Miller Samuel Charts PSFs....
Started by nyc10022
about 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
http://curbed.com/uploads/2008_11_7_3cw.jpg Pretty clear 2Q turn.... interesting to see what Q4 will look like.
Real estate does not double in price in 5 years unless incomes do. Incomes went up about 12% in 5 years. Ergo that's how much real estate should have gone up.
Only logical conclusion? CRASH!
"Incomes went up about 12% in 5 years."
Where does the 12% come from steve?
?20-30% in prime manhattan?
stevejhx...he forgets about the 2 most important aspects for real estate pricing...supply/demand. Incomes do not hinder that retired couple from california with mountains of cash who want the prestige/enjoyment of owning a manhattan apt. Incomes are the baby sister to supply/demand. We have modest inventory and pent up demand.
steve (F)-
?10-20% drop in prime manhattan sound right to you?
"Incomes do not hinder that retired couple from california with mountains of cash who want the prestige/enjoyment of owning a manhattan apt."
Uuuhhhh.... has "Wall Street will save us", "Foreigners will save us", "Doctors will save us" just actually been replaced by "old people will save us"?
ROTLF
Yes, I can see it now, oceans and oceans of dentured retirees moving to Manhattan with their fixed pensions, social security, and millions from under their mattresses (because they don't trust the stock market".
Seriously, SteveF, thanks for the laugh...
> pent up demand.
We don't have pent-up demand, we have the opposite. People who wanted to buy because they thought would appreciate. Now that numbers are coming in, they are running scared. That isn't pent up demand, that is classic bubble.
> Incomes are the baby sister to supply/demand.
Not quite... you can't demand what you can't afford...
steveF - you're too much fun to turn you off!
"stevejhx...he forgets about the 2 most important aspects for real estate pricing...supply/demand."
Yes. Demand at what price?
"Incomes do not hinder that retired couple from california with mountains of cash who want the prestige/enjoyment of owning a manhattan apt."
Absolutely doesn't. Nor does it prevent them from renting a place at half the cost, and preserving their mountain of cash.
"Incomes are the baby sister to supply/demand."
Exactly. And with Wall Street collapsing, incomes are collapsing. Or did you not hear the mayor & governor?
"We have modest inventory."
3 years = modest? Ok.
"and pent up demand"
From whom? Everyone who's losing their jobs, and just saw half their wealth erased on the stock market?
Right!
steve(j)
?50-60% Manhattan prime?
?overshoot and land below 2002 levels?
How do you come by the 3 year inventory number?
Why would these folks want to invest in a tanking asset, anyway? Think Californians didn't get burned enough by real estate?
"How do you come by the 3 year inventory number?"
Easy. Current inventory = 9,500
Historic uptake = 8,300 per year
Current uptake = 4,500 per year
Recent building permits = 30,000 units.
3 years' inventory.
"50-60% Manhattan prime?"
Yup. To get them to equal market rents, yes. 2003 prices. See the "Bonuses Slashed" thread for the whys and wherefores.
Steve(j)-
Gotcha.
Pretty convincing. Suspect that we may see prices lower than 2003 due to national and local economic evisceration of proportions not seen in the recent past (which will also drag rents down as a comparator).
I wonder how much of the 30K units of coming inventory will disappear due to rental conversion, project failure, prolonged delays by developer (if possible).
Steve (f)-any response, predictions?
A friend of mine's father is in commercial real estate as a developer & broker. He's hurting. (Lives next to AIG's CFO - Hurting even more.) He says that any large building that can reconfigure its floor plan for rentals (smaller, less luxurious) are doing so. Doesn't matter if it's to buy or to sell, though: inventory is inventory. If market rents are already half owners' carrying costs and market rents fall more because of excessive inventory, what will that do to prices to buy?
Cause them to fall further.
"I wonder how much of the 30K units of coming inventory will disappear due to rental conversion, project failure, prolonged delays by developer (if possible)."
Agreed with Steve on this. If everyone is trying to rent to wait it out (this started months ago), then you really aren't helping yourself on the inventory front. Pressure on both, developers will be desperate. And, while some projects won't get built because of developer trouble, that same trouble might also push developers to HAVE to sell at whatever price to stay afloat.
Developers going kaput comes with bad, bad markets, not solid ones.
The chart linked in the first post is really not very useful. The time series is far too short to be meaningful.
Given that the point is about what happened the in last quarter, going further back would reduce granularity and make the chart meaningless.
Point is, the perfectly upward line just turned the other way...
This chart shows ppsf of new developments essentially flat between 1Q04 and 1Q07. Do people find this odd?