Skip Navigation

Taking stock of the market

Started by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008
Discussion about
For the past six weeks I have been following 45 apartments in the West Village, Central Village, and the south of Chelsea. These apartments range from 2-4 bedrooms, with asking prices from $1.5 to $3.1 million. Some are in doorman prewar buildings on lower 5th or Bing and Bing in the West Village, some in loft buildings, a couple in townhouses, some in postwar buildings. Not one has gone into contract or gone off the market. If anyone else is following a segment of the market I'd love to hear if you have been seeing the same thing. If you have seen apartments in your universe go into contract, please provide links. I'd love to see what is moving these days.
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008

I saw a few apartments in Carnegie Hill going into contract. All Classic 7s for just under $4m. As soon as they came down below $4, they went into contract. But then again there is not a lot of inventory.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008
Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

Just to be strictly accurate, that's an 8 room apartment. But it did go into contract--thanks. Maybe 8 room apartments on Park Avenue can move under $4 then. If you can find any of the other ones you saw move, that would be great.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008
Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

perhaps we should call this thread "catch the falling knife"? thanks uppereast.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jake
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007

1185 5H was reduced to $3.995mm - Likely went for less. 2 floors down, 3H went to contract and closed in the summer of 2007 for $4.550mm.

I would think deals start to happen as the only apartments on the market now are the ones that really have to sell - estates in particular need to find clearing levels as the taxes come due, carrying costs are high and it's pretty had to divide an apartment 3 ways - much easier dividing a pile of cash.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008

Not sure about your analysis. Many of these buyers have children in the schools nearby and plan on staying for the long haul. Keep in mind these are coops and people that are going to pass the boards have enough assets to not be forced to sell over the next 5 years. These are not the hedge fund guys in their 20s that had a few good years and overleverage.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

we don't know who these people are. fact is, if you buy now you are either getting an exceptional deal, or you should expect a significant depreciation in the value of your asset. hedge funder, trust fund baby, law partner, movie star, no one is going to come through this unscathed.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jake
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007

Sorry uppereast I don't understand your comment. My post was about sellers.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008

Jake, wasn't responding to you but rather to happyrenter. We posted at the same time. Happyrenter was saying we should call it catching the falling knife and I disagreed with that. To your post, 6H sold for $3.75 in Feb 07. You don't know the condition of either one of these apt. so there it is hard to say how much prices dropped.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

upper east, you also don't know what the apartment sold for. all we know is THAT it sold, and that it sold with a given asking price.

chapin, dalton, and spence were all there in the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s. The east side coops all had strict rules in the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s. Didn't prevent enormous price declines in each of those decades. My grandmother bought a full floor apartment in 660 Park in the mid 70s for $5,000. The previous owner had given it to the coop to get out the maintenance payments, and they essentially gave it away to get the maintenance paid.

Just saying.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jake
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007

Agree uppereast. 5H likely clears around the same price as 6H. But why would you assume that I don't know the condition of either one of these apartments?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008

I am not saying it won't go down but these are people that can sit it out. Also, I believe the number of kids under 5 has doubled in Manhattan, many more familites want to stay and there are simply not so many true 3brs in Carnegie Hill, especially if you like Pre-war and/or Park Ave

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uppereast
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 342
Member since: Nov 2008

Jake, O.K, I should say I don't know the condition of these apartments. Did you see them? Were they comparable? Would be curious to know.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

if you insist. we'll see.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by patient09
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1571
Member since: Nov 2008

actually, you don't know if it TRADED, all you really know is that it currently is in contract.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jake
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Jan 2007

uppereast,
3H was renovated but very modern. Seemed very out of place in that building. 5H was estate condition and needed a lot of work. I did not see 6H. East 88th I did not see but judging from the pictures and layout it seemed in very good conditon and it obviously was priced right.

There is some pent up demand and as you point out, one needs strong financials in these buildings. There are generally no forced sellers living in these co-ops - yet. But there is and there will be supply.

Right now supply is coming from estates where the owner is no longer around. But make no mistake. We are only at the beginning of the crisis. We may yet wind up with distressed sellers who have over extended themselves, are unemployed or have incomes which are greatly reduced or paid largely in paper not in cash.

My point is that if an apartment is on the market at present, given the state of things and the holidays rapidly approaching, it is on the market because there is a serious need to sell.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008

happyrenter, I am about as bearish as you, but I agree with upper east - "catching a falling knife" is too much of a generalization. No one knows for a fact where RE prices are headed (if they did, they'd already be there), and if you can find an apartment you love, that you can live in for 10-20 years or more, at a price you can comfortably afford, who cares what prices do in the next 3-5 years. This is especially true if you find a desperate enough seller who accepts your lowball offer - I think of this as getting a 2010 price today, and starting to enjoy your new home earlier.

I am sure there are stupid buyers who are, in fact, catching falling knives, I just don't think that necessarily describes all of them.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008

I am keeping track of over 50 apartments, mostly 3-4 bedrooms on UES, UWS and midtown, with a few larger 2-bedrooms sprinkled in. The vast majority have not moved, but here are a couple exceptions:

http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/192636-coop-60-sutton-place-south-sutton-place-new-york
Went into contract 11/17. Curious whether it closes, and at what price.
I would've been tempted near the last asking price if the bedrooms were significantly larger. Obviously a huge "if"

http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/127247-condo-500-west-53rd-street-clinton-new-york
We saw this one in the summer. Beautiful place, and the price seemed ok for new construction. Layout is horrible, though, and the area is so-so at best. Something weird with the timing - streeteasy alerted me that it had gone into contract shortly after the last price chop on 9/19, then went into contract again on 11/12 and closed on 11/20. So I am not sure if it really went into contract twice, or if it was just a glitch. In any case, very curious about the price it sold at.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008

Oh, one more:

http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/357543-coop-61-west-62nd-street-lincoln-square-new-york
Went into contract 11/14 after a month on the market and no chops. Smarter sellers - the asking price was not outrageous for the layout, condition and location. One might even argue that the price was pretty compelling, but the maintenance is very high. Like 60 sutton place, curious whether it closes and at what price.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by evnyc
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1844
Member since: Aug 2008

I'm tracking lower-end 2-bedrooms in Brooklyn (Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO, Downtown Brooklyn, Cobble Hill, Boerum Hill and Park Slope). Of 30+ tracked, 6 have gone into contract since September and two are simply listed as unavailable.

Also watching a couple of "dream on" properties, but that's just for kicks.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008

"happyrenter, I am about as bearish as you, but I agree with upper east - "catching a falling knife" is too much of a generalization. No one knows for a fact where RE prices are headed (if they did, they'd already be there),"

Sure they do... DOWN. And your logic is wrong. We DID know, months (some even years) ago.

You are confusing some knowing with ALL knowing and moving the market there. Much of the city was stupid, sure, but tons of folks got it early and made that clear.

Many called the decline, and the decline is officially in. Most of those same folks are calling further declines.

Burying your head in the sand won't make it better.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008

"You are confusing some knowing with ALL knowing and moving the market there. Much of the city was stupid, sure, but tons of folks got it early and made that clear." Fair point, I screwed that up.

that said, nyc10022, - you don't know anything in the future for a fact. If you did, you'd give me 100-1 odds that NYC RE will be down at least 20% from peak by 2010 (I'm sure we could agree on a way to measure). Free money for you, right, since you know it for a fact? But you won't of course, and you shouldn't.

Read the rest of my post. For someone buying their dream apartment at a great price that they can comfortably afford, all the positives of owning may well outweigh the possibility that prices go further down, even if that possibility is actually a high probability.

If you buy some overpriced new construction for $2000psf, I agree that you're almost certainly catching a falling knife. But what if you can get your dream apartment for $800psf? Still a falling knife? $600psf? $400psf? $200psf? At some point there's a point where it makes sense, and that point is different for every apartment and every buyer.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by happyrenter
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2790
Member since: Oct 2008

newbuyer, you are certainly correct that at some point it makes sense to buy an apartment. but when you say that you can just buy and be happy and not worry about what happens over 3-5 years i think you buy into a delusion--that is, that this downturn is a temporary hiccup and that NY real estate will start booming again. the truth is that the boom of the last ten years was essentially unprecedented and is unlikely to return.

think about the nasdaq market. people who bought in when the nasdaq was at, say, 4000, might have comforted themselves when it plunged to 1500 by saying that it would be back within 3-5 years. but it is now eight years later and we are nowhere near the peak. it's possible that real estate prices in nyc won't return to the peak of 2006/2007 for ten or fifteen years--longer when you count inflation. no matter what your time horizon is, no one wants to buy right before a 15 year downturn.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by newbuyer99
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Member since: Jul 2008

happyrenter, I never said anything about the downturn being temporary or light. The reality is that no one knows for sure, although there's certainly risk of it being prolonged and/or severe.

I like the Nasdaq analogy a lot too, and have used it here before, having lived through it. I find that a lot of dynamics of bubbles and inevitable subsequent busts are very similar. That said, I do think there are some differences:

1) Many tech stocks literally had zero intrinsic value, no profits, revenues, etc. NYC apartments do have some intrinsic value, which set a floor for how far they can fall. In other words, for them to fall 70% and stay there, rents would have to fall at least 40-50%, surrounding suburban real estate would have to plunge, etc. All possible, I suppose, but pretty unlikely in my view.

2) There is very little satisfaction from owning a stock. There is plenty from owning your home. You can do a lot in it and to it, that you can't do in a rental. You also don't have to worry about having to move if the landlord jacks the rent, or refuses to renew the lease, or whatever else. To be clear, those benefits don't justify paying astronomical prices, but they do exist, and often come into play.

3) You can't really negotiate stock purchases - there's a public clearing price. In RE, you can find a desperate seller and negotiate an amazing price that's as good as anything you ever expect to get in the future. I've made this point before, but you seem to ignore it, so I'm repeating.

4) In any market, there may be exceptions. If you bought Nasdaq in December 2000 (i.e. much too early), you'd be down over 40% today. But if you bought AMZN in December 2000, you'd be up more than 150% (even though it went down further first). I would argue that there's a lot more AMZN's in an illiquid and quirky market like RE than in public stocks.

At the end of the day, none of us has a crystal ball and can predict the future. I am on the sidelines precisely because I believe there is a lot more upside than downside in waiting 1-2 years. But if I saw an apartment I loved for a price I loved tomorrow, I well may reconsider. You and nyc10022 are well within your rights to think I'm crazy for saying that.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by KeithBurkhardt
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 3003
Member since: Aug 2008

I have no idea how bad it will get but when I started as a broker in 91 it was BAD! There was virtually no sales market downtown. JI Sophers sales agents worked out of the basement and were mostly "wealthy" women that needed something to keep them busy. Co-op's were essentially rental buildings I had owners for whom I rented out there units at 250 Mercer street and 7 East 14th street begging me to just pay them what they owed the bank. At Mercer it was $30k, problem was the rent generated by the unit just barely covered the maintenance.At the end of the 80's developers were offering balloon financing for 5 years with 5% down(the only one I remember downtown was 275 Greenwich) then the idea was you re financed- didn't work out that way by the time it was time to get a real mortgage you were so far underwater it was not a possibility. Two other casualties I remember were Tribeca tower which was supposed to be a condo not a rental building the developer went bankrupt and related bought it. Also the Milan on 23rd street was another rare condo project, that went bust as well and was converted to a rental. Will things get this bad again? I hope not.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
almost 18 years ago

I am new to the area and trying to find out about leonard,worth and walker in Tribeca.Are they good areas and does anyone recommend a building?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Burkhardt
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9
Member since: Nov 2008

I had owners for whom I rented out there units at 250 Mercer street and 7 East 14th street begging me to just pay them what they owed the bank.

I'm sorry, I'm just a real estate broker but I'll do better in the future with spelling and uses of the word there versus their.

Thanks for being patient with me.

The most I post, the more people go to my web site. Free advertising, get it?

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment