Skip Navigation

Sale at 675 Sackett Street #307

Started by GraffitiGrammarian
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008
Discussion about 675 Sackett Street #307
This seems deceptive to me on many levels. First of all, it's a Fourth Avenue development. The building address may be Sackett Street, but the western facade of the building is on Fourth Avenue. And Fourth Ave., as has been discussed here on many threads, is a pretty controversial site. It's an 8-lane truck route, among other things. Second, I can't see how they get to a thousand square feet. If... [more]
Response by Slope11217
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 233
Member since: Nov 2008

"Finally, the price is out of whack with other comp 2-beds."

Chances are, it'll drop even further before it sells, but I don't think it's wildly out of whack with the current state of pricing for 2 bedroom apartments in Park Slope. Roughly $700psf is about the current going rate (check out 2 bedrooms at the Crest and Novo--just a few blocks down on 4th avenue).

4th avenue may not be prime Park Slope, but it's really not as bad as many people make it out to be. And Sackett Street is a great, great North Slope block.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Slope11217
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 233
Member since: Nov 2008

For example, check out this apartment at the Crest:

http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/89722-condo-302-2nd-street-park-slope-brooklyn

2 bedroom, 2 bath, new construction, on 4th avenue just a few blocks south of the Sackett Street apartment you listed. For just under 1,000sf (based on the developer's math), it went for $680k. Now, it may have been in contract for a long time before it closed, but I think it shows that $700psf isn't (currently) a crazy price to ask for this area.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by zinka
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 102
Member since: Nov 2007

This is NOT new construction. It's at least a few years old.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by GraffitiGrammarian
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008

Nah, I don't think so.

Here's a 2-bedroom in a far better location in brownstone Brooklyn for $100k less. I looked in the sale listing for about 3 seconds before I found one that was 100k less.

http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/367431-condo-498-henry-street-carroll-gardens-brooklyn

This one happens to still be Sackett Street, but it's at Henry, which is a residential street full of lovely old brownstones, instead of Fourth Ave., which is a truck route that historically serviced an industrial area (ie Gowanus).

I'll tell you the truth, and I guess there is some personal preference here, but I wouldn't buy the Sackett/4th Ave place if the asking price were half of the current number. I have the down paymnent and the income, and I want to buy, but I wouldn't spend $350k on a place located on 4th Ave.

I just wouldn't find it habitable. I have mild asthma, and I know the kind of soot that gets deposited on windows when you live near a big street that has constant traffic, 24/7. That soot would come up into my lungs, and I just wouldn't subject myself to that. I don't think I would subject myself to it even if I didn't have asthma.

And call me old-fashioned, but I consider being able to the open the windows a necessity in a habitable abode.

Also, I don't think I'd be able to re-sell that 4th Ave place for as much as I'd paid for it (still assuming the $350k ask) for at least 10 or 15 years. That's my personal view of what's happening with the market, and you know there are going to be lots and lots of apartments available in a few years for affordable prices, and, again, many of them are not going to be located on 8-lane truck routes.

As for Zinka's reply, thanks, I didn't know this place was a few years old.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Slope11217
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 233
Member since: Nov 2008

Graffiti: Sorry, I'm not buying your apples to oranges comparison. Let's see why: (1) The Henry street apartment has only 1 bathroom, instead of 2. (2) the apartment on Sackett Street has outdoor space--a nice amenity that the apartment on Henry Street does not. (3) the Henry street apartment is more than 200 square feet SMALLER than the one on Sackett. Accordingly, the price per square foot for the Henry Street apartment is actually HIGHER than for the Sackett Street property ($673 for Sackett Street apartment vs. $756 for Henry Street apartment).

So, given that it's 20% smaller, is it any great surprise that it's 15% cheaper?

Also, I think you're really going a bit overboard with the "I consider being able to open the windows a necessity in a habitable abode" line. I've lived near 4th avenue for a few years now and the number of times I've noticed any soot whatsoever is exactly zero.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by GraffitiGrammarian
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008

Okay, Slope, but I don't buy your argument that a Fourth Ave location is a comp for a Henry Street/Cobble Hill location.

Fourth Avenue is not and never has been the Slope. It's an industrial district. You can't make the assumption that an apartment there is comparable, all else being equal, to an apartment in the heart of a long-established brownstone neighborhood.

It's a specious premise. It's like saying central Harlem is comp for the heart of the upper west side.

Just because some developer throws up a building and pays a broker and ad agency to create a lot of nonsensical claims about it doesn't make it so.

You have to start from the premise that you are dealing with two very unequal locations and neighborhoods that have nowhere the same fundamental value.

Personally, an extra bathroom doesn't make up for the difference between living directly on top of a major thoroughfare, versus living in a peaceful, clean established neighborhood. On Fourth Avenue, you're going to breath in all that truck exhaust for years and years. It's just not a reasonable comparison.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Slope11217
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 233
Member since: Nov 2008

Wait a minute--how was it MY premise that Fourth Avenue is a comp for Henry Street?????

YOU were the one to start this thread by posting about a Fourth Avenue property (on Sackett Street). I responded by posting a link to a comparable property that sold on Fourth Avenue (at the Crest). At that point, YOU brought the Henry Street property up and presented it as a comp. I did NOT bring the Henry Street property up. To recap, YOU brought it up, not I.

So, if the premise is "specious" (YOUR term), YOU only have to look at YOURSELF (the person who brought up the Henry Street apartment).

So stop telling me that it's "just not a reasonable comparison" when YOU were the one who tried to make it!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by GraffitiGrammarian
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 687
Member since: Jul 2008

No, it's implied that you think it's a comp. The very fact that you're saying the Fourth Ave place is worth more b/c there's a second bath implies that the other criteria (outside of bathrooms) is comparable.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Slope11217
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 233
Member since: Nov 2008

how can it be implied that i think it's a comp when you brought it up?????

and when did i say that 4th avenue is worth more than cobble hill?????? please point it out to me.

by the way, i mentioned far more than just the second bathroom. since you can't read, i'll relist them for you: (1) the 4th avenue apartment is 200 square feet bigger (2) it has a terrace that the henry steet apartment does not and (3) it's cheaper per square foot

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment