over ask in this environment (though of course there could be exceptions in the case of a *very* underpriced apartment)).
John - there are 357 posts in that link ... can you point me to what you speak of?
Yes, I'm fully aware that asking and closing are different things.
look at the 2 BR on the UES posted toward the end of the thread. Beyond that, not to be rude, but you can take the time to do some of your own leg-work. Look through the thread (I know it's long), look at new listings as they come out, listings as they're cut, etc. You'll find plenty that are below where they once were.
geeclub,
the example you cite is that of someone who WISHES to get a higher price. That does not mean that is the new price. Price is set by seller AND buyer. Not just the seller. So, your title "this is up in one year's time" is incorrect. I can buy a pen for $2, and list it in craigs' list tomorrow for $4 - that does not mean the value of the pen has doubled in a day.
Gleeclub, your simple answer is you will see year on year decreases in the Q4 2008 data that will be released in January. That's when the fun starts. When we see -10% in print the deniers will shrivel up and the momentum takes over. Every new asking price will be -10%, and the buyers will be emboldened to put in even lower bids. The sellers get scared, some accept. Prices go lower still. Bankers applying for loans have trouble, because 2008 bonuses stink or are non-existent. Coop boards remain a pain in the ass, turning away qualified but marginal buyers. By the end, we have a normal historical correction of 40%, just like the early 1990s.