Skip Navigation

First Q4 Data - Sales Down 75%, Prices Down 10-15%, 2006 Prices

Started by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
http://ny.therealdeal.com/articles/new-manhattan-housing-data-provides-window-into-bleak-fourth-quarter New Manhattan housing data provides window into bleak fourth quarter By Candace Taylor The real estate industry is waiting with baited breath for the next round of quarterly market reports, when Manhattan will see the real effects of the mortgage crisis on home sales. But a new analysis by real... [more]
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

"Jackson estimated that apartments are now selling for roughly 10 to 15 percent less than they were in early 2008, when the credit crisis began to take hold in the city. The data also showed that homes are now being sold at levels approximately equal to what they were worth in the first half of 2006, he said."

And they will be down to 2000 levels shortly - there is no income, no credit, no demand.

"With the shrinking of the time period, maybe we'll get over it sooner."

That's true.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

The last part is interesting - about the speed. I think this will bottom faster than the last real estate downturn in the late 1980s/early 1990s, especially with the liquidity crunch. Although I think it will bottom and stay flat for a while ..

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

I agree... I think this will move FAST given how quickly the shit hit the fan and how slow NYC was to see it coming.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by type3secretion
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 281
Member since: Jun 2008

and so it begins.....

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by alpine292
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2771
Member since: Jun 2008

Sales down 75%? That has to be an error. I can't believe sales fell that much.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Sales were down 35-40% or so months ago. Why then would we be surprised if that accelerated once the panic started?

Remember, its YoY, so its not incremental..

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by type3secretion
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 281
Member since: Jun 2008

"He estimated that roughly 50 to 70 transactions are being signed per week in Manhattan, far fewer than in previous years.

The number of recorded sales in Manhattan in 2007, for example, was a record 13,430, according to city data, yielding an average of 258 sales per week."

60/258=0.23, so roughly 25% of levels in 2007. Assuming the typo isn't in the sales per week numbers.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Here is another way to look at it... who the hell would be buying this month?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

I actually can't believe sales were ONLY down 75%. That means 1 in 4 people still decided to buy now despite everything that was going on, I would think 90% of people who were going to buy would walk away. I bet many of these were listings in contract before labor day.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by West81st
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5564
Member since: Jan 2008

alpine: From 258/week to about 60/week is a drop of more than 75%. It's incredible, but the math is right. I guess the raw numbers could be wrong (contract numbers are less reliable than the tally of closed deals), but why would brokers hold back on reporting signed contracts in this environment?

One possible quirk is that private deals may only be counted when they close; so a comparison between 2007 closed deals and 2008 Q4 signings might be a bit of apples and oranges, or at least apples and pears

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

"I actually can't believe sales were ONLY down 75%. That means 1 in 4 people still decided to buy now despite everything that was going on, I would think 90% of people who were going to buy would walk away. I bet many of these were listings in contract before labor day. "

Bingo, kspeak.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

Type3 - your math!

(258 - 60) / 258 = -77%.

Remember, however, that last year was a statistical anomaly: the average over the prior 10 years was 8,500 units sold per year, or 163 a week. The decline is still significant at about 60%, but not 77%.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Totally. Falling 75% when going from peak time to a "twice every 100 years" crisis doesn't actually sound like very much.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by type3secretion
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 281
Member since: Jun 2008

oh, steve, i'm just thinking invertedly from you: -77% can be viewed as 23% OF THE 2007 levels. :)

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

Yes, Steve, fractions 101...

If you remove 75%, you have 25% left.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by hvd_free
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 90
Member since: Jan 2007

Steve - your math!

(258 - 60) / 258 = +77%.
(60 - 258) / 258 = -77%.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

anyone saying that a 75% decline doesn't sound like much is insane. i have never, ever, in my life and in my career, heard of sales volume declining 75% in a market year over year in one year. that is just catastrophic.

but it is also believable. just by looking at the data urban digs posts on his site every day i thought it was about that bad. but it's completely shocking.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

I don't think its crazy to say 75% decline in volume is unsurprising - especially relative to a really good year like 2007.

Volatility is the worst for any kind of deals hapenning- this is why M&A volumes are way down this quarter as well. We're in a period of unprecedented volatility right now; why would anybody want to pull the trigger. And I'm not even an "uber-bear" like many on this board.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

kspeak, if you weren't an uberbear before i hope this converts you. 75% decline in sales volume is unheard of in virtually any market. how can you not expect prices to crater?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kspeak
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 813
Member since: Aug 2008

Happyrenter - I don't have a crystal ball. It's the 15% drop in such a short period that is more alarming than the 75% drop in sales to me, given the volaitlity right now and frozen credit markets. A lot of people who wanted to buy couldn't buy even if they wanted to, and who would really want to buy when markets are like this? It's not to say that prices are going up and don't have further to fall, I don't think this either. I just think a 75% drop in sales volume is to be expected. It's the unbelievably quick drop in prices that is amazing.

As for the "uber-bear thing" - I posted my views on the "alternate case" on another thread about recession trends. I am not sure where I shake out, but I think some Wall Street business (M&A and private equity) will do nicely when the volatility quiets down (which it will likely not for a while), I think hyperinflation is somewhat of a possibility since the govenment is going to keep pumping money into the system to avoid deflation, and lastly while apartments are overvalued on a Price/Rents basis I am not sure if they are by 2x. I don't discount the uber-bear case either but am not in the "this will happen" category.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

> i have never, ever, in my life and in my career, heard of sales volume declining 75% in a market
> year over year in one year. that is just catastrophic.

Yes, it is catastrophic. But, relative to the equity markets, which are super-catastrophic....
So, its not that surprising. BIG, but not at all surprising.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

"Steve - your math!"

You subtract it from 1.

"never heard of sales volume declining 75% in a market year over year in one year. that is just catastrophic."

Quite possible. But that's not the real figure since last year was a record. The REAL problem is that there are still tens of thousands of units unsold, or about to come online. Precisely at the time when no one is buying.

Search "perfect storm" in the discussions. I said it in about February, I think.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

I thought 15-20% decline a year ago. Then, as of late, I've been saying 25-30%. In the last week, I'm starting to think I underestimated...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

50%. That is what needs to happen for prices to be in alignment with (falling) rents.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

I might have laughed at that just a few months back, but now I think we're going to get in the range. If I had to pick, I'm putting it at 35-40% median.... but, yes, I could easily see an overcorrection to 50% if there is enough panic.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by type3secretion
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 281
Member since: Jun 2008

"Yes, it is catastrophic. But, relative to the equity markets, which are super-catastrophic....
So, its not that surprising. BIG, but not at all surprising."

But it's Q4 2008. Many are predicting that this is the iceberg tip.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by NYRENewbie
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 591
Member since: Mar 2008

What is even crazier about all this is that brokers don't want to submit bids 30% off asking price because they might insult the seller. Did they ever think that those offers might actually be helping the seller in an uncertain market? Isn't a bird in the hand(someone with cash now) worth two in the bush?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

> But it's Q4 2008. Many are predicting that this is the iceberg tip.

In the RE market overall, yes. But slow sales come first, then sales speed up and prices get whacked. I don't think we're going to see sales slow to 0.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

50%.

They could fall further. They are already down 15% according to my calculations using the building where I used to live:

The apartment below mine is for sale for $1.149 million. A lesser apartment (2P) sold at the peak for $1.3 million. That is 12% nominal, at least 15% real adjusting for the difference in the apartments.

I sold for $675k in 2003, as did 4G, now listed for $1.149 million. That is still a 70% increase in FIVE YEARS!

Unsustainable. We will be back down to 2003 prices, perhaps even lower, in the medium-term.

This is collapsing fast. The faster, the better.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by dwell
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2341
Member since: Jul 2008

"I sold for $675k in 2003, as did 4G, now listed for $1.149 million. That is still a 70% increase in FIVE YEARS!"

That is insane. Seriously, what caused this jump? Seller's greed & buyer's stupidity? Seriously, how does that happen?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Amity95
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 145
Member since: Dec 2007

Yes, I agree brokers should submit the 30%+ off bids to the sellers. Even if the sellers didn't respond (and probably wouldn't - otherwise they would have just cut their price - almost all sellers are in denial right now) - at least it would let them know how out of the ballpark their asking price was....

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

"what caused this jump?"

Lax credit, obscene bonuses. I paid $218k for the place in 1998. Do the math.

This will be a crash.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by lowery
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1415
Member since: Mar 2008

this means real estate brokerage firms will lay off brokers and support staff, and perhaps need less office space

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by cleanslate
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 346
Member since: Mar 2008

"What is even crazier about all this is that brokers don't want to submit bids 30% off asking price because they might insult the seller."

They won't even submit 18% off the price just this week...and I know we're kinda insane bidding for it but I thought they're more insane not to entertain it. The fact of the matter is there's not a lot of qualified buyers left, they're becoming extinct by the minute and the brokers/sellers keep putting them off by holding on to these astronomical prices and the out-of-place posturing.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

If C does go under in the next few days - which seems likely - then we're looking at 2000 prices: $500 psf, vs. today's $1,800.

I don't care what BROKERS want - the world is different.

And if Bloomberg - a product of Wall Street - thinks that this time he can solve things with raising taxes, he's MISTAKEN. This is full-fledged deflation. He needs to deflate city & state government by minimum 30% to break even. It will be 30 years before we return to these levels of compensation.

If you don't believe me, it wasn't until about 1953 that stocks recovered to their 1929 levels. Worldwide we won't be anywhere near there, nor in the country as a whole, but in terms of NY tax revenue - YUP.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment