Miller Samuel - UWS Prices Down 20% Since August
Started by nyc10022
almost 18 years ago
Posts: 9868
Member since: Aug 2008
Discussion about
Slide 2... "Contract Prices on the Upper West Side have dropped by about 20% since August because of the credit crunch, says Jonathan Miller [Miller Samuel]" http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123015006369333335.html
I think prices are down 20% on the UWS because there are not as many closings occuring at 15 CPW, which brings down the median price.
Perhaps the mean you..err...mean?
SomaliPirate, this would be the exact argument nyc10022 used three months ago to discredit the increase in median prices. Which one is it nyc10022?
Cranky much?
Its neither actually. Based on the detail in prior analysis (which unfortunately isn't in this specific mention), I believe Samuel is talking comps. Thats what he said in the Nov report. If you did factor 15 CPW, it would make the number even worse.
Sorry to disappoint you.... perhaps you'll need to look for other opportunities for personal attacks.
"perhaps you'll need to look for other opportunities for personal attacks."
huh? How is my question regarded as a personal attack?
"I believe Samuel is talking comps"
Comps on what? The quote says UWS down 20% since August.
It has become abundantly clear that people that subscribe to the nyc10022 school are not interested in intelligent conversation about real estate. They are only interested in "I'm right...you're wrong" banter.
You can make any statement and spin it however you want to make yourself look right, and that's exactly what he and his camp do.
nyc10022: The sky is black.
everyone else: No, it is blue. And research, common sense and general consensus agree it is blue.
nyc10022: What I was saying was if you look at the sky from the inside of a tinted window, it appears black. I'm right. You're wrong as usual. Everyone knows the sky looks black when you look at it from tinted windows, which is generally what I said to begin with. I'm always right.
I wonder why nyc10022 started this thread?
I'm wondering more why you and oldbuyers just really, really, really don't want it to be true... or to be talked about at all.
Ok, no, I'm not really wondering.
;-)
happy new year, btw!
"I'm wondering more why you and oldbuyers just really, really, really don't want it to be true... or to be talked about at all."
If it is true, it is true. I really don't care. I was more interested in your interpretation of the truth, since it seems to change so often. Q3 median numbers were up and you pointed to 15 CPW as the reason and also claimed "mix issues" for the increase. Now, you are saying that Q4 median numbers are down but it has nothing to do with 15 CPW or "mix issues".
nyc10022, if you are going to spread doom and gloom, at least be accurate and, more importantly, consistent with your statements.
I think Miller was just sharing an anecdotal observation about the levels where deals seem to be getting done. Obviously, it's confusing when somebody who is best known for publishing formal statistical reports steps out of that role and makes an off-the-cuff remark. (I think the Miller-Samuel reports get misinterpreted and misused anyway, but that's a separate issue.)