Will Prices Be Impacted by Wall Street Bonuses?
Started by NYFinancier
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 5
Member since: Aug 2007
Discussion about
The media has spent a lot of time reporting on how top I-Bankers will be getting zero bonuses this year. This is all well and good, however it does not account for the vast majority of bankers (and finance professionals) who will. If the below story is any indication, those who work in the private equity industry are in for some good news. Im not sure what this means for the I-banks, but the... [more]
The media has spent a lot of time reporting on how top I-Bankers will be getting zero bonuses this year. This is all well and good, however it does not account for the vast majority of bankers (and finance professionals) who will. If the below story is any indication, those who work in the private equity industry are in for some good news. Im not sure what this means for the I-banks, but the datapoint cant be insignificant. Will increases in 2008 bonuses in 2008 help prop on NY condo prices, or will these people be the few with liquidity to swoop in and get great deals in 2009? http://www.thedeal.com/dealscape/2008/10/pe_firms_still_doling_out_reco.php Some highlights: "The total cash compensation (base salary and cash bonus) for senior associates at the largest buyout funds (those with $5 billion or more in assets) is now $435,000, a 4% increase over their 2007 levels. (Don't be misled by the "senior" in senior associate; these are first year M.B.A.s, says the report.) At the principal level, large buyout funds pay an average total cash compensation of $885,000, also a 4% increase from last year. Bonuses for principals at these funds rose 6% to an average of $607,000, which is included in the $885,000" [less]
I think you are looking at a much smaller pool of people in PE versus I-Banking, so I am not sure how much impact these few individuals will have on the RE market across the board. It would give them a chance for some good deals.
FWIW, I do know a number of people in PE and not everyone (by any stretch) has had a banner year. A lot of people in PE and in hedge funds are going to be less than thrilled with their bonuses....especially when they look back at how many hours they have put in over the course of the past year.
I don't think the question is "will", but rather "to what extent".
If the PE guys spend their bonuses, that will help -- the question is going to be how they view the outlook for condos versus other asset classes.
If it is painful enough for them to hold stocks and cash, real estate will start to seem like a safe haven, and they'll buy condos.
Otherwise, they'll probably stay on the sidelines for the most part, buying only properties that they perceive as "special" -- which means they'll prop up the co-op market.
ali r.
[downtown broker}
Yes, pay no attention to the 100 to 1 ibanker to PE associate ratio....
> real estate will start to seem like a safe haven,
Not when the panic has already started... we're a little too late for that.
Seriously - and cash is only painful when other asset classes are rising...
Did it mention the form of the bonuses? Cash gets taxed, and helps the city/state with their budget issues. Stocks will have multi-year vesting periods, so that will be less of a help for the short term budget issues. It'll help eventually, as the money still gets taxed, but I doubt anyone here (aside from rufus) doubts that NYC will be back to its wonderful sustainable self again "eventually". Short term is the question market.
Forget this year's bonuses, the majority of the comp for the LAST 4 YEARS is in stock they COULD NOT SELL and is now basically worthless (or, at best, 30% of what they thought it was worth).
Thats a whole lot more of an issue than only losing 50% of this year's bonus.
"the majority of the comp for the LAST 4 YEARS is in stock they COULD NOT SELL and is now basically worthless"
Err... if the bonuses for the last 4 years are worthless, who cares if this year's bonuses are worthless too? Sounds like we can have a booming 3 years without any bonuses...
> who cares if this year's bonuses are worthless too?
1) They're not. This year's bonuses wouldn't be worthless, as if they're in stock they'd be at the lower prices.
2) My point was that the "lost income" from this years is peanuts compared to lost income from prior years... that looking at the hit this year is only getting part of the story.
I think what you are missing is that many have been fired, so the size of the buyer pool is much reduced relative to what has been normal from 2005 to 2008. Further, at the same time loans are more difficult to obtain and inventory is ballooning. Welcome to what is called 'the cycle'. The old 'doomed to repeat' cycle. You also forget how it makes someone feel to watch their stock holdings get cut in half. You are also forgetting the hedge fund business is as a whole -15%, which means no bonus this year, and probably no bonus next year. Maybe I am stating the obvious but the price is always set at the margin. You are using averages, which is a flawed analysis. Also the employed are better employees as a broad rule, many of them are the ones who already own, the ones who drove prices up in 2006 and 2007. They ain't moving or trading up any time soon.
Rhino, I agree that all of your points are valid, but I worry more that your points will affect the rental markets. People who are fired are going to move to Chicago and post endlessly on these boards about how much better Chicago is. That's one less renter in the market, possibly driving down rents.
Lower rents can materially impact real estate prices in the medium term. Without that, any shocks will be short term at best, as rent vs. buy will push prices back to equilibrium.
Techguy, did you somehow just try to argue that because there are fewer people going to be looking to live in manhattan (or can afford to live in manhattan) that that somehow isn't going to drive prices down?
I look at it this way, its pretty simple. A few things drove Manhattan RE up.
Strong national economy
Record wall street bonuses
Idea that wall street would continue to pay record bonuses
Record NYC net worth
Dramatic increase in NYC quality of life because of all of the above hitting tax revenues
Idea that RE only goes up nationally
Idea that RE only goes up dramatically in NYC
Low mortgage rates
Foreign buyers padding the market
Only one of those factors hasn't been absolutely decimated.
Nyc10022, I think Tech_guy argued there is more impact on rental markets than purchase markets on account of these factors....but I find it just as silly an argument as you do. I think people may reason that out because in 2001-2002 interest rates were grinded down into the dust "saving" the purchase markets at the expense of the rental market. This time, rates are already low, and the financial industry contraction is way more severe. Also real estate didn't start 2001 nearly as overvalued, nor was hedge fund money (or removal of same) near the factor it is today. Listen, I am ready to listen to the compelling argument that real estate won't get cut in half to the AVERAGE price to rent multiple at the CURRENT rental prices... The reality is, as has been with most everything in this debacle, that the first guess at the correction in prices is going to prove too conservative. Manhattan real estate probably has to go down 65% to 8x peak annual rent.
PS: Techguy, what do you view as equilibrium? 25x annual rent is not equilibrium. Also, markets do not ever correct to equilibrium; they overshoot. Also, I am starting to wonder if you are worthy of engaging.
This is an absurd story. Not even Baghdad Bob (I mean Paulson) could convince himself there's truth here. I have many close friends in this industry, at major firms, and they are firing people quietly, and drastically reducing their payouts as past deals have soured significantly, and current LP interests are selling for fractions on the dollar at the biggest funds, so capital is not forthcoming. I mean, WTF!@! For every 1 firm having a decent year (who clearly did NO deals between 2006 and now because they are all equity zeroes), there's 10 more that aren't. Look, prices are falling fast in NYC, and they will continue to do so..It's called cycles, they happen
I agree with aj202. Here's my post from another thread where the same ridiculous story was referenced:
I saw that story in the deal - it's retarded, and if you think about it, you will understand why. 2008 bonuses have not yet been paid or announced in ANY PE firm that I know of. For PE, like ibanking, well over 50% of comp is bonus. So how can they possibly know what 2008 comp is, or compare it to 2007? That's right, they can't. More generally, I am quite familiar with these types of studies over the years (for myself and friends), and the methodology is complete crap. Definitions of titles, firms, pay, geography, etc. make it impossible to get a clear picture.
Speaking anecdotally, PE pay will be down this year, down more next year, hiring is way, way down, and layoffs are starting.
I was arguing that Rhino's points *would* affect the rental market. I'm also arguing that unless the rental market is affected, the purchase market won't change (or if it does, it'll be a short term panic that corrects back to equilibrium).
"PS: Techguy, what do you view as equilibrium? 25x annual rent is not equilibrium. Also, markets do not ever correct to equilibrium; they overshoot. Also, I am starting to wonder if you are worthy of engaging."
If you look hard enough (and negotiate well enough) you could get a bit under 20 (I know I did, and that was before Lehman failed). Are there properties priced at 25x or even 30x? Of course, and they will go down. But I really don't care if a bunch of new construction rush jobs get cut a ton - that's not the majority of properties (majority of transactions, sure - they are new constructions and must transact - but not the majority of properties).
As for the multiple, as I've said many times before, interest rate affects it a ton. What time frame are you using for 12x? I bet you anything that time frame includes a ton of time with mortgage rates above 10%, even above 15%. If mortgage rates go that high again now, real estate prices *will* come down considerably to keep the rent vs. buy math in check.
If mortgage rates remain stable, and rents remain stable, a lot of properties are at equilibrium prices now.
"Nyc10022, I think Tech_guy argued there is more impact on rental markets than purchase markets on account of these factors....but I find it just as silly an argument as you do."
You're giving him way too much credit... I'm pretty sure he doesn't get how any markets work at all.
> I'm also arguing that unless the rental market is affected, the purchase market won't change (or if
> it does, it'll be a short term panic that corrects back to equilibrium).
Yeah, this has absolutely no basic in logic or history.
Not to mention "correcting back to equilibrium" means a 40% or so decline.
So, basically, look elsewhere for intelligent predictions.