Prime RE being hit: Sale at 2 Fifth Avenue #PHF
Started by kylewest
about 18 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007
Discussion about 2 Fifth Avenue #PHF
While this area is prime, this building is not. Methinks the original price was ridonkulous...
Oh, Kylewest, you of all people taking list-to-list to heart as a data point! I'm glad you hedged yourself with "I haven't compared comps" --
Let's look at the price history of this particular building:
OLR shows the highest previous sale in that building as PH DF, which sold in 2004 at $3.9 million.
Between 2005 and 2007, seven apartments were floated at prices above $3 million, and none of them sold.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Oh, Kylewest, you of all people taking list-to-list to heart as a data point! I'm glad you hedged yourself with "I haven't compared comps" --
Let's look at the price history of this particular building:
OLR shows the highest previous sale in that building as PH DF, which sold in 2004 at $3.9 million.
Between 2005 and 2007, seven apartments were floated at prices above $3 million, and none of them sold.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
It sure doesn't help that this place is set up as a 1 bedroom unit. It's also too bad that for a PH with the views it has that there isn't enough true outdoor terrace space for entertaining.
This building was getting +/- $1.3MM for one bedrooms as recently as first 1/2 of 2008--top dollar in GV. Whether you think the building is "prime" or not, it fetches the same high prices as the pre-wars in the area. It's proximity to Wash. Sq. Park increases its value since many of the units overlook or have views of the park.
True ali--not much success selling in the $3MM+ department for this building. There is a listing at $6.5MM that apparently is "in contract." But FWIW it appears that many highend and mid-range apts on the Gold Coast are not being exactly snatched up lately. An offer at 30 Fifth of two apts that can be combined (a rare opportunity there) is sitting for months, the penthouses at 40 Fifth were pulled from the market I think, 1-bedrooms that flew off the shelves in 2007 at these units with little time on the market are lingering now. This prime area is definitely feeling the chill of the market. Prices are resisting the market forces but I see some slippage beginning off the peaks. You show me a one bedroom that sells for $1.35MM or $1.4MM at 20 E 9 St (Brevoort East) or 2 Fifth since spring (prices achieved in 2007/early 2008), and I'll take it back.
sorry, ali. that was me above. two accounts.
well, my question -- which I may have posed here before, forgive me,
"we know in previous down markets there's been a flight to quality; let's say we expect that again -- what's quality? Is it those Gold Coast homes that I think you and I both love so much, or is it newer luxury condos?"
also, what's the local betting on Jefferson Market coming back?
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Personally I think foremost "quality" means things that are immutable like a park outside your door, landmarked districts with plenty of light and low-rise buildings. Next, is sort of a "lack of negatives" in my book, meaning good layouts, excellent buildings with doormen and solid finances etc, no huge issues like prison nextdoor or soup kitchen and vagrants or power station or hospital ER entrance, etc. Some new construction might qualify, most does not. A shiny new awkwardly configured box with silly small spaces will age and the other factors above will be all that is left to consider; a lacquered gimmick of a "pod" in the middle of a new construction livingroom that gets all chipped and was stupid to start with (see Jade) is not quality of the type I mean no matter how many levels the rooftop lounge has.
I haven't a clue as to Jefferson Market...anyone else know?
This apartment is an extremely inefficient use of space.
For this kind of money I could retire to the Midwest in real comfort!