Is this movement on the UWS?
Started by happyrenter
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008
Discussion about
Top building on Riverside Drive, renovated Classic 7, river view, trading at 2005 level: http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/365154-coop-90-riverside-drive-upper-west-side-new-york 16 G on the market for 3.4 million Recorded sales: 09/08/2005 #8G $3,475,000 01/10/2005 #6G $3,100,000
This one too, although the new listing seems to need renovation so it is harder to tell:
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/365116-coop-201-west-89th-street-upper-west-side-new-york
Recorded Sales:
06/25/2008 #11G $1,400,000 -5.1% $1,475,000 ↓ 3 beds 2 baths 1,400 ft²
01/18/2007 #7G $1,225,000 +4.3% $1,175,000 2 beds 2 baths
The one at 90 RSD looks like movement. Hard to tell how dramatic the change really is without access to the listings for the two 2005 sales, and without knowing where 16G might ultimately trade.
In that building, #15F just went to contract after some very fast, aggressive price-cutting. I'm eager to see the price when it closes. High-floor classic six, estate condition, limited views but decent light. The owners had moved out, had little or no debt and were clearly open to offers. Looked like a setup for a successful lowball. We'll see.
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/346038-coop-90-riverside-drive-upper-west-side-new-york
The one at Chester Court is harder to read, as you noted, since it's clearly a wreck. I like Susan Leeds's euphemistic description of a "Windowed kitchen whose time has come."
Possibly; depends on the layout. I'm not familiar with that line--is it a true 7? Two gorgeous 6's on the B line at 50 RSD traded for $3 and $3.2 in the past 6 months. Apt 6B, a classic 7 at 180 RSD, sold for $3.5 back in July. These and other comps suggest there is still a way to go before we see true 'movement'.
Cautious optimism, with the emphasis on cautious, is the order of the day.
^^^ Depends on the layout AND condition.
Also with the Chester Court one--I don't think there are good views/there may not be much light. The living room, etc. is facing North looking at another buliding. The other windows face an inner courtyard, so no street view.
Wait a second Squid--in what sense does it depend on layout? I am comparing it to comps in the same line in the same building. If there are layout issues now, there were layout issues before.
As for condition, yes it depends on condition. I am, for now, taking the word of the broker that the RSD apartment is in excellent condition.
And ew, as for Chester Court, again, you can't say that it is a layout issue since I am comparing the apartment to others in the same line--and, in this case, on lower floors so any view issues are sure to be less in this one.
Because to gauge market trends I prefer to look at comps of similar units in other similar buildings, not just those in one line of one particular building.
If this apartment is, for example, primarily back-facing with one puny window on the river the ask would be high, IMO, and not indicative of any softening trend. If, on the other hand, it has glorious views from most rooms and is indeed a full 7 in great condition, then the price shows promise (though still perhaps a tad high).
I'm just not (yet) seeing a significant downturn in prices for this type of unit in top RSD buildings. And believe me, I'm looking for it.
I saw an apartment in the same line in the Chester Court over the summer (4G, lingering on the market since April, priced at $1,050,000 today, ask reduced ~15% since original listing). The apartment had very little light and looked quite dated. Some cosmetic improvements had been added over time, but those didn't help much. At the time of my visit the broker tried to lay on the pressure by saying "We have several BAFOs coming in a couple of days, so you better act quickly." In hindsight, he would have done his clients a far better service by lowering the price rather than using this amateur tactic. Needless to say, even if there were any BAFOs, clearly none of them came to anything...
I can only imagine the condition of 2G. Given the broker's honest admission about the kitchen and the lower floor, I can't imagine 2G fetching more than 4G. Either way, these two listings are all set up for a downhill race to $900,000.
900k? try 750k
Anyone else see this recent haircut?
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/348979-coop-605-west-111th-street-morningside-heights-new-york
Eh,this is only a slight trim. Get back to me when they've shaved the entire head.
This is my favorite! I don't think it's reasonably priced yet, but the broker must have been off of her rocker when it first came on the market!
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/347697-coop-500-west-111th-street-morningside-heights-new-york
Its been 6 whole days since the last price adj. They gotta be ready to peel another $50K off. The elevator only has a down button in this bldg.
aptometrist-
thanks for the info on chester court, but let's get the facts in order. we are talking about 10G not 2G. I see no evidence that 2G is on the market or has been on the market.
500 west 111th was priced insanely to begin with, but the cuts have been so fast and furious on that one that i wonder what the seller situation is. it may be a truly desperate situation. If I could stomach that location I would try a super lowball and see what I got.
what would you consider super low ball? 550K?
I think the seller is approaching desperation- tough to tell though.
I'd offer 500k, all cash, best and final.
thanks - too bad I don't have 500K cash. If I did, I'd be looking at nicer apartments.
There's something else to consider in this case. I think I mentioned 500 West 111th in one of the threads about outrageous square footage inflation. It is like 700 real sq ft instead of the 1000-plus it is listed at. Don't waste 500K on it.
happyrenter, my mistake. Re: Chester Court, you are right that it is 4G and 10G that are on the market. I must have been thinking of 2G which entered contract last week. That one was listed at $1,175,000 (http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/345698-coop-201-west-89th-street-upper-west-side-new-york). 2G has a more modern open layout and looks in better shape than both 4G and 10G. In any case, 4G vs. 10G still looks like an interesting "match-up" - let's see how that price war ends.