Skip Navigation

UWS at 400/sqft - maybe

Started by nyc10023
about 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
When we first moved to 10023 in 1998, co-ops were selling at 300/sqft . We thought those were very reasonable prices (we were making 180k combined) but we didn't have a downpayment. As soon as we could, we bought (at around 480/sqft), which I thought was still a reasonable buy (about the same as renting, maybe a little cheaper at the time). Fast forward 10 years, I don't think it's crazy to think... [more]
Response by ootin
about 18 years ago
Posts: 210
Member since: Jul 2008

smart move based on subsequent price appreciation, but what does it mean that you couldn't stand renting?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
about 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

We wanted to rent a 3-bedroom at the lowest possible price, in the best possible condition in the West 70s. This was '05. Didn't care about views. There really wasn't that much out there in our price range which
frustrated us. To be honest, after living in a completely renovated space with an optimal layout for our purposes, it was very difficult to live in a rental. Really felt that our standard of living went down. So when we bought, we were really doing it based on emotional reasons - because obviously the market peaked and we missed the chance to resell our current place last fall.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

I think it unlikely that prices will retreat to 1998 levels without adjusting for inflation, but with the adjustment I think it's very possible.

As for your hatred of renting, why didn't just find a better rental situation. Some are bad, some a are good. You really want to risk 1000/sq foot just because you didn't like renting?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by JohnDoe
about 18 years ago
Posts: 449
Member since: Apr 2007

Even given the job losses/shrinking bonuses, one gets the sense that there are probably a lot more people making more money in Manhattan today than in 1998. I also think the city has become a much nicer place to live (cleaner and safer - e.g., compare the columbus circle/lincoln center area or 96th-125th today with 1998). I think both of those would probably keep prices from retreating to 1998 levels. Then again, the employment and earnings situation in NYC is probably on the way down and it's hard to say how bad it will get or what impact that will have on quality of life in the city. Of course, if either gets really bad, many of us may no longer be in the market to buy.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
about 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

Like I said, it was emotional. And we couldn't find a better rental situation in the 70s (had to stay in the area for public school zoning reasons) than what we had - 7k for 3 bedrooms. It wasn't a bad place, but we were already spoiled with all the previous renovated places. This last time around, we switched out of a co-op so we at least have the option to rent out.

p.s. I don't the sense that things are better now than in '98. Jobs were SO much easier to find, at any level.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by JohnDoe
about 18 years ago
Posts: 449
Member since: Apr 2007

The relevant factor for housing prices is not how easy it is for any particular person to find a job, but how many people are making how much money (i.e., if there are twice as many people looking for 50% more high-paying jobs today than in 1998, it should be harder to find a job, but there are still more people in high-paying jobs than then to support higher housing costs.) (I have no idea what the actual numbers are and I realize this is highly stylized given that there are jobs at a continuum of salaries). If anyone has access to data, it would be interesting to see how the employment situation today compares to 1998.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
about 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

"I think it unlikely that prices will retreat to 1998 levels without adjusting for inflation"

I don't think they will retreat to that level, which is below the 1988 level. I bought a 2-bedroom 1-bath apartment in the West Village for $218,000 in 1998. I wouldn't expect it to fall to that level ever again. AT the peak that same apartment would sell for $1.5 million. It won't (can't) stay there. However, $650,000 would be reasonable, and would bring the monthly cost in line with market-rate rents.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
about 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

Hmmm, so with inflation, then we're looking at 2001 levels. That wouldn't surprise me. What will be real kicker is if the standard of living (street crime, breakins, vandalism) decreases to pre-98 levels.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by serge07
about 18 years ago
Posts: 334
Member since: Aug 2008

NYC10023, you are correct that the economy was in much better shape in 1998 than it is today. It was also expanding rapidly at the time and it wasn't only WS, it was the far more important industrial and Technology sectors. In 1998, the USD was also very strong versus major world currencies and rapidly appreciating. There were few European, UK or Irish investors at the time pouring investment funds into the Manhattan RE market and prices reflected that fact.

Today, all those positive economic factors have reversed the sole exception being the USD which is again strengthening after an unprecedented bear market. There is no question that the record weakness of the USD, specially between 2005 through mid 2007, was LARGELY responsible for the unprecedented run-up of Manhattan RE which priced out many New Yorkers holding dollars. I suspect that many of those foreign investors will attempt to sell over time to capture the flip side of the currency benefit which will add additional supply to the market. At some point, RE prices will reach an equilibrium reflecting historical currency levels as opposed to a Euro @ 160 or Sterling @ 210.

As I have mentioned before only American USD holders saw $1000+ per square foot prices. Euro and Sterling investors were at the same time looking @ $600-$650/sq ft pricing given their vastly over valued currencies. Sterling has already declined to 1990s levels and the Euro bear market vs the USD has IMO, a ways to go.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
about 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

I think a fall to 1998 prices is unrealistic because 1998 prices and 1988 prices were the same - in 1998, prices finally regained their 1988 highs. So that is basically implying that prices would be the same they were 20 years ago.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by serge07
about 18 years ago
Posts: 334
Member since: Aug 2008

kspeak, in 1988 there were the Japanese with their booming stock market, skyrocketing local RE markets and a Yen on steroids pouring investment funds into the Manhattan RE markets. Again, artificial inflation which was totally unwound in the 1990s as all their markets basically crashed. One of the large Japanese insurance companies was also forced to sell Rockefeller Center at a huge loss to the benefit of GE.

Foreign investors in the Manahattan RE markets have shown in the past to be an excellent contrary indicators.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by notadmin
about 18 years ago
Posts: 3835
Member since: Jul 2008

comparing prices to at the peak of the bubble valuations of 1988 is ridiculous. same with considering that current prices have any importance in terms of how far prices will fall.

get real, those prices (1988 and 2007/8) were based on an over-leveraged credit bubble that will take a decade at least to show up again. how far prices overshoot to the downside don't need to have a relationship with how much prices overshoot to the upside.

a much better analysis is to see by how much prices overshot to the downside in previous cycles with respect to fundamentals (price/rent, price/incom, price/disposable income ratios and the like ...) and see where that size of over-reaction towards the downside would put as now. my bet is that the overshooting will be much more violent and strong than in previous cycles though, given the power of deleveraging and the fast tightening of credit (both for locals and foreigners).

i'd bet prices in manhattan will follow an L shape. a drastic correction followed by many flat years at best in nominal terms (take into account the possibility of high inflation several years from now, prices will not keep up).

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by notadmin
about 18 years ago
Posts: 3835
Member since: Jul 2008

also take into account that to calculate the ratios, all the denominators will be decreasing too (rents, income, disposable income, ...).

don't accept the view that luxury buyers don't/won't suffer from this recession, most of their income is related to investments and business ownership (during a deep and long recession they shrink more than salaries). in fact, their overall wealth suffers in proportion more than normal salary earners wealth (assuming that they don't lose their jobs).

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
about 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

"kspeak, in 1988 there were the Japanese with their booming stock market, skyrocketing local RE markets and a Yen on steroids pouring investment funds into the Manhattan RE markets. Again, artificial inflation which was totally unwound in the 1990s as all their markets basically crashed. One of the large Japanese insurance companies was also forced to sell Rockefeller Center at a huge loss to the benefit of GE."

>> Thanks for the history lesson. I didn't think 1988 or now was a bubble until you explained it to me. Really.

The point isn't to debate whether there was a bubble in 1988 or whether there is a bubble now or what the causes are. It's just to say that if prices were to fall back to 1998 levels that would be the same as 1988. Which means prices would not have increased at all in 20 years, despite inflation, greater desire to live in cities, etc. Even though 1988 was a bubble period too, I still think it's difficult to imagine prices falling all the way back to what they were in the late 1980s even if this was an "overinflated bubble." I think it's a worthwile consideration when people start talking about potential data points for where prices might fall. It may not be the best one (price/rents is probably the most pure) but since the original poster was talking about 1998 prices, it's worth brining up the fact that 1998 prices = 1988 prices.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by serge07
about 18 years ago
Posts: 334
Member since: Aug 2008

admin, well stated! You made my point far better than my obvious feeble attempt. :)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
about 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

I like reading all the NYT real estate articles from 1989-1997. It's interesting to note what people were paying in rent, and why they wouldn't buy even when it was much cheaper to own than rent. One huge reason in the early 90s was the number of unsold co-op apartments and condos - there were entire buildings in 10023, 10024 (now asking 1000+/sqft for who knows how long) where sponsors walked away and people walked away from their properties because they couldn't afford the maintenance or no-one else was paying maintenance. Even if a one-bedroom was under 100k, why buy in such a building? Another reason was the number of properties in poor condition (long-time rentals) - say a Classic 6 was 400k, why buy if you had to spend another 100k in recessionary times to renovate?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by julia
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2841
Member since: Feb 2007

I'm hoping for '01 prices...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10023
about 18 years ago
Posts: 7614
Member since: Nov 2008

From what I can remember, doorman Classic 6s were low 1m on the UWS so of 96. You could have bought a large 8-room newly renovated prewar condo at the Manhasset (109th and Bway) for under 1m.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by manhattanfox
about 18 years ago
Posts: 1275
Member since: Sep 2007

A friend bought a classic six on 86/ bway in 1995 for 500K, another bought a classic six in 1994 on 66/cpw for 615K with a park view.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment