What happens to real estate prices in time of high inflation?
Started by ekartash
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 364
Member since: Jun 2007
Discussion about
I think there are likely some more variables that should be taken into account before equating monetary inflation to a new housing bull run...for one, credit will NEVER be like it was from 2002-2006!
But wouldn't inflation make it worth it to buy? rents could rise and keep prices stable?
ekartash, don't confuse ASSET inflation with PRICE inflation. they are very different.
also, the FED officially already started printing money already when it outright bought $5 billion of Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, and Federal Home Loan Bank corporate debt instead of the swap-a-roo tactics it had been implementing to date.
The New York Fed's website says the purchases are being "financed through the creation of additional bank reserves." The Fed has finally started to create money out of thin air.
This was just a test as $5 bill is chump change relatively, but it worked and mortgage rates went down without much mainstream media and market drama (except for the USD which started tanking as those in the know saw this as the 'start' of the printing presses, hence the ascent of Gold).
Watch for much more to come from this successful experiment.
I think the more important variable than current inflation would be inflationary expectations. Those expectations are correlated with long-term interest rates, which are negatively correlated with property values.
after the biggest credit bubble in history, with insolvent banks needing govt aid to stay alive, with consumer balance sheets filled with debts, with massive job losses upcoming, with no more investment banking model on wall street - basically no more wall street, with budget deficits likely to make prop taxes rise....this train of thought is outright silly.
The inflation you are referring to is a surge in the money supply, when in normal times (not after the biggest credit bubble in history and biggest housing bubble in history) yes RE generally does well. But we are at now now, and to simply ignore credit deflation and housing deflation as both these bubbles popped and to say the inflation that will come will re-ignite home prices is just narrow sighted. Rents are dropping because the 50% rise in 3 years has proven to be an unsustainable move as Manhattan enters its local economic slowdown. Nobody likes slowdowns. People argue every time that when housing slows, rents will rise because all those homeowners that dont buy or sell will rent. Not so. In slow times, times with negative wealth effect, plunging stock market and net worth's hurt, rents do not rise! Especially after rents rose 50% in about 3 years times.
A 750sft 1BR DRMN in UES used to rent for about 2200-2300 or so in 2005. In past 6 months or so these rents rose to about 3200-3400 or so. This rise is unsustainable and to say that given the slowdown rents will rise FROM HERE, I will take the other side and say that is wrong. I say rents will fall as this slowdown, job losses, neg wealth effect, hit Manhattan and affordability goes DOWN.
but if the fed keeps printing money, wouldnt that decrease the value of the dollar? and if thats the case, than the $10 i have in my bank account are now worth less. am i better off putting my $10 into something else (not saying it should be real estate)?
ekartash, again, you are confusing asset inflation with price inflation.
sure the value of the dollar will decrease. but the valuation of some asset classes (*cough cough* real estate) might decrease even more as it was in a massive bubble that just popped.
put your $10 into Gold if you're worried about it's decrease in value.
yea, gold. But I would never give investment advice here. MMAfia and I spent many comments discussing this very thing and that when the fed starts monetizing the debts, the printing that was done will likely devalue the dollar and that is when you MAY, and I stress may because nothing is ever certain, see hard assets that is nobody's liability (gold), rise.
just my two cents. Everyone is printing and bailing out.
but if you have price inflation, and wages rise accordingly (i guess thats a big IF), than wouldnt the cost of either buying or renting (even at todays prices) seem relatively cheap.
not if the asset is in the midst of a collapsing bubble at the exact same time that the credit pendulum swings from one extreme, ez credit, to the other, contracting/hard credit. You are for some reason taking out where we came from, what damage was done, and where we are now in your argument.
wage/price inflation just isn't in the cards in the near term, probably not in the not so near term either. wage deflation is occurring, and consumer prices have been declining as well. real estate has a development lag time, so in certain markets, such as NYC's, supply is still increasing as well.
as was pointed out earlier, real estate is a HUGE chunk of the CPI... so on paper we're likely not going to have inflation for a while.
And likely the other components also suffer price-wise because of declining Re.
sorry, just realized the irony of this...
Wall Street will save Manhattan RE...
Foreigners will save Manhattan RE...
Lawyers will save Manhattan RE...
Doctors will save Manhattan RE...
and now its...
INFLATION will save Manhattan RE...
Talk about wing and a prayer.
we will see a surge in monetary base though, and eventually those dollars will reach the ground as fed monetizes the debt.
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/fredgraph?chart_type=line&s[1][id]=BASE&s[1][transformation]=pc1
thing is, this chart is a bit misleading as much as it is amazing to look at because the destruction of wealth in the shadow banking system more than offsets this 'printing'. So where is the money going?
RESERVES!
Why you ask? Well banks still have tons of toxic assets on their books of all sorts of securitized debt, all quality classes, and we certainly have more writedowns ahead of us as this process continues. I mean, there is $300Bln of alt-a securities on review for downgrade right now. Go do a search in google for "alt-a securities under review" and read up on what is coming as reviews are completed by ratings agencies already under intense scrutiny after dropping the ball!
i am not saying that anything should save real estate. just wondering what would happen in time of inflation. and i dont believe you can just print money without some consequence.
When was the last time folks were freaking out about inflation and deflation in the same paragraph?
i think usually in high inflation times, interest rates go up, so price will likely be affected by that
I find this thread interesting - ekartash asks if there will be any effect on prices, and everyone jumps down his throat for wishful thinking about an inflation lead housing runup. He didn't ask about a runup, he asked about an effect. Will high inflation dampen an otherwise severe downturn? That's an effect, no?
The answer is yes, inflation would help housing prices. Perhaps not as much as the credit deflation is hurting it, but that doesn't make it any less of a help.
Why is it so difficult to acknowledge any piece of news that may dampen this blow?
well he did say "woudnt that have an affect on all prices, including real estate?"
so answers just came to that question, thats all.
It's been said repeatedly on these boards that real estate is an excellent hedge against inflation. I like this explanation of why it might not be...
"Good hedges have a few key properties. We mention here only four. One key property of a hedge is that it holds its value. It should lose little value over time. Cars and eggs lose value over time. Land, silver and wine do not.
Another key property is marketability. This means that it is easy to sell. Other people will easily take it for payment. Hence, it is good for barter. Chairs and clothes do not sell. Corn and gold do.
A third key property is divisibility. This means that the asset splits into smaller parts without a loss of value. Houses, cars and cows are not divisible. Rice, wine, gas and gold are.
The last key property is financing. It is vital. Experts prefer to fully ignore it. Investors buy assets with either cash or credit. Cash-based hedges are good. Credit-based hedges are bad. History repeatedly shows that assets bought on credit are prone to speculation and bubbles. The hedge might be already overvalued. In this case, investors should avoid it. Credit clearly drives real estate. Moreover, real estate recently went through a wild bubble. It is grossly expensive, so a poor hedge."
- http://whiskeyandgunpowder.com/is-real-estate-a-good-hedge-against-hyperinflation/
djradon: All you're doing is explaining why the word "hedge" is poorly used in both the question and the answer. Quite obviously, the original poster knows that housing fails the divisibility test. I'd venture that the OP knows that when it comes to marketing, housing is more like chairs and less like corn.
This isn't a dictionary question. The OP is asking if inflation will push prices upwards. Didn't ask about a bull market (that was only mentioned in "answers"), didn't even ask if the push upward would be enough to negate other pushes downward. But still, its a push upwards.
it also now faile the marketability test...
and the "should lose little value over time".
or at least protection against rising rents.
"INFLATION will save Manhattan RE...
Talk about wing and a prayer."
This was a great thread and discussion until I read this. nyc10022, the OP had a great question, why do you feel it is neccessary to bring it back to bull vs. bear? Are you incapable of having an intelligent dialog about facts?
"I think the more important variable than current inflation would be inflationary expectations. Those expectations are correlated with long-term interest rates, which are negatively correlated with property values. "
Great point.
Remember what happened to values when interest rates hit double digits...
http://www.housingwire.com/2008/12/15/fitch-alt-a-mortgages-deteriorating-more-rapidly-than-expected/
"Fitch said it now expects losses on all Alt-A collateral to far exceed the estimates of its ‘moderate stress’ scenario in its late ratings update earlier this year. “Market developments, ongoing home-price declines and loan performance trends in the Alt-A sector over the prior six months have effectively eliminated the possibility of this stress scenario,” said Fitch in a statement. "
This is what I was talking about above, news came out few hours ago. There is a reason why TARP is being used to inject into banks and why reserves are piling up. Banks will need this money to handle further deterioration of held securities
Its probably worth noting that the ratings agencies have been severely behind the curve during the crisis to date.
"Its probably worth noting that the ratings agencies have been severely behind the curve during the crisis to date."
Especially when it comes to rating the US's AAA status.
yes but in this case it doesnt matter. As more securities are downgraded, there will have to be more capital raising for banks. But yes, you are right.
So what is the verdict? Gold is the only viable hedge for inflation? What else would you guys look at?
its a good question. We got a 600Bln-800Bln fiscal package coming out that will have a good portion put to infrastructure.
In addition, many commodities got wrecked and who knows what production cutbacks, etc. there will be as a result. When global downturn cycle starts to ease, stocks may start their slow ascent and maybe things like engineering plays, copper, oi&gas, etc. will bounce back. Perhaps companies like POT, FCX, FLR, CKE, will be good plays?
I still think the short the treasury play is going to be a great trade. But treasuries are in silliness phase now, and you know that means its going to last a while longer! TBT may go to 20s, but when it turns, it will prob be fast.
"Especially when it comes to rating the US's AAA status."
When your debt is denominated in your own currency, you effectively can't default. AAA is very accurate. The bond holders may not be happy that hyperinflation is the reason why we didn't default, but the rating doesn't claim to predict buyer happiness. It predicts the probability the buyer will recover the same nominal amount at maturity.
First, don't confuse the Government printing a ton of money with inflation. That money is currently being hoarded by banks and not entering the money supply. Meanwhile credit is being withdrawn at a faster rate then printing is being done. So net result - deflation. And deflation will be the story until this whole housing mess is done. Don't expect that to happen anytime soon.
Now in general about inflation and house prices...it depends on a few things:
1) What are the mortgage rates. The Fed increased interest rates into the high teens in the early 80s, dampening housing demand. http://whybuildnow.com/_images/interest_rate.png
2) What's going on with the overall economy. China has high inflation, but it's housing market was doing fine until this year due to its economy.
3) What happens to New York. This one is perhaps scariest because it would sadden me...what happens if New York becomes undesirable to live in again? Would you want to live here in the 70s?
"But treasuries are in silliness phase now, and you know that means its going to last a while longer! TBT may go to 20s, but when it turns, it will prob be fast."
Yep- that's how all bubble end... they last way longer than many think, and then when it pops, it shrivels into nothingness way quicker than many think.
How about foreign currencies that don't have a dollar peg and are not in “printing money” mode? Does one exist?
Low mortgage rates will not be around this time next year. You will regret if you don't buy within the next year. It's OK to stay on the sidelines but not forever.
You're full of it if you think you can predict mortgage rates in a year. Especially when all signs point toward the opposite.
"what happens if New York becomes undesirable to live in again? "
My biggest fear!
http://www.gothamgazette.com/article/issueoftheweek/20081004/200/2668
OCT 6th, 2008 - "4. What is your biggest fear regarding the turmoil on Wall Street?
My biggest fear is seeing a change in crime, cleanliness, drugs, homelessness, etc. to this great city. Everything that Rudy Giuliani did to clean this city up, I fear may be undone by this Wall Street centered crisis. The worst-case scenario for Manhattan is if crime increases and quality of life deteriorates as the local economy and individuals hurt from this deep slowdown. If the perception of Manhattan as a "great place to live" is psychologically altered, that combined with the negative macroeconomic forces can put downward pressure on real estate values for many years to come. This will likely not be a V shaped cycle, instead, it is more likely that any correction in real estate prices will resemble an L shape, with prices reverting back to their historic means where incomes and affordability get back in line. "
Fascinating that people still infatuated with inflation,
Not only has the "shadow" banking system and it's $1-$2 trillion in annual swill creation blown up, NOT only does 75% capacity utilization (and falling) tell you there's TOO MUCH Capacity in this economy, NOT only does a finally improving savings rate (thanks to imploding stock markets, housing prices and Mad-off-with-your-money) suggest that we are at the foot of a long-term cyclical downturn in consumer spending and concomitant rise in savings, Not only does real unemployment and continuing claims tell you there's many who will willingly work for less, AND STILL, people are concerned about inflation. Stop regurgitating what you read on another blog vis a vis Weimar stle inflation- You've got to walk across a pretty long valley to reach that mountain..come on folks..The Fed has cut interest rates from 5.25% in little more than 18 months, arranged JPM/BSC, provided collateralized funding for trillions of assets, used it's own BS to take all the garbage that caused this mess, and you still have faith they can achieve what they want. Seems to me like deflationary purge is fairly inevitable. This is NOT Great Depression Part II but it is real pain..Just be thankful you're not China- Imagine if those jobs making GPS sweaters and TLB dresses were still here..Then where would unemployment be?
Fascinating that people still infatuated with inflation,
Not only has the "shadow" banking system and it's $1-$2 trillion in annual swill creation blown up, NOT only does 75% capacity utilization (and falling) tell you there's TOO MUCH Capacity in this economy, NOT only does a finally improving savings rate (thanks to imploding stock markets, housing prices and Mad-off-with-your-money) suggest that we are at the foot of a long-term cyclical downturn in consumer spending and concomitant rise in savings, Not only does real unemployment and continuing claims tell you there's many who will willingly work for less, AND STILL, people are concerned about inflation. Stop regurgitating what you read on another blog vis a vis Weimar stle inflation- You've got to walk across a pretty long valley to reach that mountain..come on folks..The Fed has cut interest rates from 5.25% in little more than 18 months, arranged JPM/BSC, provided collateralized funding for trillions of assets, used it's own BS to take all the garbage that caused this mess, and you still have faith they can achieve what they want. Seems to me like deflationary purge is fairly inevitable. This is NOT Great Depression Part II but it is real pain..Just be thankful you're not China- Imagine if those jobs making GPS sweaters and TLB dresses were still here..Then where would unemployment be?