Co-op Boards Get Tough and Tougher
Started by stevejhx
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
Real estate agents say they have also heard of co-op boards that rejected applications because they believed the sale price was too low and would adversely affect the values of other apartments in the building. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/21/realestate/21cov.html?pagewanted=2&ref=realestate They did this in the 80's, as well, and its effect was devastating: artificially increased... [more]
Real estate agents say they have also heard of co-op boards that rejected applications because they believed the sale price was too low and would adversely affect the values of other apartments in the building. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/21/realestate/21cov.html?pagewanted=2&ref=realestate They did this in the 80's, as well, and its effect was devastating: artificially increased inventories, lower prices long-term, insolvencies. "Very well. Sea," cried King Canute, "I command you to come no further! Waves, stop your rolling!. Surf, stop your pounding! Do not dare touch my feet!" He waited a moment, quietly, and a tiny wave rushed up the sand and lapped at his feet. "How dare you!" King Canute shouted. "Ocean, turn back now! I have ordered you to retreat before me, and now you must obey! Go back!" [less]
And then there's the two-year sublet rule that I'm sure they won't budge on. Timmmmmmberrrr!!!
They're going to need Dumbledore for this one.
Wait - some still don't allow gays.
How right you are, Steve. Don't show up at 1001 Fifth with your domestic partner (or as a single man of a "certain age"). We are not welcome.
Stevejhx - I just sat next to a broker who insisted that the market was absolutely going to "turn around" next year -- with a great rebound and how many FANTASTIC BARGAINS are out there. I said -- not even close yet. I shared my thoughts re that the recession will be long and painful and the flow through to real estate will take some time. After about 15 minutes -- she leaned and very much concurred (softly) with my stances... so softly that maybe nobody else would hear us... It was hilarious.
How's that price-fixing "thing" working out for OPEC? ...So ironic that those who purport to tighten standards to uphold value are merely doing the exact opposite. 1-2 yr escrow, higher equity components, mortgage restrictions are all well and good EXCEPT when you're trying to protect bubble era valuations that were in part driven by the absence of these standards from the start. Amazing..I'm certain many of these co-op boards (Esp those in the 5th-Lex UES corridor) and their residents now hold to "standards" that many of their own residents could not qualify for...If you're a "lockdown" resident, someone who's trying to sell an apartment but can't b/c the board won't let you price to market, pipe in...
"the market was absolutely going to "turn around""
Right. 360 degrees.
One of the beautiful things about price fixing is it almost never works in a down market, unless there is at least an oligopoly. The incentives to cheat are too high. Sort of like when we had a dog and a cat and the dog would eat out of the cat's bowl and the cat would eat out of the dog's bowl, regardless of what food we put in which.
At $140 a barrel Chavez was making a fortune. He got drunk, now is stuck with $30, but has a budget at $140. Ergo, he has to produce a lot more and hope that Saudi Arabia cuts back.
Same thing with co-op boards. Now, though, their business judgment rules has been cut back by the courts, and if I were on the board I'd approve any deal that could be made, lest the shareholder in question sue me personally for causing my loss for no reason.
That's the next thing to happen, since prices are falling and going to fall like never before.