Is it possible?
Started by hotproperty
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 277
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
Now that we have declined some. Is it possible that prices will now hold steady thoughout 2009 & 2010 thanks to record low interest rates and the fact that Manhattan is still very desirable?
We'll have to wait until the post holiday rush to see if there are buyers and if things are moving quicker. Only time will tell. Manhattan real estate is very complicated.
"Now that we have declined some. Is it possible that prices will now hold steady thoughout 2009 & 2010 thanks to record low interest rates and the fact that Manhattan is still very desirable?"
No chance whatsoever. Its not very complicated at all.
Manhattan is no more desirable than when the crash started, so not sure how that would improve things.
Also, the record low interest rates can't be accessed by most buyers. And there are no interest onlys and bullshit stuff to get. And you can't get those rates in JUMBOs anyway.
All the negative factors are still here, and, in fact, they are worse.
Wall Street, which was 1/3 of city income and 1/3 of apartment buyers, is absolutely toast, and not getting any better
National economy news still getting worse
Foreigners aren't buying anymore
And then we have the new bad news...
NYC and NYS cuts will affect city services
Property tax increases
Income tax increases
The Manhattan crash has only just started.
And also factor in the inflation that will occur at some point which will raise rental prices down the rd. while your mortgage payment won't increase.
and, actually, the biggest point of them all...
Now that we have a 20% decline, all of the "Manhattan never goes down" and "solid investement" logic that was used to create the bubble in the first place is now gone.
This data, when it goes wide, is going to completely freak out a lot of this market.
Its going to get worse... much worse.
"And also factor in the inflation that will occur at some point which will raise rental prices down the rd. while your mortgage payment won't increase."
Yes, because 3% inflation is going to make up for your 20% capital loss levered 5x
Guess what, the fear is DEFLATION, not inflation.
Which actually just means owners are extra screwed.
Wow, an awful lot of denial on this thread.
"And also factor in the inflation that will occur at some point which will raise rental prices down the rd. while your mortgage payment won't increase."
Very, very doubtful that rents are going up.
From a Real Deal article linked in Curbed today:
"In 2009, the vacancy rate in market-rate rental apartments will rise to its highest level in at least 28 years, as mounting job losses drive renters from the city, a new report from commercial real estate services firm Marcus & Millichap predicts. The vacancy rate will reach 4.7 percent, topping the previous record of 4 percent in the fourth quarter of 2003, the firm determined in its 2009 National Apartment Report." That's more than double the vacancy rate in 2007.
http://ny.therealdeal.com/articles/record-apartment-vacancy-rate-predicted-for-next-year
nyc10022 is totally correct, hotproperty.
In addition to his(?) fundamental reasons, I would also note the very strong tendency for residential prices to "trend."
There is no reason to rush to buy real estate. Take a look at monthly, quarterly, and annual S&P Case Shiller price data since inception. Real estate prices do not turn on a dime. Unlike stock market returns (uncorrelated monthly returns) residential real estate prices "trend" (very positive serial correlation of returns in statistical terms). Wait until real estate prices, in general, have at least bottomed out for a period of time. (You won't miss the boat!)
Thanks, T.
99% of the city denies that RE will ever go down. Then, the numbers finally come in saying we have declines, and the 99% seems to be sure we're bottom, about 30 seconds into the crash.
Denial is a VERY powerful thing, it seems.
"And also factor in the inflation that will occur at some point which will raise rental prices down the rd. while your mortgage payment won't increase."
HAHAHA Inflation. Talk to me in a few years and we'll see if we are even close to getting inflation again.
Meanwhile you will pay more (a lot more) in carrying costs for purchasing than renting AND your home will have lost a lot of equity which means you will suffer gigantic losses (10% down payment, 30% drop in equity = 300% loss). All for your holdout that at "someday" rental prices will increase.
1.After the deflation there will be massive inflation.
2.The Marcus & Millichap study said rents will go up.
3 4.7 percent vacancy is only up .7% from the record in fourth quarter of 2003
4.Property taxes are still low compared to surrounding areas.
5.Low interest rates can be combined with a big down payment.
6.There is still a strong desire to own and where else can you put your money these days?
"Now that we have declined some. Is it possible that prices will now hold steady thoughout 2009 & 2010 thanks to record low interest rates and the fact that Manhattan is still very desirable?"
As nyc10022 said, we are 4 months into the real estate crash in Manhattan which is a 2 year late start to the rest of the country. The rest of the country is still accelerating to the downside. There are cities with a lot better job markets now, DC, Boston, Chicago, that are still falling in prices. What makes you think Manhattan, which is taking it in the ass with the credit crisis, is going to fair any better than these cities? We have a *long* time to go until prices approach reality again. No amount of wishing is going to change that.
> 1.After the deflation there will be massive inflation.
Given that housing is half the CPI, thats a load of crap your broker made up...
> 2.The Marcus & Millichap study said rents will go up.
3-5%? Yeah, thats a load of crap.
> 3 4.7 percent vacancy is only up .7% from the record in fourth quarter of 2003
Yes, 15% higher vacancy rate than the RECORD. Sounds like a hot market to me.
Are you actually trying to note this as a positive?
> 4.Property taxes are still low compared to surrounding areas.
Low property taxes were already factored into prices. They don't have to get "high" to hurt prices, they just have to get "higher". And we have that.... plain and simple. And you left out income tax.
> 5.Low interest rates can be combined with a big down payment.
Who has a big down payment?
> 6.There is still a strong desire to own and where else can you put your money these days?
Given that sales have declined SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT, sounds like a huge pile of crap to me. And thats with a tanking stock market. Given that the stock market bounces almost always preceed economic recover (by 6 months or more) and RE (took FOUR YEARS after 87), when that happens, you'll see even more fleeing from RE.
I also notice how you conveniently "missed" all the other factors..
> Manhattan is no more desirable than when the crash started, so not sure how that would improve
> things.
If anything, its worse given the fear factor, fewer cops, death of Wall Street. It is certainly not MORE desirable.
> Also, the record low interest rates can't be accessed by most buyers.
Whoops.
> Wall Street, which was 1/3 of city income and 1/3 of apartment buyers, is absolutely toast,
> and not getting any better
Sort of a big one you ignored, huh?
> National economy news still getting worse
That, too.
> Foreigners aren't buying anymore
They were 30% of new condo sales at one time. And they're gone.
Conveniently missed that, too, huh?
> NYC and NYS cuts will affect city services
Sort of a biggie.
The ironic thing is, ALL of the "logic" you're trying to use was used to say why Manhattan would not decline. And now we're down 20%.
Doesn't say much for accuracy, does it?
> 1.After the deflation there will be massive inflation.
Btw, lets pretend for a second this is true.
Guess what happens... mortgage rates go up. Good for locked in rates, but that absolutely screws an already horrible RE market.
Of course, it was made up in the first place... but just pointing out the bag logic.
Said it before, I'll say it again...
"99% of the city denies that RE will ever go down. Then, the numbers finally come in saying we have declines, and the 99% seems to be sure we're bottom, about 30 seconds into the crash."
"1.After the deflation there will be massive inflation."
Talk to Japan. They're still waiting on "massive" inflation after 18 years. This despite massive Government intervention fiscally and monetarily. With the rate that credit is being retracted and capital is being destroyd, those betting on hyperinflation are going to be waiting a long time.
"2.The Marcus & Millichap study said rents will go up. "
My 8-year old niece can do simple queries that show rents have gone down. Have you seen the November report from TREGNY? Rents are down year over year and heading lower. http://www.tregny.com/manhattan-apt-rental-report.jsp
"4.Property taxes are still low compared to surrounding areas."
Not for long, seen the news lately? Not that this matters. Manhattan real estate isn't priced according to relative property taxes.
"5.Low interest rates can be combined with a big down payment."
Where are people getting big downpayments from? That's part of the problem - homes are too expensive requiring way to much savings to get a 20% downpayment. People also don't buy when the market is heading lower.
"6.There is still a strong desire to own and where else can you put your money these days? "
CDs, investment grade bonds. Heard of them?
jgr, we're probably preaching to folks with their eyes and ears covered.... not sure any logic is going to change the mind of folks who want to believe what they want to believe.
Denial is VERY powerful thing.... it got us into this mess, and its going to keep us here for a while.
Man you type fast nyc10022.
This is not Japan.
Rents are still too expensive.
You can get a deal if you're a buyer now.
Lot's of people still have money for a down payment.
CD's are paying nothing.
If the dollar collapses at least you'll have a place to live.
Wow, more denial city..
> This is not Japan.
Yes, economic rules don't apply here.
> Rents are still too expensive.
And getting cheaper... Given that prices factored in high rents, and rents are getting lower, that is BAD for prices.
> You can get a deal if you're a buyer now.
A bargain about to become a bigger bargain is no bargain at all.
> Lot's of people still have money for a down payment.
Sure, if you say so...
> CD's are paying nothing.
Better than things that pay -20%
Man, this is getting too easy.
Seriously, hotproperty, where does all this blind denial come from. Are you a broker.
If the dollar collapses at least you'll have a place to live.
> Man you type fast nyc10022.
Fingers back in holster.
;-)
Yes, I actually did the typing training way back... in this online world, it pays off pretty well.
Sorry missed this one...
> If the dollar collapses at least you'll have a place to live.
If the dollar collapses, you'll have plenty of cheap apartments to choose from in NYC. Hell, if the dollar collapses, how much rule of law you think there is going to be protecting your apartment?
And, co-ops and condos starting approaching $0.
Seriously, hotproperty, where does all this blind denial come from? Are you a broker?
You pretended to be asking... but it is VERY clear now that you just wanted to make your denial play. You have tried to disprove every answer you've gotten.
Do you have a bridge to sell us?
"This is not Japan. "
Agreed. But how else are you going to make educated judgements on the future if you don't examine the past? It's the closest modern example to what is going on now. The next best thing is the Great Depression. I think that example is worse...
And in many cases, what happened here is worse than Japan - no savings rate and we are a consumer economy for example. In some cases its better - everyone is going into deflation together, Japan had a larger bubble.
"Rents are still too expensive. "
Agreed! And they are heading lower. Much lower.
"You can get a deal if you're a buyer now. "
And you can get a much much better deal in a year. Obviously people don't find these to be very good deals if sales are down 75%. Why is that so hard to understand?
"Lot's of people still have money for a down payment. "
Either they don't or they don't feel like buying due to the direction of the market.
"CD's are paying nothing. "
Just bought a 10 year at 5.25% FDIC insured. I'll take it over hundreds of thousands in losses in real estate any day.
"If the dollar collapses at least you'll have a place to live."
If the dollar collapses you will lose your job and will be unable to pay the mortgage. Have fun with that.
nyc10022 what happens if your crystal ball is broken and you turn out to be wrong? I'm not trying to disprove anything. Merely pointing out that you NEVER KNOW what will happen.
Hope you don't mind my answer...
"what happens if your crystal ball is broken and you turn out to be wrong?"
There's no "crystal ball" that is telling me prices are going lower. That judgement is made based on my own knowledge of how markets and bubbles work and all the evidence layed out by people much smarter than I.
"Merely pointing out that you NEVER KNOW what will happen."
Oh course not. I was an Electrical Engineering major and we never deal in absolutes, always probabilities. But when something has a small probability of happening (e.g., hyperinflation & the complete reversal of the Manhattan market) I don't risk hundreds of thousands on that probability.
Exactly.
This isn't us waving magic wands and making magical predictions. This is looking at the facts and logic and trends, something that you seem to have trouble doing.
That you think we're pulling this out of thin air just shows how much you need to learn...
Not to mention, don't be a hypocrite. You're doing more predictions than anyone... and you don't actually back it up with any facts.
jgr put it well..
"There's no "crystal ball" that is telling me prices are going lower. That judgement is made based on my own knowledge of how markets and bubbles work and all the evidence layed out by people much smarter than I. "
hyperinflation & the complete reversal of the Manhattan market
It will happen-just a question of when.
anyone who thinks this is out of a crystal ball needs to do a LOT more homework before they buy an apartment...
> hyperinflation & the complete reversal of the Manhattan market
> It will happen-just a question of when.
And you're saying *we* have crystal balls. You didn't even try and support it with a fact.
hotproperty, your denial is hillarious.
well, at least we know for sure that this is a troll thread, and not an honest question.
Well, hotproperty, if you're really certain that hyperinflation is on the way, the good news is that you can then expect double-digit money market rates. And commodities will be the place to invest.
Why invest is something that is way overvalued and headed south?
(BTW, seems pretty clear that we're headed for low inflation - at least short term. Take a look at the "breakeven" inflation rate on TIPS - close to 0% for 10 year TIPS. That said, I think there is a chance of rising inflation in a couple of years. Not clear that NYC real estate, though, is the place to ride it out!)
There is no bubble...
then... Wall Street will save us...
then... Foreigners will save us...
then... Doctors will save us...
then... INFLATION will save us...
thats my favorite... LOL
we're sorta running out of saviors, huh?
don't forget the physicians .. .. then the Martians!
The Feds r outta ammunition... I believe we r in a liquidity trap... whatever that means :)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquidity_trap
yup
Hotproperty: Don't listen to anyone here. Go out and buy that apartment of your dreams TODAY. If you wait, someone else WILL snatch it up. Also, because someone else may take it, I recommend that you offer above the asking price. I know that this may require you to stretch and deplete your savings, but you HAVE TO DO IT. Borrow from family if you must to to get the downpayment. If that's not enough, max out your credit cards. Hell, I think it's worth it to sell your blood if that's what it'll take to get you into the home of your dreams today. I know that this is an unconventional stretegy, but any minute that goes by is a minute wasted. Everyone else on this board isn't as smart as you are and they are giving you BAD advice because they're jealous of your success.
HotProperty, in one year, when you're sitting in your beautiful home that has already doubled (if not tripled) in value, you'll be having a good laugh at all the naysayers on this board who can no longer pay their rent because it has gone up so much.
So you're going to rent for the next 30 years?
Interestingly, I actually think some of your arguments might be convincing... 30%+ below where we are now. I can't speak for anyone else here, but no, I don't plan to rent for the next 30 years. But I have no problem doing it for 1-3 years. No crystal ball, but I consider the chances of prices falling in that time much, much greater than the chances of prices rising. So my upside to waiting is much greater than my downside.
Actually, inflation raises interest rates as well as rents, which is more deleterious to values. I wish more bulls on this board were actually aware of the decade called the 1990s. We saw inflation, rents went through the roof (relatively), the fed raised interest rates...and guess what, apartments sold for 6-10x annual gross rent.
"So you're going to rent for the next 30 years?"
Did anyone say that? Let's wait and see what the economy and the rent vs buy math looks when we hit the trough. This will take a few years to play out - No region in the country has reached a bottom and they started 2 years ago. With real estate you have the luxury of time because there aren't V-shaped recoveries.
Even just renting for 2 years, and sitting out 2008 and 2009, looks like it would have saved anyone a very pretty penny (assuming they delayed purchasing).