Skip Navigation

Sale at 419 West 55th Street

Started by anonymous
almost 20 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about 419 West 55th Street #5A
(Discussing Sale at 419 West 55th Street) http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/55982-condop-419-west-55th-street-clinton-new-york Can somebody help me understand how to valuate this? I measured it, I don't think it has 616 sqf, more like 550. I am guessing they mean 616 shares. The maintenance is quite high obviously it is on land lease, only 21% tax deductable. Compare to the neighbourhood it seems expensive but then it is a condop not a coop. Bath and kitchen are nice, lot of light through the window and some sort of view.
Response by anonymous
almost 20 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

When they measure square footage, they are going from inside the walls halfway to the next apartment to the same in all directions. Plus it also includes closets and any irregularities that you might have missed, area taken up by kitchen counters, bathtub, etc. With the figures you give, you are only off by an area of about 7' X 8'. This could be the items I mentioned, which the average person wouldn't normally include in their measurements. Many realtor web sites disclaim any guarantee of accurate square footage measurement.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by jk1002
almost 20 years ago
Posts: 8
Member since: Dec 2006

>off by an area of about 7’ X 8<

7*8 = 56. 8*8=64. 616-550=66. Realtor math I guess. I think it is very common to include common areas in the SQF so I am not overly concerned about that. Question remains how do you valuate that unit? For 550 that you can effectivly use it seems a lot considering the underlying landlease and the high monthly.
I looked at the sales records similiar sized unit configured as a 1 bed sold for 512500$ 6 month back - 2 floors lower though.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
almost 20 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

The big issue with this building is the land lease. The building itself is nice and the location is great (IMO) - close to Columbus Circle and transportation, good restaurants and shopping on 9th and 10th and close to the west Side Highway. I have looked at 3-4 of the larger units in the building and they were nice. As one would expect the smaller units sell for a higher $/SFT than the larger units, which seem to sell in the range of $700 - $800/sft.The poster above is right that the identical unit 2 floor lower sold for $831/sft last spring when I would say that the market was a little stronger than right now. I would say that $512.5K would be a very fair price for this unit, as being on the 5th floor on this street is key as you can see over the buildings across the street and have a nice southern (bright) skyline view. You could argue that the unit is worth maybe $50K more because it is higher, but then again it is February and the market is anything but frothy. If you are really interested, I would offer $500-510 and see if you can get the deal done close to the price paid for 3A. Remember, due to the land lease issue, you have to beat up this seller on the way in, because the next buyer is gonna beat you up on the way out.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment