Low-balling
Started by warybuyer
about 18 years ago
Posts: 19
Member since: Jan 2008
Discussion about
I am very interested in a NYC condo that lists for 1,295,000 (there have been two price drops). I will not be heartbroken if I do not get it, as this market obviously continues to decline and I have patience. What offer is sufficiently low to try and get get a real deal here without it being insultingly low? 20% below ask?
2004 price. If that's 20% down, be it.
Obviously depends on the buyer AND the seller.
1) What do you know about the seller? Do they need to sell? What did they pay for it?
2) Are you pre-approved ... I think the more certain the buyer the more willing the seller is to lower their price.
Good luck - curious to see what happens. Sounds like you have the right approach though, where you are willing to walk if need be.
The willingness to walk will work well in your favor--sellers and brokers can smell that. I wouldn't be too concerned with a 20% below offer; gather some comps to back up why you believe that is a fair price.
What's the worst that will happen... you'll insult the guy? Big deal.
One point I would make about lowballs is that buyers are getting too anchored to list. In most cases, what an apartment will go for is a function of what it's worth (in about 10% of cases there is a "seller unaware of reality" exception) and a thorough analysis of comps will give you some idea of what that number is.
But I have a whole article about this up on walletpop -- www.walletpop.com (second item down)
ali r.
{downtown broker}
2002 price
Ali - agreed it should be about what the apartment is worth, but I think you will have a hard time coming up with relevant current comps since even recent sales were done in a vastly different environment. I think it's fine to take current comps and subtract 40% similar to stock market declines, especially b/c past nyc real estate gains significantly outpaced the stock market in the past few years...
It really come down to how much you want the place, and what you are willing to pay for it.
If all you are *willing to pay* is say, $900k, then bid $900k. The worst they can do is say no. However, if you are *willing to pay* $1.1 million, but want to pay as little as possible, I think the issue becomes a bit different. It's not the risk of insulting them - personally I think in this market, where there is so much uncertainity and establishing comps is so difficult because there aren't enough out there yet, nobody should be "insulted" whether or not they want to take the offer. But, if you offer $900k, they say no, then you offer $1 million, they say no again, and you finally come up to $1.1 million, you lose your negotiating power. You can say all you want "this is a best and final offer" but if you've shown you are willing to negotiate, they won't know how serious you are, until you walk away.
buster2056: Excellent post. Since prior-sale comps get stale so quickly in this environment, I think on-market comps are more important - both for their inherent uses and as a guide to the appropriate haircut to apply to prior sales. Using the stock market as a proxy makes some intuitive sense, but there are other factors that can be used to refine the formula.
"Using the stock market as a proxy makes some intuitive sense"
No it doesn't. The bears are picking it because its down 40%. When it recovers (and it will long before housing does) they'll no longer think the stock market has any bearing (no pun intended) on real estate prices.
If you lowball 40%, do you *honestly* think the seller will take it? Why wouldn't they just drop ask by 10% and garner new interest like that? If an apartment is grossly overpriced, add it to your saved streeteasy listings and watch for price drops, coming back in a few weeks or months. But offering 40% below ask - I have a hard time imagining that ever working.
I think 20% is much different than 40% and in the range of reasonable. Even if 40% is the new fair price, I think most sellers are willing to take their changes and keep slashing prices 5-10% at a time until they attract interet. 40% probably would be tough even if it is the fair price.
kspeak - agree with you there, but there's no reason to pay 20% below when 40% off asking is the fair price. Obviously, the gap between most buyers and sellers is pretty wide right now or we would be seeing more transactions...
tech_guy: Nobody suggested bidding 40% below ask. As I understand the idea, Buster2056 suggested using the stock market to determine the haircut to apply to a prior-sale comp that went to contract at a given point in time. That means an October 2007 comp might get a 40% haircut, but an October 2008 comp might be taken at face value.
Personally, I think that approach assumes too tight a linkage between stocks and real estate; but it does have the virtue of capturing (though possibly overstating) the negative-wealth effect of a falling stock market. Anyway, the suggestion wasn't 40% off asking price. The recsult of the analysis might actually be an offer at full ask, depending on the age of the comps and how the subject property is priced in relation to them.
West81st, agreed, but I wouldn't accept an October '08 comp at face value... I think you can actually bid 40% below asking because most asking prices are at October '07 levels. We have seen evidence of some asking prices falling below '07 comps (even '06 and '05 comps in certain instances) but they are far more the exceptions than the rule.
Thanks for everyone's input. I'm thinking if I go in at 20-25% below ask, and the seller is motivated (which I think she is), I can reasonalby expect to get somewhere between 10-15% below the reduced price once the neogtiating process plays out. If I get that, I believe it is a very good value, particularly since I'm planning on living there for at least 5 years so I'm less concerned about a short-term dive in prices. If I don't, I'm willing to walk away and see where the rest of the market goes in 6 months.
If you really like it and are ready to pull the trigger, offer them 999,000 and tell them that there is no financing contingency and that you are prepared to close in 30 days. Tell them this is your only offer, and they can take it or leave it. If they sheepishly come back to you at say 1.1, say, that for the sake of expediency, you will go as high as 1.015, but not a penny higher. You may be slightly overpaying for the unit, but if you love it and want to live there and can afford it, I think you will get the unit for this price. If they balk and the unit languishes for another 6 months, go back to them again with 950,000. You have the right attitude in that you don't really care if they don't accept your offer. That is the right mindset to bring to the negotiation.
the danger of using the drop in the stock market as a proxy for what real estate "ought" to be worth is that to a certain extent they're substitutable assets -- if the stock market is crashing, other asset classes should be more in demand, not less.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Do you have a broker? If not, don't use one - the listing agent will be much more likely to push the seller to accept.
Ali - so by your theory, if the stock market is rising, real estate should be in less demand? That didn't hold true over the past few years when real estate had excess returns above the stock market implying a high beta. You could make the argument that NYC Real Estate should fall even harder... Realistically, when risky assets are experiencing declines, people move towards safer/risk-free assets, and real estate does not typically fall into that category.
No, by my theory, you value an apartment by looking at 1) recent sold comps; and 2) the availability and quality of alternatives for your money -- this includes looking at on-market comps, the cost of money, the safety and returns of other asset classes, and considering alternatives such as not renting.
This also allows for a factor of "what the apartment is worth to me" -- maybe a certain location is worth more to you than to most buyers because it's right near your work, for example.
But I'm not going to look at list and adjust by any "X factor." That puts you on the seller's playing field, a concession that I think buyers shouldn't make.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
^^ sorry, I meant "not buying"
ali r
{downtown broker}
Hi front_porch--you seem to know a lot about the market. What do you think of this property: http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/354805-condo-121-west-20th-street-chelsea-new-york.
Any insight into the apartment and/or building?
Frontporch - I agree that "recentely sold comps" are generally the best way to value an apartment. It's not that this is reflective of it's intrinsic value - it's becoming clear now that most places that sold in the past few years sold above their instrinsic value as measured by price to rents / relative cost of renting vs. buying which is probably the most pure way to value - but it WILL tell you what somebody is likely going to be willing to sell it to you for today. At the end of the day, you're not going to get something for much less than the market is willing to pay, unless the seller is really stupid. If the market is willing to pay more than you are or more than its intrinsic value, you're best not being in the market at all (this has been my strategy for the past few years).
However, I don't think there have been enough listings that have gone into contract in the "new world order" (e.g., post mid-September) to do this. That's why I think it's a really interesting market right now - there is the potential to get a good deal, but also the difficulty of convincing the seller of what has happened.
Well, warybuyer, I'm a member of REBNY, which is the NYC real estate trade association, and one of the things that means is that I can only comment on other people's listings in the most general terms (I've heard about another broker who once got his hand slapped for saying POSITIVE things about other REBNY member listings).
The building is an old warehouse, I believe, and it was converted in 1991 in a wave of development in Chelsea (I lived on West 26th Street, which was nowheresville, at the time). Andrew Heiberger, who used to run Citi Habitats, wrote an article where he described the "Barney's District" (the original Barney's men's store was down there) and mentioned buildings like the Chelsea Mercantile, the Grand Chelsea and the Campiello Collection all in the same sort of competitive set.
Chelsea 121 is more "lofty" than some of those others, so I think the question is whether loft features like a part-time doorman and a bedroom that's somewhat open are the right lifestyle fit. The neighborhood has certainly gotten much more residential than when I lived there, with a Whole Foods and all sorts of other available retail.
This building kind of reminds me of the Cass Gilbert too, although the Cass Gilbert is further north so maybe that's no a fair comparison.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
understand the ethical contraints, thanks front_porch.
Yes, the building is an old warehouse (I think from 1891) which gives this apartment a TON of character (20 foot ceiling, french doors, etc.) The doorman is pretty much there all the time except for a brief period on the weekends. And right now, the second bedroom, which is open (and the office upstairs) I wouldn't use as a bedroom, but you're right, I should think about that is we have kids some day.
Offer $500 per square foot. That will get their attention.
For what it's worth, I think you are subject to the 1% "mansion" tax at $1 million and above. You might want to consider that in your bidding process.