Affect of Big 3 Bankruptcy on NYC Real Estate Market?
Started by alpine292
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 2771
Member since: Jun 2008
Discussion about
So if the Big 3 go under, what will the impact be right here in NYC? Will we be standing on soup lines? Or will we see no meaningful impact? Thoughts?
I think if they go through a planned bankruptcy it should have little impact on NYC at all. In fact, it might even help the stock market with their stabilization.
Isn't that what Paulson said when he let Lehman go under?
Lehman wasn't a planned Bankruptcy and Lehman is slightly more directly relevant to the NYC economy than the Big 3.
Now, if you are asking what happens if the Big 3 don't do a planned bankruptcy and just fold, then my answer would be different. I don't, however, see that option occurring.
"I think if they go through a planned bankruptcy it should have little impact on NYC at all. In fact, it might even help the stock market with their stabilization."
I think you have it backward. If it hits bankruptcy, things get worse.... and probably quickly. The market will panic.
I think that's the problem the administration came up against, a planned bankruptcy doesn't seem particularly feasible. So, if they can't make it...
"Effect" not "affect"
Nobody is going to buy cars from a bankrupt car company so Chapter 11 will eventually turn into a Chapter 7 liquidation.
Thank you Grammar Police.
I don't think a planned bankruptcy will turn into a Capter 7. I guess one of us will be right. No offense, but I am really hoping you are wrong.
The government will require the Big 3 to achieve a cost structure similar to Toyota's U.S. operations by the end of 2009. If not, bye bye Big 3.
"Nobody is going to buy cars from a bankrupt car company so Chapter 11 will eventually turn into a Chapter 7 liquidation."
1) Nobody is buying cars now, even from Toyota
2) The consumer surveys say the opposite. Bankrupcy doesn't matter much to them. Having the money/loan to afford does...
"I don't think a planned bankruptcy will turn into a Capter 7. I guess one of us will be right. No offense, but I am really hoping you are wrong."
Doesn't have to to be messy.... the market won't like it, period.
I don't think the market likes it now either. Something has to be done to fix it. You cannot let them just die, so what is a better plan than bankruptcy and reorg?
none, move along folks.
"I don't think the market likes it now either. Something has to be done to fix it. You cannot let them just die, so what is a better plan than bankruptcy and reorg?"
Bankruptcy would be better for that industry.
But for our economy, they simply can't do anything with the B word. If they do, panic...
So, the best plan would be to come as close to bankruptcy in reality - break union contracts, lower pay, reorganize - without having to use the B word.
"So, the best plan would be to come as close to bankruptcy in reality - break union contracts, lower pay, reorganize - without having to use the B word."
Agree, and that's close to what is happening. Restructuring with a government plan.
yes, so far thats what it seems like to me, too. Hopefully they'll get the unions to play, but I think the unions know they can't do b-word either, so they might be pushing back.
That's what can happen with a planned bankruptcy and it can shorten the amount of time needed to reorg the company.
There is no pre/pak bnkrtcy, there is no reorg coming. This is just an extraordinarily expensive step in the runoff of the Detroit 3. The Detroit 3 produce roughly 48% of the vehicles in the U.S. This market share has cratered every year for the last 20. It will continue. Over time, the suppliers, which is the real concern, will gradually sell more and more parts to the transplants. One day, someone will say, hey, what would happen to you mister ash tray maker if the Detroit 3 close down? The response will be "nothing much, lose a little business, but nothing I can't adjust to." Best idea I have heard to save the detroit is this. The thin we do good is make parts. The Detroit is a rounding error compared to the 4800 factories of parts makers. Detroit is an assembler, period. So, who is the best assembler in the U.S.? Michael Dell. He doesn't make anything either, he assembles computers. Lets let him assemble the cars, and hey, maybe someone might buy one some day!
80% of consumers say they won't buy from bankrupt auto maker:
http://www.reuters.com/article/domesticNews/idUSN1644326220080716
very little
by the way, steve, ever read death in venice? you're scarily like Gustav...
SPeaking of bankrupt auto makers, I wonder if people would buy condos from bankrupt builders. In Hoboken, a major builder filed for bankruptcy last year and a lot of people did not want to buy from them as a result. Another big builder, WCI, filed for bankruptcy this year.
Has anyone considered the cashflows that will result from the bankruptcy credit event wrt CDS?
"That's what can happen with a planned bankruptcy and it can shorten the amount of time needed to reorg the company."
Except, once again, you are missing the point that it is a BANKRUPTCY. If it hits the b-word, the market will spook. Doesn't matter what the technical follow-through is.