significant amount of job loss will be commuters
Started by steveF
about 18 years ago
Posts: 2319
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
Those hoping for job loss to soften real estate market?... this one's for you..... The latest statistics show drivers took 25 million trips over bridges and through tunnels last month, down 1.3 million - or 4.8% - from October 2007. Much of the 12-month slide can be attributed to high gas prices. But last month's downturn may be the result of commuters no longer having jobs to go to in Manhattan, officials said. Traffic at the MTA's four Manhattan crossings was down on average about 7% from September to October, even though gas prices had fallen, Moretti said. "It would be the high-paid guys and gals who would rather drive [to work] than ride the train," MTA Chairman Dale Hemmerdinger said. "My goodness." -NYDailynews
Wow, I guess that must mean that no one who lives in Manhattan got laid off. Great statistical analysis, Steve.
no aboutready...it just seems that most people think that layoffs automatically means manhattan dwellers. I'd be willing to bet that most of those layed off are living in Westchester and North Shore/garden City LI.
Don't shoot the messenger, steveF is right. You can expect 1st tier burbs (Greenwich and the like) to drop to around $100psf, 2nd tier burbs (south shore of LI etc.) drop below $50psf, and brooklyn brownstones will be 3 for $10 (just like those I love NY shirts). Expect 10 fold increases in Manhattan.
Of course there will be layoffs across the region. But Steve starts with "those hoping for job loss to soften real estate..." Oh, TheFed, I just caught the irony.
Steve, you don't have a clue exactly where the layoffs will come from, certainly not "most". They will be widespread. I am not hoping for anyone's demise myself, just a correction of an articially inflated asset class. Unfortunately that won't likely happen without a lot of pain.
Wouldn't you say though, aboutready, that due to the historically low ownership rate in NYC and the still predominant migration to the suburbs when space is needed, that layoffs are more likely to impact renters in nyc and homeowners in the burbs and outer boroughs (I'm thinking Staten Island with its very high ownership rate compared to other byc boroughs) than they are owners in Manhattan in terms of numbers?
of course there are more people laid off who commute than work in manhattan, because clearly most people who work in manhattan during the day don't live there (i am not sure what the number is but i have heard the population of the city triples during the day). but all that matters is what percent of people who live in Manhattan are laid off, and what percent of people who live in the suburbs or boroughs are laid off, not the absolute number. e.g., if 100,000 people who live in manhattan out of 1.5 million residents are laid off, that is the same thing as if 500,000 out of 3.0 million comuter is laid off (these are made up numbers).
of course there are more people laid off who commute than work in manhattan, because clearly most people who work in manhattan during the day don't live there (i am not sure what the number is but i have heard the population of the city triples during the day). but all that matters is what percent of people who live in Manhattan are laid off, and what percent of people who live in the suburbs or boroughs are laid off, not the absolute number. e.g., if 100,000 people who live in manhattan out of 1.5 million residents are laid off, that is the same thing as if 500,000 out of 3.0 million comuter is laid off (these are made up numbers).
Why percentage?
If inventory numbers (not percentages) are an important indicator as many of us have discussed then wouldn't it be interesting to quantify how many apts are due to come onto the market in Manhattan (or choose your borough - aboutready and I are interested in Manhattan) because of layoffs?
And then wouldn't be interesting to quantify size, location etc of each apt?
Because - there are fewer Manhattan apartments than suburban resdiences, so all that matters is the number of people in manhattan who lose their jobs RELATIVE to the amount of apartments available. It only makes sense that fewer people who live in Manhattan will lose their jobs - the overall pool is smaller. Unless for some reason one beli
Inventory numbers matter in the same way - inventory is relevant only RELATIVE to average number of transactions per year/total apartments in the city/total number of buyers. But there is no need to talk about inventory numbers in percentage terms because the number is already anchored to what "normal" inventory is based upon last year's number. That's why you can't really compare inventory numbers across cities very well - having 5,000 places on the market may be high in one city and low in another.
It's like those idiots in 1998 ... "this dot-com gave me 10,000 options! wow, that's so many" - but what matters is how many shares in the whole company they are, what the exercise price is, etc.
Really, a very simple concept.
First paragraph - I mean to say "unless somebody believes a lower/higher percentage of people in Manhattan will lose their jobs." But I doubt this will be true. I think this will be pretty true across the board - e.g. layoffs at all levels.
The biggest difference for the Manhattan market is that people have the option to leave and move somewhere cheaper. No matter how cheap it gets, you're always going to pay more for 1,000 square feet in manhattan than the suburbs. Of course, people can always leave Westchester for the Atlanta suburbs, etc., so I suppose this argument can always be made.
Yes, inventory relative to turnover.
So if ave turnover is 5k a year and inventory is 5K then 100 extra apartments owned by laid off wall streeters is a useful number to know.
TheFED--what do you know about the Westchester market..specifically Southern Westchester,,,that is an awfully low PSF quote there....is it hurting that much more than NYC?
kspeak, I agree. Manhattan is a fairly sensitive market. Not much sells here (per population) in a robust year. A mild exodus has great effect. The effects may also be cumulative. If people can't afford to rent any longer, and leave Manhattan, that simply increases the total number of units available, which may be why this time around we may not have increasing rents with declining purchase prices. Total units available may decrease the price of rentals, forcing those people trying to rent out new units to lower their prices, creating further competition from a rent/buy perspective. Impossible to quanitfy now, but interesting nonetheless.
In New Jersey we have definitely noticed decreased traffic at the Holland Tunnel in the am. I know of many moderate to high income (350 and up) who are now unemployed, or 'less employed.' Meaning that they are still 'rich' by Obama standards (greater that 250/year) but much less rich that they were by a third to a half. No one to feel sorry for, but these people will not come up on the official radar when the stats about the unemployed roll around.
The places that will see the most layoffs are those that have high percentages of people that work in finance. Take a town like Darien, CT. There was a recent times article that said they had the largest # of financial workers (as a %) in the country. I think that it was somewhere around 30%. Also, i don't think that it is a big secret that most high-paid financial workers move to big houses in the burbs...In fact, I would say that the vast majority do.
On the other had, you have some towns that cater more towards marketing/creative types, those may be more immune.
on the flip side, when things tend to get ugly in the city (cut back police, crime, etc. etc.) people tend to flee the city for the better schools, safety and community that nice suburban towns have to offer. So, I would say that they will be the first to start recovering as well.