Charting a strategy
Started by aj202
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 49
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
As most on these boards are convinced NYC prices are headed lower, I'm curious as to how those who are SERIOUSLY considering buying into a declining market are approaching this over the next 6 months. What price levels would nudge you? Are they absolute? Relative to previous peaks? Relative to rent? I for one am seriously looking at 2 BR's (family situation has changed) b/w $1-$1.5mm and think I will have MANY good options on the UES for $500-$600/sf in this period.
I think you have to keep in mind that NYC could go through some major changes over the next year. Things are very uncertain right now. What will happen to the public and private schools? Will families still want to live in the city? If not, then there could be a glut of large apartments hitting the market soon. This could have an impact on the 2Br/2Ba market b/c for the price you're paying now, you might be able to get another room or two in 6 months, if that matters to you. There may be some opportunity to purchase a poorly combined 4BR unit at a fire sale price, and break them apart, keeping one for yourself and sell or rent out the other one. The suburban markets have some very compelling offers right now with tuition-free, uncrowded public schools, and opportunities to work in mini-cities like White Plains or Stamford. This could seriously impact the family apartment market in Manhattan, which would trickle down to the smaller units.
I think schools are a major concern to people right now, and once one private school goes under, I think many families may get nervous and look to raise kids in well-established suburban public systems that are seemingly more stable.
Every investment involves elements of risk and uncertainty. I recognize that real estate prices embed a set of expectations regarding some unknowns but I was just curious as to what prices are required for potential buyers to feel these "uncertainties" are to a large extent, priced in...Higher taxes, busted schools, bursting credit bubbles clearly bode ill for real estate valuations but at what point does that pale next to the long term potential for NYC real estate? Probably a theoretical exercise but just throwing it out
If you could get a unit in tribeca for 900psf would that entice you?
Michele...to be excited over 900psf is strange...
Michele1045, that might entice me!
Michele...to be excited over 900psf is strange...
Michele...to be excited over 900psf is strange...
Michele...to be excited over 900psf is strange...
it all depends on what unit. there might be some unit in tribeca that would seem a great bargain at 900psf. but if you mean an average unit, then no way.
If it's going to go down to 500-600 in UES (as I think it'll do) then it shouldn't be over 700-800 in Tribeca.
(1) To buy now it is best that you are already be in the market, so essentially you are trading assets for the bulk of the sale. Depreciation in the RE market will impact you less since you are selling/buying at essentially the same time.
(2) You must have AT LEAST 5+ year horizon. I would personally not consider buying anything if I weren't planning to hold it for 10-20 years. If you plan to sell in 5 yrs or less, you could very well take a real loss. You have no business buying into this market with a short time horizon and any prudent indepenent financial advisor would tell you purchasing in today's market must be considered a medium-high risk investment. Are your jobs/financial situation stable? If not, this is NOT a time to buy for you.
(3) Value, value, value. Location, building quality, layout, light, views. This is NOT a market to scrimp in. Protect investment as best as possible by compromising as little as possible on these fundamental, virtually unimprovable aspects of any apartment. Pay attention to how immutable these qualities are: is the view in a landmarked neighborhood or can a highrise go up out your window? Is the 2d Avenue subway about to dig under your building for the next 5-10 years (assuming the project goes forward) and is an entrance planned for in front of your building? Is the layout gracious or wierd? Realize building amenities are likely to be severely cut back in coming months/years or fees likely to rise significantly to maintaiin them. Shiny new finishes in new construcction will age by the time you want to sell and paying a premium for them is an investment you will not likely recover.
(4) Buyinig a unit with a tax abatement in place is an immediate benefit but carefully anticipate what those monthlies will/might be when it is time to sell. If you are in new construction in a building with a concierge, rooftop lounge, gym, pool, parking, and communal kids' playroom, ask what will happen when the tax abatement expires? If the monthlies will double or triple, will residents really be able to continue funding all those amenities? How will this affect resale?
There's a few of my thoughts. With a 20 year potential horizon and already owning an apartment for 15 years that I sold recently, I felt very comfortable trading up. Great mortgage rate on 30 year fixed (under 6%), prime 'hood, solid building with good finances, traditional and gracious junior-four layout. Great buy so money left to renovate to our liking and level of quality and taste. We were buying a place to live for the foreseeable future--not looking for the wisest "investment" in terms of is the RE better than a bond fund.
Julia,why is that strange,will it even come down further?And if so how long should someone wait till they jump in ?Cash and credit rating are high.....thanks for all the input
UWS classic 7, 2000 sq.ft., good original condition, solid doorman building (no need for fancy amenities), zoned for PS9 or PS87, $750/sq.ft. I think that's about 33% off peak, and 40-45% off peak ask.
In the immortal words of the Knights of the Round Table, "RUN AWAY, RUN AWAY!!!" To wit -
Tim: There he is!
King Arthur: Where?
Tim: There!
King Arthur: What? Behind the rabbit?
Tim: It *is* the rabbit!
King Arthur: You silly sod!
Tim: What?
King Arthur: You got us all worked up!
Tim: Well, that's no ordinary rabbit.
King Arthur: Ohh.
Tim: That's the most foul, cruel, and bad-tempered rodent you ever set eyes on!
Sir Robin: You tit! I soiled my armor I was so scared!
Tim: Look, that rabbit's got a vicious streak a mile wide! It's a killer!
Sir Galahad: Get stuffed!
Tim: He'll do you up a treat, mate.
Sir Galahad: Oh, yeah?
Sir Robin: You manky Scots git!
Tim: I'm warning you!
Sir Robin: What's he do? Nibble your bum?
Tim: He's got huge, sharp... er... He can leap about. Look at the bones!
King Arthur: Go on, Bors. Chop his head off!
Sir Bors: Right! Silly little bleeder. One rabbit stew comin' right up!
(Bors boldly struts down towards the mouth of the cave to slaughter the killer rabbit)
Knights: RUN AWAY! RUN AWAY! RUN AWAY!...
[after Bors is killed by the killer rabbit0
Tim: I *warned* you, but did you listen to me? Oh, no, you *knew*, didn't you? Oh, it's just a harmless little *bunny*, isn't it?
aj202, I think your math is off. If your price range is $1-1.5MM, and you want $500-$600psf, you are looking for an apartment between 1700 and 3000 SF. I don't think that's a 2-bedroom.
Also, I don't think expecting family-sized apartments in many parts of the UES to hit $500-$600psf is crazy, but I would guess you will have A LOT more options in that price range in 12-24 months than in 6 months. Just a guess.
We are sideliners, but would seriously consider buying if we saw something at/around 2000SF, a floorplan that allows for 4 legitimate bedrooms, a balcony or other outdoor space in a doorman or elevator building in decent area on UES, UWS, or midown for $1.5MM or less.
The big caveat is that we have not done school zone research yet (precisely because we are sideliners and thus not in a rush), and schools would likely impact any buying decision.
Malraux is right.
I'm not sure what he's getting at, but anyone who quotes Holy Grail is, by definition, right.
O, what a noble mind is here o'erthrown!
The courtier's, soldier's, scholar's, eye, tongue, sword;
The expectancy and rose of the fair state,
The glass of fashion and the mould of form,
The observed of all observers, quite, quite down!
And I, of ladies most deject and wretched,
That suck'd the honey of his music vows,
Now see that noble and most sovereign reason,
Like sweet bells jangled, out of tune and harsh;
That unmatch'd form and feature of blown youth
Blasted with ecstasy: O, woe is me,
To have seen what I have seen, see what I see!
Get thee to a nunnery.
This lady's not for burning.
As I have posted 1000 times. I buy every year and this year is no different. The property I am looking at right now is a shell in Washington Heights.
In a small condo,only 14 units with very little common space to have a building's financial ,list the building's utility to be 76k which is 35% of the revenue collected.
Is leonard,worth ,walker in tribeca good areas for condo's.Is it congested in the summer ,to get in and out of the area.New to the Area and looking to buy,Any information about the area would be appreciated