90 Riverside Drive #15F
Started by bfgross
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 247
Member since: Jun 2007
Discussion about
I am still amazed at this price. One of the premier buildings on Riverside. Very high floor (albeit with NE views) estate condition classic six just trades for 850 psf. If that doesnt give us a strong guide as to where this market is going, I dont know what does.
Motivated seller and shrewd buyer:
StreetEasy History
09/04/2008 Listed in StreetEasy by Elliman at $2,195,000
09/17/2008 Price decreased to $1,995,000
10/02/2008 Price decreased to $1,895,000
10/30/2008 Price decreased to $1,795,000
11/06/2008 Elliman listing entered contract
12/18/2008 Sale closed for $1,530,000
Basically within a week of lowering the price by $100K to $1.795, a party put in a bid more than $250K lower than the asking price and a deal was struck. To me the price history and bidding is more interesting than the price per square foot.
gleeclub: agree on all points, except for your last one. Its not all that important why something goes for what it goes for. Comps are comps. SInce buyers are mostly sitting on their hands right now, motivated sellers in this market are making the market.
Future values get priced off of past comps. And this one is a doozy.
All I said was that to me, the price negotiations were more interesting.
From the looks of the quick closing, the buyers probably didn't finance the deal which may have been why they accepted the lower offer.. all cash, no worries about passing the board. This was worth sacrificing on price. Furthermore, the sellers do not have a mortgage and acquired the apartment for a fraction of the selling cost. There is no doubt, if you have a lot of cash and can forgoe financing, there are a lot of deals to be had in this market.
because the price was probably far more than what the seller paid..don't look at today's price, look at what it was in '03.
huh? so current market doesnt matter, just whatever the sellers cost is? sorry i dont follow
w. u bfgross... what the hell does what I paid for have anything to do with RE... it's like saying I paid $100K for this car so I want $110K... or better yet... bought at $100K.. took out an CEHLOC for $50K (car equity line of credit ) and now need to sell for $150K,.... oh don't forget closing costs (6%).... LMAS....I'm always LMAS.... where's the yellow ones?
cars break down and eventually are useless but property can be forever so not a good comparison
i think west 81st discussed that estate sales will drive prices down example 277 west end
bfgross - I agree with you. Very interesting data point, hoping to see more like it (and even lower).
it's an interesting data point, but what i find so funny is that people find it "shocking." the real estate market is in collapse--the savvy folks here are the sellers, not the buyers. this is not a 'deal' relative to the current market, but relative to the market of a year ago--a market that no longer exists. there are apartments down 50% from peak asking prices that still aren't selling. 75% decline in volume is not a slow-down, it is a collapse. congratulations to the sellers on this one.
bfgross: I agree that you have probably flagged a milestone transaction, for several reasons. The key point is that this listing typifies the bedrock of the Upper West Side market: a good-sized classic six, adaptable to 3BR, in an excellent building but with no special features like views, offered in estate condition (though the sellers happen to be alive; they've simply moved on). In normal times, that's a highly marketable commodity, with no shortage of ready buyers. There's no way to explain away a 20-30% decline on a property that represents such a wide swath of the market.
It's also notable that one of the top brokers in the neighborhood presided over this fire sale. If Ann Lenane says the days of the viewless $2MM UWS fixer-upper six are over, I'm not about to argue with her - especially since Kory at Corcoran and Lippman/Moore at BHS seem to have drawn the same conclusion.
Before declaring that all viewless RSD apartments have been repriced, I'm inclined to await confirmation from other sales at 90 RSD and comparable buildings like 50, 110/118, 173/175 and 180. Still, it's hard to see why a buyer who passed on this listing as it slipped under $1.6MM would pay more for a similar apartment elsewhere.
bfgross: I agree that you have probably flagged a milestone transaction, for several reasons. The key point is that this listing typifies the bedrock of the Upper West Side market: a good-sized classic six, adaptable to 3BR, in an excellent building but with no special features like views, offered in estate condition (though the sellers happen to be alive; they've simply moved on). In normal times, that's a highly marketable commodity, with no shortage of ready buyers. There's no way to explain away a 20-30% decline on a property that represents such a wide swath of the market.
It's also notable that one of the top brokers in the neighborhood presided over this fire sale. If Ann Lenane says the days of the viewless $2MM UWS fixer-upper six are over, I'm not about to argue with her - especially since Kory at Corcoran and Lippman/Moore at BHS seem to have drawn the same conclusion.
Before declaring that all viewless RSD apartments have been repriced, I'm inclined to await confirmation from other sales at 90 RSD and comparable buildings like 50, 110/118, 173/175 and 180. Still, it's hard to see why a buyer who passed on this listing as it slipped under $1.6MM would pay more for a similar apartment elsewhere.
bfgross: I agree that you have probably flagged a milestone transaction, for several reasons. The key point is that this listing typifies the bedrock of the Upper West Side market: a good-sized classic six, adaptable to 3BR, in an excellent building but with no special features like views, offered in estate condition (though the sellers happen to be alive; they've simply moved on). In normal times, that's a highly marketable commodity, with no shortage of ready buyers. There's no way to explain away a 20-30% decline on a property that represents such a wide swath of the market.
It's also notable that one of the top brokers in the neighborhood presided over this fire sale. If Ann Lenane says the days of the viewless $2MM UWS fixer-upper six are over, I'm not about to argue with her - especially since Kory at Corcoran and Lippman/Moore at BHS seem to have drawn the same conclusion.
Before declaring that all viewless RSD apartments have been repriced, I'm inclined to await confirmation from other sales at 90 RSD and comparable buildings like 50, 110/118, 173/175 and 180. Still, it's hard to see why a buyer who passed on this listing as it slipped under $1.6MM would pay more for a similar apartment elsewhere.
Yikes - sorry about the triple post. Serves me right for posting via wireless from the sticks.
haven't personally seen the apt you are talking about bfgross. However, my colleague has a contract for the following unit in 90 Riverside. She actually had a bidding war on the unit and got above asking (close to $1500 psf). sorry to burst your bubble!
http://www.prudentialelliman.com/Listings.aspx?ListingID=1054733&rentalperiod=&SearchType=Broker_Contract&Region=NYC&BID=JENK
Rachel:
I guess we will see about the other unit at 90 Riverside.
But lets not compare a considerable larger and very nicely renovated south -facing unit to 15F just yet.
And if its already in contract, then unfortunately the buyers didnt have the datapoint from 15F to work with, now did they?
bfg - my point is only that for every doom and gloom example you give, I can probably find a happy one. The market is generally down and things are moving slower. Can't we leave it at that rather than trying to scare everyone and spread doom and gloom??
I doubt 15F would have influenced 16G much one way or the other. The only thing those two apartments have in common, as far as I can see, is an address.
The "G" line is great. Still, judging from the lower-floor priors and the excellent condition of #16G, that sale appears to have been struck at a 2004-2005 price. So I'm not sure this deal bursts any bubbles, except for maybe the one that pushed apartments like #16G up to $4MM.
By the way, who picked out those sofas?
Agent Rachel,
"the market is generally down" is not being honest, at all.
The market is substantially down, according to any objective standard, nonwithstanding any comments or examples I've ever noted.
If Miller Samuel is reporting prices are down 20%, does it make sense that there is one "happy example" for every "unhappy one?."
The answer is obviously not. Is the stock market "generally down" or "substantially down?". You can spin it however you want.
Things are moving slower is also not so honest, given that sales volume is off 75%. Not really fair adjectives to use.
How exactly have I been a "doom and gloom" spreader? I said there was an apartment at the Majestic the other day I thought would trade at at least $10 million, and was arguing with someone else on this board who thought much lower.
While I do believe the market is going lower, so far Im just reporting the facts ma'am.
i visited the apartment at 90 riverside. it is absolutely superb. it would easily have gone for $2000 a square foot 6 months ago. $1400 a square foot means market is down over 30%.
I would have said $1700-1800. $2000 would have surprised me even at the height of the run-up.
Agent Rachel,
I really don't understand what you're talking about with "spreading doom and gloom." how is it "spreading doom and gloom" to simply report actual sales of actual apartments? should i accuse you of spreading false optimism and trying to trick people into overpaying for apartments when you post a more favorable sale? data is data and i can't see any reason we shouldn't share it and analyze it.
i also agree with west81st that while the G-line sale at 90 RSD is great for the sellers, it certainly would not have been considered a strong price over the summer or last winter. it also represents some softening. i don't think it was a good buy at that price in today's market, so i can see why you report it to try to create a bull scenario, but its not exactly bullish.
the truth is that the real estate market is in collapse, and we're all just waiting to see how bad it gets. so far, it's down on average 20-25%, but with volume down 75%....you do the math.