StuyTown - 20% Vacancy Rate
Started by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
http://stuytownluxliving.com/2008/12/stuyvesant-towns-20-vacancy-rate.html A friend in the complex who said the same thing.... given their rents and the downside of the complex, I am not at all surprised (if its true).
I doubt it's true except perhaps with respect to market-rate apartments. The vast majority are still rent-regulated. But the fact is that they NEED to raise rents and keep them high so as not to be bled dry, and they won't be able to.
It's the same thing I said about Archstone, owned by Lehman: they now have both the highest asking rents and the highest vacancy rates among luxury rentals. Because they NEED to get that price to prevent from going under.
> The vast majority are still rent-regulated.
Its been over 10 years of hardcore enting RS leases... if you think its the "vast majority", you aren't keeping tabs.
They've installed cameras and electronic locks to stop illegal sublets, and have had an investigation team for years. Last blast apparently had hundreds of "we think you are violating, we don't plan to renew youu lease" letters going out.
They've been so aggressive that Garodnick got involved...
They've been aggressive, but if I recall the figure was still 80% at purchase.
By purchase, I assume you mean the year or so ago?
They redoubled efforts after that...
I called stuyvesant town thinking their one bedrooms would be somewhat reasonable. $3100 with a free month..when I told them I could get a one bedroom for $2600 they said they have been complaining about the high rents but management does not want to lower the rent. They keep lists of apartments in the area and the prices for one bedrooms w/o doorman but they still won't lower rents.
Yes I mean a year or so ago.
No doubt that the figure is lower now, but still not enough to cover the cash-flow needs to service the debt.
They've recently really upped the harrassment of RS tenants. They have teams of lawyers combing property records trying to prove that RS tenants do not meet primary resident status. Still, most of the RS tenants I know won't give in graciously, they'll fight until the end, I'm pretty sure it's still at least 60% RS, which is one of the reasons TS is bleeding money on the complex.
I doubt it's 20% vacancy, but a couple of months ago I heard that the number of vacant apartments could fill five buildings. Their retention of market-rate tenants has been abysmal (myself excluded, sadly). The place is becoming kind of silly (all the "extras" one can pay for to achieve "luxury" living), and the location has it's definite issues, particularly if you aren't at the southern end, but there are quite a few upsides to the complex as well. I can see the negatives outweighing the positives fairly soon, however.
> I heard that the number of vacant apartments could fill five buildings
Thats the stat he got.... I thought it was 35 buildings total though... which gets us close to 20%.
I think the total vacancies included both Stuy Town and Peter Cooper, which I think total more than fifty buildings (dammit, where did that handy mousepad of the complex that management gifted us with when we signed our lease go off to?). Either or any way you look at it, they're going down. Their current reserves will supposedly only last until September. Even if they boot out hundreds more RS tenants it won't do anything for them, because their rental and income projections not only included new market-rate tenants, but also presumed that market-rate rents would continue to climb, climb, climb.
It still takes years to evict a tenant. Lots of proving to do.
And at a certain point the maximum regulated rents are higher than market rents. Until recently that was the norm in the outer boroughs. Don't be surprised to see 1-bedrooms going back to the $1,700 level, at which point, why bother kicking them out?
Unless they use their other properties to subsidize, those complexes are going under.
Stuy Town is 10% of a 2007 CMBS deal called Cobalt. It has been slow to covert to market rates vs. projection and using reserves.
The Peter Cooper Village and Stuyvesant Town Loan ($250.0 million -- 10.4%), represents a pari passu interest in a $3.0 billion first mortgage. The loan is secured by two adjacent multifamily apartment complexes totaling 11,227 units located on the east side of Manhattan. The borrower is pursuing a comprehensive renovation of the property and conversion of rent regulated units to market rents. However, progress has been slower than expected. As of June 2008, approximately 35.8% of the apartments were at market rate, compared to 28.5% at securitization. In addition to the delay in converting apartments, operating expenses have been higher than projected, largely due to utility expenses and repairs and maintenance expenses associated with upgrading apartments upon tenant lease expirations. At securitization, a $400.0 million interest reserve and a $190.0 million general reserve were established to cover interest shortfalls. As of September 2008, approximately $200.0 million of these reserves remain. At the present pace of the conversion program, it is expected that the reserves will be depleted by the end of the third quarter of 2009. The loan is on the servicer's watchlist due to low debt service coverage. The loan sponsors are Tishman Speyer and BlackRock Realty Advisors. In addition to the first mortgage loan, there is a $1.4 billion mezzanine loan secured by a pledge of equity interests in the borrower. Moody's current valuation of this loan reflects a slower rate of conversion of units to market rates, higher expenses and a lower rental growth, resulting in a decrease in value. Moody's underlying rating is Ba3 compared to Baa3 at securitization.
This is going to collapse.
doomed from the start...what an ugly complex
ante 148 is correct. Ante got a little caught up in the nitty gritty, which might be hard to follow for some folks, but ante is correct.
The short and sweet is, Tishman/Blackrock bought StyTown/Peter Cooper in 2007 at the top of the bubble, I forget the price but it was the single biggest commercial real estate deal ever. I think the total value of the transaction was somewhere near $5 billion, that was the biggest amount ever paid for a single property, at least in the US.
Tish got a humongous loan, I think it came from a consortium of banks but the lead banker on the deal was Wachovia I believe. It was a cmbs loan, which means commercial mortgage backs. The loan got turned into bonds and thus was sold off in dribs and drabs to hundreds, if not thousands, of bond buyers.
Now Tish justified getting this ridiculously huge loan by saying, we can create new value at StyTown, the way we'll do it is we'll push out the rent regulated people who don't really belong there and then raise the rents on those units to market levels.
The Tish business plan for the process was very aggressive, the Times has written about it. I forget the numbers, but Tish said it could convert a quarter or third, some big chunk of the units, to market level rents.
This led to Tish's management guys getting really mean with the StyTown residents. People who had lived there for 20 years were being denied lease renewals on flimsy grounds. The Times wrote this up a couple times, you can google it. Many tenants sued, I believe the lawsuits still drag on.
Anyhoo, if this little blog post is correct, and the vacancy rate over at the complex has actually climbed to 20%, well the loan is screwed and the investors who own the commercial mortgage backs that are connected to the loan are gonna be in trouble.
Stuy town and peter cooper look like housing projects. It's absolutely sickening that people pay that much in rent to live in that shithole. In any other city, such living conditions would be considered barbaric. But in NYC, it's a normal part of life.
Stuy/ Peter Cooper sold for $5.4 Billion, the most expensive RE transaction in U.S. history
hmm...yes it was the most expensive transaction in history but it's now about 35 percent market. About 3 to 5 percent will convert to market each year (it's taken 10 yrs to turn over about 35 percent pf the units so 3.5 is average and now they are being even more aggressive with evictions and investigations). Assuming rent stab laws remain the same (decontrol at 2000 rent and 175k income for 2 years), the complex will be about 70 percent market rents in 10 years. (Dem Senate may change that though) Tishmans are known to be long term investors..so they can wait this out...they need to take a hit on the loan payments coming up..but if they do, this place will turn about and be extremely profitable in the long term. The other alternative is to convert Peter Cooper to coops in about 3 years when the real estate has improved...That would raise tremendous amounts of cash to pay down debt service...SO bottom line..they bought at the height and it's a slow process to make money here...but they have options to get them out the immediate crisis and if they have a long term perspective...Tishman will do great.
stguy... the asset will do great as RS/RC goes away... but it won't be the Tishman as owners.... they'll have to re-cap this thing in BK.
w67th, agree. in the long term. in the short term there already are too many "market-rate" rentals in the city. even if they can remove apartments from stabalization, there's no one to take them at over $3000 for a one bedroom, and close to $5000 (PC starts at $4800) for a two bedroom.
stguy, they've pretty much weeded out all they can with the evictions and investigations. now they need to wait for death, or for a few who are closer to the limit to decide to move as the market is softening. many, although certainly not all, of the RS tenants wouldn't exceed the income limits at this point, so they would stay. i had read, i can't recall where, that albany was considering a change to the RS laws, increasing the rent ceiling .
i don't think coop conversion would be feasible until they are over 50% market rent. too many of the RS tenants are in their 70s and older and most would have zero interest in purchasing.
> It still takes years to evict a tenant. Lots of proving to do.
Yes, and as I noted, the process started 10-15 years back. They've been hard at work on the proving for some time, including the electronic locks and investigations.
As for Stuytown overall, they clearly would rather have vacant apartments than lower the "market" rate and watch thousands upon thousands ask for lower rent.
I agree that the elderly tenants on fixed incomes would not exceed the 175k income needed to deregulate but stuy town is also full of civil servant couples..(usually on the higher end of the pay scales for civil servants) so income levels would be exceeded. Market rents at stuy town need to soften about 10 to 15 percent to be competitive. Who knows? Many of my friends here are living in two bedrooms paying 1800 or 1900 rent so there's only about two years left til they have to move so they are gettin ansy. As far as Albany goes, there was a bill drafted to increase the rent deregulation amount from 2000 to 2800 but it went no where with Republican senate and then Spitzer's fall. It may come back and insiders think the compromise will be an increase to 2500 with annual COLA increases. If that happens, Stuy Town HAS To convert because it will take 30 years plus to become market rent.
don't forget the illegal sublets...
"About 3 to 5 percent will convert to market each year"
Market may be less than maximum stabilized shortly.